01Facts
The petitioners, initially appointed as Lecturers in the Department of Pre-University Education, were permanently transferred to the posts of District Tribal Welfare Officers under Rule 16(a)(ii) of the Karnataka Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977, by orders dated 19 March 2015 and 25 May 2016.
pp. 3–5Respondents 1 and 2, who entered the District Tribal Welfare Officer cadre in 2018, challenged the petitioners’ transfers before the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal in 2022.
pp. 3–5The Tribunal rejected their claim that the petitioners did not hold equivalent posts but set aside the transfers on the ground that the petitioners had not passed the prescribed departmental examinations.
pp. 10–11The petitioners challenged that decision under Article 227 of the Constitution
pp. 10–1102Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioners’ permanent transfers were invalid because they had not passed departmental examinations prescribed for the posts of District Tribal Welfare Officer
pp. 11–15ii.2. Whether respondents 1 and 2 could maintain their challenge to the petitioners’ transfers despite entering the cadre later and bringing their applications after a substantial delay
pp. 15–1803Law Applied
Rule 16(a)(ii) of the Karnataka Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977, permits appointment by permanent transfer, subject to the applicable conditions; its proviso requires an officer to have passed the departmental examinations prescribed for the post to which transfer is sought
p. 11The Karnataka Civil Services (Service and Kannada Language Examinations) Rules, 1974 govern prescribed service examinations; the court treated the existence of an examination requirement for the relevant post at the time of transfer as material
pp. 11–15Under P.S. Sadasivaswamy v. State of Tamil Nadu, (1975) 1 SCC 152, courts may refuse relief where a claimant delays unreasonably and seeks to unsettle a settled service position
pp. 17–18Union of India v. N. Murugesan, (2022) 2 SCC 25, explains the related doctrines of delay, laches and acquiescence, including the relevance of delay, conduct and prejudice
pp. 18–20The court also cited Bichitrānanda Behera v. State of Orissa, (2023 LIVELAW (SC) 883), for the significance of delay and laches in service matters
p. 2104Reasoning
The court held that the Tribunal had erred in finding that the petitioners failed to pass examinations prescribed for the District Tribal Welfare Officer post.
pp. 12–15The materials showed that, after creation of the Scheduled Tribes Welfare Department, no departmental examinations had been prescribed for that post when the petitioners were transferred; the 2020 communication merely directed adoption of examinations used in the Social Welfare Department.
pp. 12–15The court also noted that respondents 1 and 2 entered the cadre after the petitioners and challenged the transfers only in 2022, notwithstanding their own transfer in 2018.
pp. 15–18Their explanation that they learned of the petitioners’ transfers only on publication of a provisional seniority list was not accepted; the court found their challenge affected by delay and laches
pp. 15–18The Tribunal’s finding that the petitioners held equivalent posts was not challenged and was left undisturbed.
pp. 10–11, 2105Holding
The writ petition was partly allowed.
pp. 21–22The court quashed the Tribunal’s finding that the petitioners had not passed the prescribed departmental examinations and set aside the Tribunal’s decision quashing the petitioners’ transfer orders and the related promotion notification.
pp. 21–22The finding that the petitioners held equivalent posts was confirmed, and consequential benefits were granted, with three months allowed for compliance
pp. 21–22Original Court PDF
SRI.K.R. RAJAKUMARvsSRI SHIVKUMAR C
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
