Madras High CourtCriminal LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Madras HC Acquits POCSO Convict, Holding Prosecution Failed to Prove Girl's Age Beyond Reasonable Doubt

GOVINDA SARKIv.The State Rep. by its Inspector of Police,

Madras HC Acquits POCSO Convict, Holding Prosecution Failed to Prove Girl's Age Beyond Reasonable Doubt. GOVINDA SARKI vs The State Rep. by its Inspector of Police,. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the prosecution established beyond reasonable doubt that the victim was a minor on the date of occurrence, given the documentary and medical age evidence.

The court held

The prosecution failed to prove the victim's minority, penetrative sexual assault, or the Section 366 IPC ingredients beyond reasonable doubt, and the evidence of PW9-PW11 could not be used because of the Section 313 Cr.P.C. lapse.

It also directed

The Criminal Appeal is allowed. The conviction and sentences in Special S.C. No. 198 of 2023 are set aside and the appellant is acquitted of all charges. Any fine paid is refundable on application. The appellant is to be released from Central Prison, Puzhal-I, unless required in another case, and bail bonds stand cancelled. The Rs. 1,00,000 compensation under Section 33(8) POCSO is set aside, but amounts already disbursed to the victim shall not be recovered.

01Facts

The appellant was convicted by the Special Court under the POCSO Act, Chennai, in Special S.C. No. 198 of 2023 (judgment dated 21.03.2025) under Section 6 POCSO Act (10 years' rigorous imprisonment, Rs. 5,000 fine) and Section 366 IPC (3 years, Rs. 5,000 fine), with concurrent sentences.

¶ 3

A compensation of Rs. 1,00,000 was directed to the victim under Section 33(8) POCSO.

¶ 3

The prosecution case is that the 13-year-old victim (PW2), known to the appellant for a few months and in regular telephonic contact, left home on 18.06.2023 to meet him at Tower Park, Anna Nagar.

¶ 4.2

He allegedly took her for ice cream and then to K.K. Nagar, where he worked, and kept her there for about three days.

¶ 4.3-4.4, 4.6

Her mother (PW1) lodged a complaint with the Anna Nagar police, and the victim was traced and rescued on 21.06.2023.

¶ 4.6, 4.9

Medical examination (PW5, Ex.P6 and P7) noted nail scratch marks on the breasts (later attributed by PW5 to possible self-infliction), no external injuries, and a non-intact hymen; the doctor's final opinion was only that sexual intercourse was "possible".

¶ 7.6-7.12

The FSL report (Ex.P8) detected no semen or spermatozoa.

¶ 7.44

The victim's date of birth (28.12.2009) rested on a Bonafide Certificate (Ex.P1) and school evidence (PW9), which was challenged because PW1 knew only Hindi, the certificate was in English, and the school did not offer Class VI.

¶ 7.19-7.22

Further investigation under Crl.O.P. No. 7638 of 2024 produced age-estimation evidence (Exs.P15, P16; PW10, PW11), but the radiological report was not produced and the Section 313 Cr.P.C. questioning did not cover PW9-PW11.

¶ 7.24-7.29, 7.49-7.54

The defence examined the appellant (DW1), his sister (DW2) and a native-place witness (DW3), who asserted that the victim stayed voluntarily because of domestic ill-treatment at home.

¶ 7.15, 7.45-7.48

02Issues

i.1. Whether the prosecution established beyond reasonable doubt that the victim was a minor on the date of occurrence, given the documentary and medical age evidence.

¶ 7.18-7.31, 7.55

ii.2. Whether the prosecution proved penetrative sexual assault beyond reasonable doubt, in light of the victim's testimony, the medical evidence and the forensic report.

¶ 7.9-7.17, 7.43-7.44, 7.56-7.57

iii.3. Whether the ingredients of kidnapping or abduction under Section 366 IPC were established, given the victim's voluntary departure and her stay with the appellant.

¶ 7.32-7.40

iv.4. Whether the uncorroborated testimony of the victim (PW2) is reliable enough to sustain conviction as a "sterling witness."

¶ 7.41-7.43

v.5. Whether the defence evidence (DW1-DW3) probabilised the defence version.

¶ 7.45-7.48

vi.6. Whether evidence collected in further investigation (PW9-PW11) could be used against the accused when the incriminating circumstances were not put to him under Section 313 Cr.P.C.

¶ 7.49-7.54

03Law Applied

Section 6 read with the penetrative-assault provisions of the POCSO Act, Section 366 IPC, Section 33(8) POCSO (compensation), Section 313 Cr.P.C. (duty to put incriminating circumstances to the accused), and Section 415(2) BNSS (appeal).

¶ 3, 7.49-7.53

Akula Raghuram v. State of Andhra Pradesh, 2025 INSC 185: ossification-based age estimation carries a margin of two years on either side, so documentary and medical proof of minority must be reliable.

¶ 7.30

S. Varadarajan v. State of Madras, AIR 1965 SC 942: distinguishes taking a minor from lawful guardianship from a minor voluntarily accompanying the accused, and requires examining whether the accused actively took or induced the minor to leave.

¶ 7.37-7.38

Rai Sandeep v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2012) 8 SCC 21: a victim's sole testimony may sustain conviction only if it is reliable, trustworthy and inspires confidence ("sterling witness" standard).

¶ 7.42-7.43

The prosecution must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt, and the accused is entitled to every reasonable doubt.

¶ 7.59

Provisions in the judgment · 8 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 415

Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 Section 4Section 6Section 33

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 164Section 313Section 428

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 366

04Reasoning

The Bonafide Certificate (Ex.P1) was in English while PW1 knew only Hindi, and PW9 conceded that the school offered no Class VI, contradicting the victim's own schooling account. The school register was not produced, so the documentary proof was unreliable.

¶ 7.19-7.22

The ossification evidence was deficient: Ex.P16 did not record ossification or radiological findings, the radiologist's report was absent, the X-ray (M.O.2) was unsupported, and the further investigator (PW11) had done little beyond producing the victim.

¶ 7.25-7.29

Applying the two-year margin in Akula Raghuram, the estimated range of 15-17 years did not establish minority.

¶ 7.30-7.31

The medical evidence was insufficient for penetrative assault: scratch marks were not conclusively attributable to the appellant, the hymen condition was not conclusive, and the doctor's opinion showed only possibility.

¶ 7.10-7.12

The absence of injuries or semen does not by itself negate sexual assault, but combined with the victim's shifting account (one incident initially, then more in the Section 164 statement) and the shared sleeping arrangements in a house with other occupants, the account did not inspire sufficient confidence.

¶ 7.13-7.17, 7.43-7.44

Applying Rai Sandeep, the victim's testimony was not sterling.

¶ 7.42-7.43

The victim had called the appellant to the park, shared ice cream, and stayed three days without raising an alarm or resisting. Under S. Varadarajan, this did not establish active inducement or force.

¶ 7.33-7.40

The evidence of DW1 and DW2, consistent with PW2's admissions about her stay, probabilised the defence of voluntary stay.

¶ 7.46-7.48

The evidence of PW9-PW11, which bore on age, was not put to the appellant under Section 313 Cr.P.C., so it could not be used against him.

¶ 7.50-7.54, 7.58

Taken cumulatively, these defects created reasonable doubt.

¶ 7.60-7.61

05Holding

The prosecution failed to prove the victim's minority, penetrative sexual assault, or the Section 366 IPC ingredients beyond reasonable doubt, and the evidence of PW9-PW11 could not be used because of the Section 313 Cr.P.C. lapse.

¶ 8.1-8.2

The Criminal Appeal is allowed. The conviction and sentences in Special S.C. No. 198 of 2023 are set aside and the appellant is acquitted of all charges. Any fine paid is refundable on application. The appellant is to be released from Central Prison, Puzhal-I, unless required in another case, and bail bonds stand cancelled. The Rs. 1,00,000 compensation under Section 33(8) POCSO is set aside, but amounts already disbursed to the victim shall not be recovered.

¶ 8.1-8.5
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

GOVINDA SARKIvsThe State Rep. by its Inspector of Police,

Madras High Court · November 13, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment