01Facts
The first respondent’s father, a watchman at a private aided pre-university college, died in service on 5 June 2015.
pp. 3–6The first respondent applied for compassionate appointment on 12 December 2015. A later proposal to appoint him as a Second Division Assistant (SDA) was rejected on 18 January 2024 because he had possessed only an SSLC qualification when he applied; the required qualification for the SDA post was PUC. By the time the proposal was considered, he had obtained PUC. The Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal set aside the rejection and directed the authorities to consider his case, if otherwise eligible under the Rules, and provide compassionate appointment within three months. The State challenged that order before the High Court.
pp. 3–602Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal’s direction to consider the respondent’s case for compassionate appointment, if otherwise eligible under the Rules, warranted interference by the High Court.
p. 6ii.2. Whether the State had established a basis to quash the Tribunal’s order.
p. 703Law Applied
The Tribunal relied on the principle in N.C. Santhosh v. State of Karnataka, (2020) 7 SCC 617, that the norms prevailing on the date the application for compassionate appointment is considered should govern the claim.
p. 5It also referred to the Karnataka Pre-University (Academic Registration, Administration and Grant-in-Aid, etc.) Rules, 2006, concerning eligibility for grant-in-aid posts in private aided pre-university colleges.
p. 504Reasoning
The High Court considered the Tribunal’s order innocuous because it directed the authorities only to assess the respondent’s claim under the applicable Rules and subject to his being otherwise eligible.
p. 6Since the order required lawful consideration rather than automatic appointment, the Court found the State’s challenge to that direction unjustified.
p. 605Holding
The High Court rejected the writ petition and declined to set aside the Tribunal’s order.
p. 7It extended the Tribunal’s three-month period for compliance by a further six weeks from the date of the High Court’s order.
p. 7Original Court PDF
THE STATE OF KARNATAKAvsMANJUNATH GOVANNAVAR
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
