01Facts
The workman, Sri Bhasasabi, was a driver at Chintamani Depot of the Corporation.
¶ 3On 20.11.2008, while operating Route No. 52 in bus KA-07/F-880, he replaced a flattened front tyre during the night.
¶ 3, 9He did not cover the remaining 60 km of the journey between 22:00 hours on 20.11.2008 and 06:00 hours on 21.11.2008.
¶ 3, 9Articles of charge dated 22.12.2008 alleged (i) failure to complete the uncovered journey despite the Depot Manager's request, causing revenue loss, and (ii) instigating workers to protest and blocking the depot entrance from 14:00 to 15:00 hours on 21.11.2008, delaying passenger buses.
¶ 3-4The workman's defence to charge (i) was that he had not slept during the previous night due to the tyre replacement.
¶ 10The Enquiry Officer held both charges proved.
¶ 5The disciplinary authority, by order dated 23.08.2010, imposed reduction of basic pay by two stages with cumulative effect.
¶ 5The workman raised an industrial dispute (I.D. No. 344/2012).
¶ 5The Industrial Tribunal, Bengaluru, by award dated 03.02.2020, set aside the penalty, while accepting that the domestic enquiry was fair and proper.
¶ 5, 6(ii)The Corporation challenged the award under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 1, 502Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in holding that the Corporation failed to prove Charge No. 1 (non-completion of the 60 km journey), in light of the workman's explanation that he had not slept.
¶ 6(i), 7(i), 10, 12ii.2. Whether the charge of instigating workers to protest and block the depot entrance was proved, in the absence of documentary or oral evidence.
¶ 6(ii), 7(ii), 11, 12iii.3. Whether the Enquiry Officer's findings were perverse, such that the Tribunal's setting aside of the penalty warrants interference under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 12, 1303Law Applied
The writ court's supervisory jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution is not to be exercised absent an error or illegality in the Tribunal's findings.
¶ 13A disciplinary finding resting on no evidence, or contrary to the material on record, is perverse and may be set aside.
¶ 12The burden of proving each charge rests on the employer, which must establish the charge through documentary or oral evidence.
¶ 11, 12A reasonable explanation for non-performance of duty, namely a driver's need for rest to safely operate a public-service vehicle, may defeat the charge.
¶ 10No statutory provisions other than Articles 226 and 227 and no precedents were expressly cited in the judgment.
04Reasoning
On Charge No. 1, the Court accepted as undisputed that the workman replaced the tyre during the night and could not complete the journey.
¶ 9The Court accepted his explanation that he had not slept and that driving in that condition would endanger the travelling public, and therefore held that the Corporation had failed to prove the charge.
¶ 10On Charge No. 2, the Court noted the admission that the workman was not present at the protest and had left for home that morning.
¶ 11The Corporation produced no documents and examined no witnesses to show that the workman instigated the protest, either before the Enquiry Officer or in the proceedings.
¶ 11In the absence of both documentary and oral evidence, the Enquiry Officer's finding on Charge No. 2 was erroneous.
¶ 12Having found the findings on both charges unsupported by the record, the Court upheld the Tribunal's conclusion that the findings were perverse and contrary to the material on record.
¶ 12Because the Tribunal's conclusion was not shown to be erroneous, no ground for supervisory interference arose.
¶ 1305Holding
Issue 1 is answered in the affirmative in favour of the workman: Charge No. 1 was not proved, given the accepted explanation of non-rest.
¶ 10Issue 2 is answered in the affirmative in favour of the workman: Charge No. 2 was not proved, as no documentary or oral evidence established instigation.
¶ 11-12Issue 3: The Enquiry Officer's findings were perverse, and the Tribunal's award was not vitiated by any error or illegality warranting interference under Articles 226 and 227.
¶ 12-13The writ petition was dismissed, and the Tribunal's award dated 03.02.2020, setting aside the penalty of reduction of basic pay by two stages with cumulative effect, stands.
¶ 5, 13Original Court PDF
THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLERvsSRI BHASASABI
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
