Madras High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceContract Law

Madras HC Dismisses Property Appeals in Full as Dead Owner's Heirs Stay Off Record, Buyers Cannot Carry On Alone

D. Chellakumar(Died)v.V.G.P. Rajadas,

Madras HC Dismisses Property Appeals in Full as Dead Owner's Heirs Stay Off Record, Buyers Cannot Carry On Alone. D. Chellakumar(Died) vs V.G.P. Rajadas,. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the substituted appellants, as pendente lite purchasers, can continue the second appeals in the absence of the deceased plaintiff's Class-I legal heirs, and whether the appeals abated in toto.

The court held

Both second appeals (S.A. 561 and 562 of 2020) stand abated in their entirety. The substituted appellants could not continue them in isolation because the right to sue did not survive to them alone and the cause of action is indivisible, which would otherwise produce conflicting decrees.

It also directed

The Court did not decide the merits or the framed substantial questions of law.

Both second appeals are dismissed as abated, without costs. The connected miscellaneous petitions are closed. The concurrent judgments of the trial court (2010) and the first appellate court (2018) therefore remain undisturbed.

01Facts

The suit properties originally belonged to Ebenezar Nadar and were gifted to Dharmakkan Nadar (father of the plaintiff, D. Chellakumar) in 1969. The plaintiff claimed title by intestate succession.

¶ 2

On 21.01.1978 he executed a registered power of attorney (Ex. B1) in favour of V.G. Santhosam (D-6), a partner of M/s V.G. Panneerdas & Co. (D-7), a registered partnership firm.

¶ 2.1

The plaintiff cancelled it on 21.01.2003, the cancellation being registered on 20.08.2003.

¶ 2.2

The defendants contended that a sale agreement dated 25.03.1975 (Ex. B3) and a stamped receipt dated 21.01.1978 (Ex. B5) showed full payment of ₹21,200, so the power of attorney was coupled with interest and irrevocable.

¶ 3.3–3.6, 9–10

The plaintiff denied executing Ex. B3 and Ex. B5.

¶ 2.5, 39.2

Alienations were made to purchasers, including Lisi Edward, Stella, Stephen and Subbaiah Konar (O.S. 334/2003).

¶ 2.3

In O.S. 423/2003 the plaintiff challenged a 1999 power of attorney in favour of Arul Raj and the resulting sales, and the defendants (Royan family and Kalaiselvan) relied on those sales.

¶ 4.2–4.4, 4.8–4.9

The trial court dismissed both suits on 05.04.2010, holding the power of attorney irrevocable under Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 and that possession had continued for over 30 years.

¶ 10–16, 20

The first appellate court dismissed A.S. 8 and 9 of 2013 on 20.03.2018.

¶ 21, 30–33

The plaintiff filed Second Appeals (SA) 561 and 562 of 2020 and died on 06.05.2021.

¶ 34, 52

His class-I heirs were not brought on record despite the Court's order of 25.10.2025, which required their impleadment by 13.11.2025.

¶ 42–43

Narayanan and Paichmuthu, who had purchased portions of the property from the plaintiff, were substituted as appellants.

¶ 36, 43

The respondents argued that the appeals had abated and could not continue.

¶ 37.9–37.12

02Issues

i.1. Whether the substituted appellants, as pendente lite purchasers, can continue the second appeals in the absence of the deceased plaintiff's Class-I legal heirs, and whether the appeals abated in toto.

¶ 40–41, 74

ii.2. Whether the right to sue survived in favour of the substituted purchasers alone, or whether it devolved only partially, and whether the claim is divisible.

¶ 48–50

iii.3. Whether the abatement of the appeals in respect of the unrepresented portions would lead to conflicting or inconsistent decrees.

¶ 53–65

iv.4. Whether the power of attorney dated 21.01.1978 is coupled with interest and irrevocable; whether Ex. B3 and Ex. B5 are proved; and whether the plaintiff's appeals are maintainable given the sale to the substituted appellants (framed as substantial questions of law, admitted but not decided).

¶ 35, 74

03Law Applied

The Court applied Order XXII CPC, particularly Rules 1, 3, 9, 10 and 11, which provide that a suit does not abate if the right to sue survives, that legal representatives must be brought on record within time, and that a pendente lite assignee may continue the suit with leave of the Court.

¶ 44–45

"Legal representative" is defined under Section 2(11) CPC.

¶ 58

The "right to sue" means the right to pursue the same relief the deceased asserted, per Phool Rani v. Naubat Rai Ahluwalia (1973) 1 SCC 688.

¶ 47

Under Sardar Amarjit Singh Kalra v. Pramod Gupta (2003) 3 SCC 272, abatement of one party in a joint and indivisible decree or common cause of action is fatal to the entire appeal, to avoid conflicting decrees.

¶ 59

State of Punjab v. Nathu Ram, AIR 1962 SC 89, and Suresh Chandra v. Parasram, 2025 (5) CTC 196, refine this test: an appeal does not proceed where its success would produce a decree irreconcilable with a final decree, and a decree is inconsistent only where the two are mutually irreconcilable.

¶ 60, 62

Hemareddi v. Ramachandra (2019) 6 SCC 756 and Budh Ram v. Bansi (2010) 11 SCC 476 apply these principles.

¶ 67–68

Sharadamma v. Mohammed Pyrejan (2016) 1 SCC 730 and K. Naina Mohamed v. A.M. Vasudevan Chettiar (2010) 7 SCC 603 recognise a pendente lite assignee's right to continue where the entire subject-matter has devolved on the assignee, and were held inapplicable to partial assignment.

¶ 66

Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Indian Contract Act, 1872 Section 202

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100Section 2

04Reasoning

The Court held that the right to sue survived the plaintiff's death because the dispute concerned proprietary title and the validity of a power of attorney.

¶ 49

However, the right did not vest in the substituted appellants alone. It split along property lines, since they purchased only part of the suit schedule and the plaintiff retained substantial unalienated extents, including item 1 of O.S. 423 (2.11 acres in S. No. 40/1A) and unpurchased portions in O.S. 334.

¶ 50, 54–56, 66

The sale deeds to the substituted appellants themselves recognised the plaintiff's earlier alienations.

¶ 57

The children, who were the Class-I heirs entitled to represent the unpurchased estate, were not brought on record despite the 25.10.2025 direction.

¶ 42–43, 71

The Court treated the cause of action as indivisible: the validity of the power of attorney, its irrevocability, and the consequences of its cancellation determine every alienation under it.

¶ 63

Allowing the appeals in favour of the purchasers alone would have reversed the decree for their items while leaving the decree intact for the rest, producing irreconcilable decrees on the same power of attorney.

¶ 64–65, 73

The Court therefore refused to adjudicate the merits, including the substantial questions of law, because it lacked the necessary parties before it.

¶ 73–74

05Holding

Both second appeals (S.A. 561 and 562 of 2020) stand abated in their entirety. The substituted appellants could not continue them in isolation because the right to sue did not survive to them alone and the cause of action is indivisible, which would otherwise produce conflicting decrees.

¶ 64–72, 74

The Court did not decide the merits or the framed substantial questions of law.

¶ 73–74

Both second appeals are dismissed as abated, without costs. The connected miscellaneous petitions are closed. The concurrent judgments of the trial court (2010) and the first appellate court (2018) therefore remain undisturbed.

¶ 75
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

D. Chellakumar(Died)vsV.G.P. Rajadas,

Madras High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment