01Facts
The petitioner, a party-in-person, was appointed as an Estate Assistant (company-paid staff) in the Office of the Official Liquidator, Madras High Court, on 03.08.1992 and claimed 32 years of continuous service, along with a Master's degree and LL.B.
p. 2The petitioner relied on the Supreme Court's order in Civil Appeal No. 5642 of 1994 (27.08.1999), which directed the Government to frame a scheme to absorb company-paid staff.
pp. 2–3 · p. 6Under the resulting scheme, the petitioner was placed at Serial No. 14 for Junior Technical Assistant (JTA) and Serial No. 17 for Lower Division Clerk (LDC). Candidates up to Serial No. 13 were absorbed.
pp. 2–3The petitioner's representations were rejected by the impugned order dated 16.10.2018, passed after a CAT direction in OA No. 881 of 2018.
p. 3The respondents contended that: (i) DOPT OM dated 09.04.2009 reclassified the JTA post from Group C to Group B; (ii) LDC recruitment was abolished across the Ministry of Corporate Affairs under a 2009 policy decision; (iii) earlier rejections were never challenged.
p. 4 · pp. 5–6The respondents relied on the Division Bench decision in W.A. No. 2237 of 2022 and a single-judge order in W.P. No. 9645 of 2023.
p. 4 · pp. 7–11The petitioner relied on a CAT order in OA No. 180/01015/2018 (23.06.2023).
p. 1102Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to absorption as a JTA under the Supreme Court's order in C.A. No. 5642 of 1994 when the post was reclassified to Group B in 2009.
pp. 5–6 · p. 7 · pp. 11–12ii.2. Whether absorption as an LDC can be granted when that recruitment stream was abolished by a 2009 policy decision.
pp. 5–6 · pp. 11–12iii.3. Whether the denial of absorption, while juniors were absorbed, violates Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
pp. 3–4 · pp. 11–12iv.4. Whether the petitioner's claim is barred by the Division Bench decision in W.A. No. 2237 of 2022 and the single-judge order in W.P. No. 9645 of 2023.
pp. 7–11 · p. 1203Law Applied
The Supreme Court's 27.08.1999 order in C.A. No. 5642 of 1994 required the Government to frame an absorption scheme within six months, failing which the High Court judgments would stand confirmed.
pp. 6–7Absorption under the scheme is subject to vacancies.
p. 5The Government's policy decision of 09.04.2009, which reclassified JTA as Group B and abolished LDC recruitment, is treated as a binding change in service policy.
pp. 5–7 · pp. 11–12Principle of judicial discipline: a single judge must follow a Division Bench ruling on identical facts.
pp. 10–11, quoting W.P. No. 9645 of 2023 · ¶ 16The Division Bench in W.A. No. 2237 of 2022 held that the absorption scheme was a one-time measure, that belated claims after decades of silence are barred, and that benefits to other employees are not precedents.
pp. 7–9, quoting paras. 7–9A claim of parity under Article 14 requires a showing that a junior was regularised; the CAT's "no pick and choose" direction applies only in that context.
p. 1104Reasoning
The Court accepted that the petitioner was at Serial No. 14 and that candidates up to Serial No. 13 were absorbed, but held that this did not create an enforceable right, since absorption depended on vacancies.
pp. 5–6The 2009 reclassification of the JTA post to Group B meant that absorption to a Group B post could not arise under a scheme meant for Group C staff. The abolition of LDC recruitment meant that absorption to that post was equally impossible.
pp. 5–6 · p. 8 · p. 12The petitioner did not challenge the 2009 policy decision, and his earlier rejections were not challenged either, so his claim rested only on the 1999 Supreme Court order.
p. 4 · pp. 6–7The Court held that the Division Bench in W.A. No. 2237 of 2022 covered identical facts, namely long service as company-paid staff and reliance on the same scheme, and bound it to reject the claim.
pp. 7–8 · pp. 10–12On Articles 14 and 16, the Court noted that the petitioner did not allege that any junior had been regularised after the policy change, which distinguished the CAT order relied on.
pp. 11–1205Holding
Because the JTA post was reclassified to Group B and LDC recruitment was abolished under the 2009 policy, the petitioner could not be absorbed under the 1999 Supreme Court order, and the Division Bench decision in W.A. No. 2237 of 2022 governed the matter. The Court found no merit in the claim.
pp. 11–12The writ petition was dismissed and the impugned order dated 16.10.2018 was upheld, with no costs and connected WMPs closed. No separate direction was issued to the respondents.
p. 12Original Court PDF
T.SUNDARAMOORTHYvsTHE SECRETARY
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
