Karnataka High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceProperty and Real Estate Law

Karnataka HC Refuses To Reopen Final Decree, Upholds Sale Deed Draft In Joint Development Dispute

SRI.DHANPALv.ALTHAF,

Karnataka HC Refuses To Reopen Final Decree, Upholds Sale Deed Draft In Joint Development Dispute. SRI.DHANPAL vs ALTHAF,. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the appellants/judgment-debtors have made out any ground warranting interference with the order dated 03.09.2026 in Com.Ex. No. 908/2025.

The court held

The judgment-debtors identified no recital in the rectified draft dated 30.07.2026 that enlarges the decree or confers a right not recognised in it. Their objections sought to reopen finally decided matters rather than to show a demonstrable inconsistency with the decree.

It also directed

The Court found no error warranting interference.

The appeal was dismissed and the order dated 03.09.2026 in Com.Ex. No. 908/2025 was confirmed. No order as to costs was made, and the pending I.A. was disposed of.

01Facts

The decree-holder (Althaf) sued for specific performance of a Joint Development Agreement dated 08.05.2013 in Com.O.S. No. 4029/2017. The Commercial Court decreed the suit on 22.05.2023, directing the judgment-debtors to execute a sale deed within two months, failing which execution could proceed through a Court Commissioner, and granted a permanent injunction against alienation.

¶ 3, 4

The Commercial Appeal No. 265/2023 was dismissed on 03.07.2025, and SLP (C) No. 27429/2025 was dismissed on 14.10.2025.

¶ 4, 16

The decree-holder filed Com.Ex. No. 908/2025 on 18.08.2025 under Order XXI Rule 11 CPC.

¶ 5

The decree-holder filed a draft sale deed on 10.06.2026. On the judgment-debtors' objections under Order XXI Rule 34 CPC, the Executing Court on 15.07.2026 directed correction of boundaries and deletion of references to undivided share and covered car parking.

¶ 6, 17

A rectified draft was filed on 30.07.2026, and fresh objections were raised on 01.08.2026, with written submissions on 06.08.2026.

¶ 6, 7

The judgment-debtors contended that the draft exceeded the decree and the JDA, describing a ground-plus-three-floor, eight-flat development on a 30 ft. x 50 ft. portion for ₹1,42,00,000, and objected to recitals concerning pending O.S. No. 402/2017.

¶ 3(a), 8, 12, 13

Earlier, the judgment-debtors' application under Order XXVI Rules 18A and 26 CPC for a commissioner to measure the built-up area was dismissed on 18.02.2026 and not challenged.

¶ 20

On 03.09.2026 the Executing Court overruled the objections, accepted the second rectified draft, and imposed costs of ₹2,000.

¶ 9, 10

The judgment-debtors appealed under Section 13(1-A) of the Commercial Courts Act.

¶ 11

02Issues

i.1. Whether the appellants/judgment-debtors have made out any ground warranting interference with the order dated 03.09.2026 in Com.Ex. No. 908/2025.

¶ 15

ii.2. Whether, at the execution stage, the judgment-debtors can reopen the rights flowing from the decree, which has attained finality.

¶ 16

iii.3. Whether the rectified draft sale deed enlarges the decree or the JDA by including recitals on the extent of the property, consideration, or pending O.S. No. 402/2017.

¶ 18, 19, 22

03Law Applied

Section 13(1-A) of the Commercial Courts Act is the statutory basis for the appeal.

¶ 1

Order XXI Rules 11 and 34 CPC govern execution applications and objections to the execution of decrees.

¶ 5, 6

The executing court's enquiry is confined to whether the draft instrument conforms to the decree, not whether the decree itself is open to reconsideration.

¶ 16

A decree attains finality once the appeal is dismissed and the SLP is dismissed, so the judgment-debtors cannot reopen its rights at execution.

¶ 16, 22

Under Order XXVI Rules 18A and 26 CPC, an unchallenged dismissal of a commissioner application bars re-agitation of the same measurement issue.

¶ 20

The judgment cites no precedent for these propositions.

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Commercial Courts Act, 2015 Section 13

04Reasoning

The objections were not ignored. The Executing Court had already acted on the first objections by directing correction of boundaries and deletion of the undivided-share and car-parking recitals, and it had heard the later objections and written submissions.

¶ 17, 21

Applying the finality principle, the judgment-debtors could not use the execution stage to question the decree, which had been upheld in appeal and by the Supreme Court.

¶ 16

The rectified draft identifies the southern 30 ft. x 50 ft. portion (1500 sq. ft.) with eight two-BHK flats, and expressly refers to the northern 600 sq. ft. portion as belonging to the judgment-debtors. No material showed conveyance beyond the suit schedule.

¶ 19

A recital noting the pendency of O.S. No. 402/2017 did not adjudicate the rights in that suit, which must be decided on their own merits.

¶ 19

The attempt to reopen the extent and nature of construction, which had been put up on the sanctioned plan dated 28.09.2013 and had already been scrutinised, was rejected as unsupported by material showing departure from the decree.

¶ 20, 21

05Holding

The judgment-debtors identified no recital in the rectified draft dated 30.07.2026 that enlarges the decree or confers a right not recognised in it. Their objections sought to reopen finally decided matters rather than to show a demonstrable inconsistency with the decree.

¶ 22

The Court found no error warranting interference.

¶ 23

The appeal was dismissed and the order dated 03.09.2026 in Com.Ex. No. 908/2025 was confirmed. No order as to costs was made, and the pending I.A. was disposed of.

¶ 23
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SRI.DHANPALvsALTHAF,

Karnataka High Court · October 08, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment