01Facts
The petitioners are owners, purchasers, occupants and resort operators in the Moorkangudda block, Sakleshpura Taluk, Hassan District, claiming lands through auctions, grants, sale deeds, partitions, conversions and long possession.
¶ 7–14, 35–37, 45–53The Forest Department relies on Notification No. R.8806-Ft.43-15-6 dated 05.02.1920 issued under Section 4 of the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900 ("Regulation"), proposing to constitute about 7,938 acres 38 guntas as a State Forest.
¶ 15, 65.1–65.2The petitioners contend that a Government Order dated 11.01.1924 cancelled that proposal and that the Regional Commissioner's coordination meetings (10.06.2022, 08.09.2022) directed withdrawal of forest cases.
¶ 17–19, 49, 79.6–79.10Despite this, the Forest Department passed an eviction order dated 26.07.2022 under Section 64A of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963 ("1963 Act"), issued a Section 5 proclamation dated 19.07.2023/09.11.2023 after a Forest Settlement Officer was appointed on 19.12.2022, and issued further notices in 2024–2025.
¶ 15, 29–30, 56, 65.59The State contends the 1924 order related only to a separate acquisition notification (R.8808-Ft.43-15-7) and that the 1920 notification remains operative.
¶ 65.20–65.22No final notification under Section 17 of the Regulation has been identified.
¶ 70.2, 70.502Issues
i.1. Whether the Section 4 notification dated 05.02.1920 (R.8806-Ft.43-15-6) remained operative, or was withdrawn/cancelled by the Government Order dated 11.01.1924.
¶ 67(i), 69.36ii.2. Whether the absence of a final notification under Section 17 of the Regulation precludes the State from asserting forest status or taking action.
¶ 67(ii), 70.38iii.3. Whether the repeal of the Regulation by the 1963 Act affected the 1920 notification and proceedings under it.
¶ 67(iii), 71.20iv.4. Whether the prolonged delay and abandonment render the proceedings unsustainable.
¶ 67(iv), 72.40–72.42v.5. Whether the grants, auctions, registered instruments, revenue entries and conversion orders confer enforceable rights.
¶ 67(v), 73.62vi.6. Whether petitioners must establish that their lands fall within the 1920 notification boundaries.
¶ 67(vi), 74.23vii.7. Whether writ jurisdiction is maintainable despite statutory alternative remedies.
¶ 67(vii), 75.30viii.8. Whether Section 64A of the 1963 Act applies to the petition schedule lands and whether the proceedings were initiated by competent officers in compliance with its procedure.
¶ 67(viii), 76.44–76.479.9. Whether the appointment of the Forest Settlement Officer, proclamations, notices and inquiry complied with the 1963 Act.
¶ 67(ix), 77.28–77.2910.10. Whether orders under Section 14 are subject to appeal under Section 16 and warrant writ interference.
¶ 67(x), 78.25–78.2611.11. Whether the Regional Commissioner's proceedings have binding effect.
¶ 67(xi), 79.2212.12. Whether petitioners have established enforceable individual rights warranting relief.
¶ 67(xii), 80.5603Law Applied
Sections 4 and 17 of the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900: a Section 4 notification only proposes a State Forest, the forest status arises on a Section 17 final notification, and the Government may drop the proposal.
¶ 69.7–69.9, 70.9–70.10Sections 4, 5, 6, 7, 11–17 and 64A of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963: a Section 4(1) notification is the foundation for Chapter II proceedings, and Section 64A(1) requires land within the listed categories, a Forest Officer not below Assistant Conservator rank, and a mandatory hearing.
¶ 70.12, 76.12, 77.8–77.9, 76.35Section 117 of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963 (repeal and savings): savings preserve only actions still in force on commencement and do not revive a withdrawn proposal.
¶ 71.10–71.12The two-stage process under the Regulation and the bar on Forest Officers conducting settlement inquiries, as laid down in M/s. Bharat Parikh & Co. (W.P. 22514/2018) and Emerald Haven Estates (W.P. 41187/2016).
¶ 63.50, 63.53–63.55, 70.13Reasonable time for issuance of final notification, as laid down in V. Sampangi Ramaiah (2012) and Girish H.E. (2013), and the reasonable-period doctrine in Joint Collector Ranga Reddy v. D. Narsing Rao and Union of India v. Citi Bank.
¶ 72.2–72.13Maintainability versus entertainability of writ petitions, as laid down in Godrej Sara Lee and Radha Krishan Industries.
¶ 75.7–75.8Article 300A of the Constitution of India and the limits of writ directions, as laid down in Kirloskar Pneumatic and Manish Goel.
¶ 72.34, 80.16–80.17Provisions in the judgment · 29 · Linked ones open on LawLens
KARNATAKA FOREST ACT, 1963 26 provisions
Section 2Section 3Section 4Section 5Section 6Section 7Section 8Section 9Section 10Section 11Section 12Section 13Section 14Section 15Section 16Section 17Section 18Section 19Section 20Section 23Section 24Section 64Section 73Section 104Section 109Section 117Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam, 1980 Section 2
Indian Forest Act, 1927 Section 5
Customs Act,1962 Section 27
04Reasoning
The court examined the contemporaneous Government records (File No. 296 of 1922; Entries IC 4236.8 and IC 4239 dated 11.01.1924) and held that Entry 271 dropped the proposal to constitute the entire Block, while Entry 272 only withdrew acquisition of 68 acres 33 guntas; the State's contrary reading was rejected as ignoring the principal decision and its context.
¶ 69.16–69.24, 69.36Because the proposal was dropped and no Section 17 notification issued, the Block never became a State Forest or reserved forest.
¶ 70.11, 70.34The court held that Section 117 of the 1963 Act could not revive the withdrawn proposal, and that Section 6 restrictions depend on a subsisting notification and a triggering proclamation, which were absent.
¶ 70.15–70.19, 71.12–71.13, 73.20–73.22Independently, the court found that nearly a century of inaction, with no settlement steps between 1923 and 2022, was unreasonable and amounted to abandonment.
¶ 72.16–72.18, 72.25On writ maintainability, the court held the jurisdictional challenge fell within recognised exceptions, while appeals under Section 16 lie only against orders on claims, not proclamations or notices.
¶ 75.13–75.15, 75.30On Section 64A, the Respondents failed to show parcel-wise that the lands fell within a listed category, and the Deputy Conservator's order rested on the withdrawn notification; the Range Forest Officer lacked rank, and no pre-eviction hearing was shown.
¶ 76.17–76.31, 76.35–76.37The Forest Settlement Officer's proceedings lacked the Section 4(1) foundation, since the 19.12.2022 appointment order cannot substitute for that notification.
¶ 77.9–77.11, 77.14Regional Commissioner's minutes were held not to bind the State Government.
¶ 79.11–79.13Revenue entries and grants were held not to be invalidated by the 1920 notification, but title, extent and boundaries were left undecided.
¶ 73.58–73.65, 74.22–74.2305Holding
The court holds that the 05.02.1920 notification, R.8806-Ft.43-15-6, was dropped by the Government Order of 11.01.1924 (IC 4236.8), has been abandoned and lapsed, and has no operative effect to found proceedings under the 1963 Act against the petitioners or their lands.
¶ 69.36, 81.1.1, 81.29(ii)The 1963 Act notices of 04.06.2024, 28.08.2024, 10.09.2024, 20.09.2024 and 18.10.2024 (W.P. 29656/2024) are quashed, and the Respondents shall not disturb possession on the strength of the 1920 notification.
¶ 80.25–80.26, 81.29(iii)The order dated 26.07.2022 and notice dated 18.07.2023 (W.P. 16251/2023, W.P. 19980/2023) are quashed, and the 09.11.2023 proclamation is quashed as to the petitioners, with articles seized on 18.07.2023 still held to be returned within four weeks.
¶ 80.30–80.35, 81.29(iv)–(v)The 19.07.2023 proclamations and 2025 notices (W.P. 29690/2025) are quashed as to the petitioners' lands, and the enquiry/penal action is barred on the 1920 notification.
¶ 80.40–80.42, 81.29(vi)The proclamations, notices and consequential inquiry/orders in W.P. 33767/2025 are quashed as against the petitioners, with the State bound by its statement not to proceed against the admitted claims.
¶ 78.20, 81.29(vii)The 30.06.2025 notice (W.P. 700/2026) is quashed.
¶ 80.52, 81.29(viii)The order dated 24.10.2025 in W.P. 29656/2024 is neither set aside nor upheld, and remedies against it remain open.
¶ 78.15–78.16Title, extent, boundaries and validity of grants are expressly left open, and the State may act afresh under Sections 3 and 4(1) of the 1963 Act or Section 64A after compliance with the prescribed procedure.
¶ 81.2, 81.29(ix)The Principal Secretary, Forest, Environment and Ecology Department is directed to undertake a State-wide scientific identification exercise of unnotified forest and forest-like areas within nine months, with reports listed for 12.03.2027.
¶ 81.15–81.25, 81.29(xiv)Interim orders merge in the judgment and cease to operate, and there is no order as to costs.
¶ 81.29(x)–(xii)Original Court PDF
SRI. STEPHEN K.J.vsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
