01Facts
The petitioners alleged that respondent No. 12 was constructing a commercial building on property in Sy. No. 36/A, Munaganahalli Village, within the prohibited area or tank bed of Munaganahalli Tank. They further alleged that he had obtained a survey sketch by misstating the property boundaries and that their representations to the authorities had not resulted in effective action.
p. 5Respondent No. 12 disputed the allegations and characterised the petition as motivated by personal and political animosity.
p. 6The State submitted that a district-level committee for the sustainable development, protection and management of lakes had been constituted by Government Order dated 6 June 2026.
p. 702Issues
i.Whether respondent No. 12 had constructed within the prohibited area or tank bed of Munaganahalli Tank, requiring consideration by the competent committee.
pp. 6–8ii.Whether the petitioners’ complaint should be referred to that committee for consideration and appropriate action.
pp. 7–803Law Applied
The Court considered the petitioners’ allegation of a violation of the Karnataka Tank Conservation and Development Authority Act, 2014, as referred to in the judgment.
p. 6It also relied on the Government Order dated 6 June 2026, which constituted a committee to address the sustainable development, protection and management of lakes and to consider questions concerning illegal construction in prohibited areas.
p. 7The judgment cites no particular statutory provision or precedent and does not determine the substantive legal limits of the prohibited area.
04Reasoning
Given the allegations concerning construction in or near the tank bed and the denial by respondent No. 12, the Court considered that the factual question required examination by the designated committee rather than determination in the writ petition.
pp. 6–8In light of the committee’s stated remit, the Court directed the Deputy Commissioner to place the complaint before it. The committee must give respondent No. 12 notice, consider the parties’ contentions and pass appropriate orders; any further action must be taken in accordance with law.
p. 805Holding
The petition was disposed of without a finding on whether the construction was unlawful.
pp. 8–9The Deputy Commissioner was directed to refer the petitioners’ complaint to the committee, which must issue notice to respondent No. 12, consider the contentions and pass orders within three months of receiving a certified copy of the judgment. Any follow-up action is to be taken by the designated officer in accordance with law.
pp. 8–9Original Court PDF
SRI NAVEEN RvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
