01Facts
The petitioner, K. Sudhakar Reddy, filed Commercial O.S. No. 3/2021 before the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Raichur, seeking recovery of ₹50,14,17,195 with 18% interest. The claim arose from a 1989 contract for construction of SBC Distributary No. 21-A.
¶ 2The Respondents (Government/KBJNL officials) filed a written statement denying the claim. The petitioner led evidence as PW1, and his cross-examination was repeatedly deferred at the Respondents' request. It was finally closed on 17.10.2022.
¶ 3DW1's cross-examination was completed on 29.03.2025, after which the petitioner filed written arguments and the matter was posted for the Respondents' arguments, which were adjourned at their request.
¶ 4The Respondents then filed I.A. No. IV under Order XVIII Rule 17 r/w Section 151 CPC to recall PW1 and permit further cross-examination, citing documents that had surfaced. The petitioner opposed.
¶ 4, 9The Trial Court allowed the application on 26.09.2025, recalled the order of 17.10.2022, imposed costs of ₹10,000, and directed completion of further cross-examination within one or two hearings, failing which the right would be forfeited. The petitioner challenged this order under Article 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 1, 502Issues
i.1. Whether a party to a suit may invoke Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC to recall a witness for further examination or cross-examination.
¶ 12ii.2. Whether the Trial Court was justified in entertaining I.A. No. IV and recalling PW1 for further cross-examination in a commercial suit, absent special circumstances.
¶ 15–1703Law Applied
Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC permits the Court, at any stage, to recall a witness and put questions the Court thinks fit; it is an enabling provision for the Court and not for the parties.
¶ 12Relying on Shubhkaran Singh v. Abhayraj Singh (2025 SCC OnLine SC 1028), a witness cannot be recalled at a party's instance for examination, cross-examination, or re-examination.
¶ 13In K. Bharathamma v. Bandaru Sakku Bai (2026 SCC OnLine SC 1484), Order XVIII Rule 17 and Section 151 CPC are to be used sparingly, only in compelling circumstances; they cannot be used to fill evidentiary gaps, to improve evidence, or merely because no prejudice would result.
¶ 14, 5.7–5.9, 6.2–6.3, 7.5The Bombay High Court's decision in Balkrishna Shivappa Shetty holds that Order XVIII Rule 17 does not empower recall for cross-examination by either party, consistent with K.K. Velusamy, Gayathri v. M. Girish, Vadiraj Naggappa Vernekar, and Ram Rati v. Mange Ram.
¶ 14Suits under the Commercial Courts Act, read with the CPC, must be decided expeditiously.
¶ 17Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
04Reasoning
The Respondents' application sought precisely what Order XVIII Rule 17 does not permit: recall of a party's witness at a party's instance for further cross-examination.
¶ 12–13The Trial Court had not examined the provision and had allowed the application only because the petitioner would suffer no prejudice and the recall might help adjudication. The Supreme Court in Bharathamma rejected "no prejudice" as a sufficient ground.
¶ 14–15The Trial Court did not identify any special circumstances justifying the recall, despite acknowledging that such applications must be entertained only with caution. The Respondents' stated reason, the surfacing of documents, was not treated as a compelling justification.
¶ 16The suit was filed in 2021 and was pending. The Respondents had already cross-examined PW1 and had repeatedly sought adjournments, and the Trial Court had overlooked the commercial suit's mandate for expeditious disposal.
¶ 4, 17–1805Holding
A party cannot invoke Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC to recall a witness for further cross-examination, and the Trial Court erred in entertaining I.A. No. IV in a commercial suit without special circumstances.
¶ 12–18The Writ Petition was allowed, and the order dated 26.09.2025 in Com. O.S. No. 3/2021 on I.A. No. IV was set aside.
¶ 19–20Original Court PDF
K SUDHAKAR REDDYvsKRISHNA BHAGAYA JALA NIGAM LIMITED REPRESENTED BY ITS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
