Madras High CourtCriminal LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Madras HC Acquits Car Driver Convicted Over Scooter Rider's Death, Citing Negative Blood Test And Non-Working Signals

ABDUL KHAIYUMv.INSPECTOR OF POLICE

Madras HC Acquits Car Driver Convicted Over Scooter Rider's Death, Citing Negative Blood Test And Non-Working Signals. ABDUL KHAIYUM vs INSPECTOR OF POLICE. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the prosecution established that the appellant drove under the influence of alcohol, so as to commit an offence under s.185 MV Act.

The court held

The prosecution failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt either intoxication under s.185 MV Act or the rash act and requisite knowledge under s.304 Part II IPC.

It also directed

The Court held that the appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt. The appeal is allowed. The conviction and sentence dated 13.12.2023 in S.C. No.85 of 2022 are set aside, and the appellant is acquitted of the charges under s.185 MV Act and s.304 Part II IPC. The fine amount is to be refunded, and any bail bond stands discharged. The appellant voluntarily deposited Rs.5,00,000 in the bank account of the deceased's mother, A. Uma, under an undertaking given in Crl.O.P. No.9934 of 2021, and he has no claim to that amount.

01Facts

On 21.05.2021 at about 2.15 p.m., the appellant, Abdul Khaiyum, allegedly drove a Hyundai Creta (TN-01-AZ-9339) from west to east near Kilpauk Medical College Hospital, at the EVR Periyar Highway–Barnaby Road junction, while allegedly intoxicated and driving rashly.

p. 2

The car struck a Honda Activa ridden by Selvi Yamuna, an ECG technician, who suffered severe head injuries and died at Government Rajiv Gandhi General Hospital at about 5.45 p.m. The appellant allegedly did not stop. The car was later found near Gengu Reddy Road Subway with front-end damage and a punctured tyre, and PW-4 apprehended him.

pp. 2–3

A breath analyser test (Ex.P-6; photostat Ex.P-7) was conducted. Blood and urine samples were taken by PW-10, but the FSL Toxicology Report (Ex.P-11) recorded no ethyl alcohol. The prosecution attributed this to delay caused by COVID-19 laboratory closure.

p. 4

The prosecution examined PWs 1–16 and marked Exs.P-1 to P-23, with no defence evidence. The Sessions Judge convicted the appellant under s.185 MV Act and s.304 Part II IPC, and acquitted him under s.188 IPC. He was sentenced to six months' RI with a fine of Rs.10,000 under s.185, and five years' RI with a fine of Rs.10,000 under s.304 Part II, concurrently.

pp. 4–5

The appellant contended that the signal was non-functional during COVID-19, that PW-1 and PW-2 were doubtful witnesses, that the breath analyser evidence was unreliable, and that the deceased cut across the road from an unauthorised point. The State defended the conviction.

pp. 6–9 · pp. 11–13

02Issues

i.1. Whether the prosecution established that the appellant drove under the influence of alcohol, so as to commit an offence under s.185 MV Act.

p. 14 · ¶ 5.2(i)

ii.2. Whether the prosecution established that the appellant drove rashly and dangerously and caused the death of Selvi Yamuna.

p. 14 · ¶ 5.2(ii)

iii.3. Whether the prosecution established the requisite knowledge to attract s.304 Part II IPC.

p. 14 · ¶ 5.2(iii)

iv.4. Whether the conviction and sentence warrant interference.

p. 14 · ¶ 5.2(iv)

03Law Applied

The Court applied s.185 MV Act, which penalises driving under the influence of alcohol, and s.304 Part II IPC, which requires knowledge that the act is likely to cause death.

p. 26 · ¶ 5.7(i)

The Court applied s.304A IPC and the causa causans doctrine, under which the rash or negligent act must be the direct, proximate and effective cause of death and not merely a causa sine qua non.

p. 24 · ¶ 5.7(iii)

State of Karnataka v. Satish, (1998) 8 SCC 493, holds that high speed is a relative term and cannot by itself establish rashness without specific evidence.

pp. 22–23 · ¶ 5.6(iv)

Bhagubhai Hassanalli Karyani v. State of Maharashtra, (1971) 3 SCC 930 (also cited as "Bachubhai"), holds that the smell of alcohol does not by itself prove intoxication, and that intoxication requires a urine test, chemical analysis or reliable medical evidence.

p. 10, 19

Mahadeo Hari Lokre v. State of Maharashtra, (1972) 4 SCC 758, holds that a sudden crossing by the deceased without a reasonable opportunity to avert the collision negates criminal negligence.

pp. 21–22 · ¶ 5.5(v)–(vi)

Satya Saai Ram v. Inspector of Police (Crl.O.P. No.23492 of 2025, dated 14.07.2026) is relied upon for the causa causans principle.

p. 28 · ¶ 6.1

The Court applied the presumption of innocence and the rule that the prosecution must prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt, with the benefit of doubt going to the accused.

p. 27 · ¶ 5.8(i)–(ii), (v)

Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 374

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 188Section 304Section 308

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 185

04Reasoning

Intoxication was not proved. The original breath analyser printout (Ex.P-6) was smudged and undecipherable, Ex.P-7 was a photostat with no satisfactory proof of accuracy, and there was no evidence of calibration or the preliminary test required by the ACP (Traffic) instructions.

pp. 16–17 · ¶ 5.4(ii)–(iv)

The blood and urine samples were negative. The Court rejected the prosecution's explanation that alcohol evaporated during the COVID-19 delay as an assumption unsupported by scientific material.

p. 17 · ¶ 5.4(v)–(vii)

Smell of alcohol, congested eyes and unsteadiness were held insufficient in the absence of scientific or medical proof, following Bhagubhai.

pp. 18–19 · ¶ 5.4(viii)–(ix)

The Court found the eyewitness evidence of PW-1 and PW-2 doubtful. The police records (PW-4, PW-13, PW-15, observation mahazar and rough sketch) showed the traffic signals were switched off with only amber lights blinking during COVID-19. PW-1 and PW-2 were colleagues of the deceased and their accounts of a red-signal violation were not accepted without independent corroboration.

p. 15 · ¶ 5.3(i)–(iv) · pp. 15–16 · ¶ 5.3(ix)–(x)

The Court found that the deceased may have crossed from an unauthorised point. PW-13 and PW-15 stated there was no passage from KMC Hospital across the highway, and the place of occurrence was about five metres from the median. Applying Mahadeo, the Court held that such a sudden crossing could negate criminal negligence.

p. 19 · ¶ 5.5(iv) · pp. 20–21 · ¶ 5.5(v)–(vii)

On speed, the damage to the car and the punctured tyre did not prove high speed or rashness. The tyre may have been punctured for other reasons, and the puncture may have occurred while avoiding the accident.

p. 22 · ¶ 5.6(iii)–(vi)

Because intoxication was not proved, the basis for inferring knowledge of likely death fell away. The prosecution also failed to show that the appellant's act was the proximate cause of death, given the possible intervening negligence of the deceased. Knowledge could not be presumed merely because a car was involved in a fatal accident.

p. 25 · ¶ 5.7(vi) · pp. 24–25 · ¶ 5.7(iv)–(viii) · p. 26 · ¶ 5.7(ix)

The trial court did not properly appreciate the material contradictions and deficiencies, and placed undue reliance on the prosecution version. The Court acknowledged the family's loss but held that suspicion cannot replace proof.

p. 27 · ¶ 5.8(iv)–(vi)

05Holding

The prosecution failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt either intoxication under s.185 MV Act or the rash act and requisite knowledge under s.304 Part II IPC.

p. 29 · ¶ 6.2

The Court held that the appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt. The appeal is allowed. The conviction and sentence dated 13.12.2023 in S.C. No.85 of 2022 are set aside, and the appellant is acquitted of the charges under s.185 MV Act and s.304 Part II IPC. The fine amount is to be refunded, and any bail bond stands discharged. The appellant voluntarily deposited Rs.5,00,000 in the bank account of the deceased's mother, A. Uma, under an undertaking given in Crl.O.P. No.9934 of 2021, and he has no claim to that amount.

p. 27 · ¶ 5.8(vii) · p. 29 · ¶ 7.1–7.3 · p. 30 · ¶ 7.4–7.6
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

ABDUL KHAIYUMvsINSPECTOR OF POLICE

Madras High Court · November 13, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment