01Facts
The petitioner was appointed as a Physical Education Teacher on consolidated pay on 9 May 2005, following earlier proceedings, and was placed on the regular time scale from 1 June 2006.
pp. 2–3He sought to have his service notionally reckoned from 30 August 1998, relying on an earlier High Court order, and claimed consequential benefits, including coverage under the Old Pension Scheme applicable to employees appointed before 1 April 2003. He retired in 2011 and filed this writ petition in 2022.
pp. 2–3, 10–1102Issues
i.Whether the petitioner could obtain a direction to reckon his appointment notionally from 30 August 1998, with consequential service, monetary and Old Pension Scheme benefits, despite the unchallenged order fixing his regular time-scale appointment from 1 June 2006.
pp. 10–11ii.Whether the petitioner’s claim was liable to be rejected for delay and laches, given that he filed the petition nearly eleven years after retirement.
p. 403Law Applied
Under Article 226, relief is discretionary and may be refused where a petitioner approaches the court after inordinate, unexplained delay; the court may consider the prejudice, public inconvenience, or injustice that belated relief could cause.
pp. 4–10The Court relied on Chennai Metropolitan Water Supply & Sewerage Board v. T.T. Murali Babu, (2014) 4 SCC 108; State of M.P. v. Nandlal Jaiswal, (1986) 4 SCC 566; and other authorities concerning delay, laches, acquiescence, and the discretionary nature of writ relief.
pp. 4–10The Court also applied the principle that an unchallenged order fixing a person’s regular appointment cannot be indirectly unsettled by seeking a mandamus for inconsistent consequential relief.
pp. 10–11Provisions in the judgment · 1
the Act (alias, unresolved) Section 62
04Reasoning
The petitioner waited nearly eleven years after retirement to seek relief, and the Court found no basis to overlook that delay.
p. 4On the merits, the record showed appointment on consolidated pay in 2005 and regular time-scale placement from 1 June 2006. Because the petitioner had not challenged the order fixing that date, the Court held that he could not use this petition to secure, indirectly, a notional appointment date in 1998 and the resulting pension and monetary benefits.
pp. 10–1105Holding
The Court held that the petitioner had not established entitlement to the requested mandamus, both because of delay and laches and because he had not challenged the order fixing his regular time-scale appointment from 1 June 2006.
p. 12The writ petition was dismissed, with no order as to costs.
p. 12Original Court PDF
G.RamaswamyvsThe Secretary to Government
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
