Karnataka High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceConstitutional Law

Karnataka HC Upholds Recall Of Witness In 1965 Partition Deed Dispute, Finding Sale Deeds Prima Facie Relevant

SRI NARAYANAPPAv.SMT RATHNAMMA

Karnataka HC Upholds Recall Of Witness In 1965 Partition Deed Dispute, Finding Sale Deeds Prima Facie Relevant. SRI NARAYANAPPA vs SMT RATHNAMMA. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Trial Court's order allowing recall of PW-1 and production of additional documents, passed without detailed reasons, warrants interference under Articles 226/227.

The court held

The absence of detailed reasons in the Trial Court's order does not, by itself, warrant interference where the order is otherwise sustainable.

It also directed

The sale and confirmation deeds bear a prima facie nexus to the registered partition deed dated 25.10.1965, so their production and the recall of PW-1 for further examination-in-chief were justified. No grounds warranted interference.

The writ petition is dismissed and the Trial Court's order dated 15.07.2026 in O.S. No. 1247/2005 stands. The evidentiary value and effect of the documents are left to be determined at trial.

01Facts

The petitioners challenged the order dated 15.07.2026 of the I Additional Senior Civil Judge, Bengaluru Rural District, in O.S. No. 1247/2005, under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.

p. 5

The Trial Court allowed IA Nos. 1/2025, 2/2025 and 3/2025, which sought (i) recall of PW-1 for further examination-in-chief and (ii) production of additional documents.

The petitioners sought quashing of that order and dismissal of the plaintiff's applications under Order 18 Rule 17A r/w Section 151 CPC and Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC.

p. 4

The suit is for declaration and injunction.

¶ 2

The dispute concerns a registered partition deed dated 25.10.1965, a reference to which is traceable in the plaint.

¶ 6

The documents sought to be produced are stated to be sale deeds and confirmation deeds, relied upon to show that the partition deed was acted upon.

¶ 6

The petitioners contended that the Trial Court assigned no reasons, that the documents lacked pleadings and relevance, and that they ought not to have been admitted.

¶ 2, 2.1

The Trial Court's order contains no detailed reasons.

¶ 4

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Trial Court's order allowing recall of PW-1 and production of additional documents, passed without detailed reasons, warrants interference under Articles 226/227.

¶ 4 · ¶ 11

ii.2. Whether the sought-to-be-produced sale deeds and confirmation deeds have prima facie relevance and nexus to the controversy involving the registered partition deed dated 25.10.1965, so as to justify their production and recall of PW-1.

¶ 6, 7, 10

03Law Applied

The supervisory jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, under which interference is warranted only where an order is unsustainable.

¶ 4

At the stage of considering an application for production of documents, the Court need not examine evidentiary value or ultimate merits, and must confine itself to prima facie relevance and necessity for adjudication.

¶ 8

Whether documents establish the parties' assertions, were acted upon, and what evidentiary weight they carry are matters for trial.

¶ 9

The absence of detailed reasons does not by itself justify interference where the order is otherwise sustainable on independent examination of the record.

¶ 11

The provisions invoked in the applications (Order 18 Rule 17A r/w s.151 and Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC) are referred to only in the prayer; the judgment does not analyse them.

p. 4 · no citation for their substantive content

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151Section 7

04Reasoning

The Court noted the absence of reasons in the Trial Court's order but held that this alone did not warrant interference.

¶ 4

The Court independently examined the record and the grounds in the applications.

¶ 5, 11

The Court found that the sale and confirmation deeds were not wholly unrelated to the controversy, because they were relied upon to show that the registered partition deed of 25.10.1965 was acted upon and given effect.

¶ 6, 7

Applying the prima facie test, the Court found a nexus between the documents and the partition deed, which forms part of the suit's controversy. The Court treated the contention that the documents lacked pleadings as not supported in this context, since a reference to the partition deed is traceable in the plaint. The Court expressly refused to examine evidentiary value at this stage, reserving those questions for trial.

¶ 6, 8, 9, 10

05Holding

The absence of detailed reasons in the Trial Court's order does not, by itself, warrant interference where the order is otherwise sustainable.

¶ 11

The sale and confirmation deeds bear a prima facie nexus to the registered partition deed dated 25.10.1965, so their production and the recall of PW-1 for further examination-in-chief were justified. No grounds warranted interference.

¶ 7, 10, 12

The writ petition is dismissed and the Trial Court's order dated 15.07.2026 in O.S. No. 1247/2005 stands. The evidentiary value and effect of the documents are left to be determined at trial.

¶ 12 · ¶ 9
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SRI NARAYANAPPAvsSMT RATHNAMMA

Karnataka High Court · November 11, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment