Madras High CourtEmployment and Labour LawAdministrative and Public Law

Man Who Resigned From CRPF in 2001 Loses Bid for Pay and Pension for 1991–2012 Service, as Discharge Stands Final

T.Murugesanv.The Additional Deputy Inspector General of Police

Man Who Resigned From CRPF in 2001 Loses Bid for Pay and Pension for 1991–2012 Service, as Discharge Stands Final. T.Murugesan vs The Additional Deputy Inspector General of Police. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the appellant, whose resignation acceptance was ultimately restored by the Division Bench, can claim the period from 15.11.2001 to 28.05.2010 as regular service for monetary, terminal, and pensionary benefits merely because he worked during that period under a conditional reinstatement.

The court held

The appellant cannot treat the conditional interim service (15.11.2001–28.05.2010) as regular service, and cannot reopen his discharge through a subsequent representation, because the orders on the resignation and the "dies non" period have attained finality.

It also directed

The learned Single Judge's refusal to interfere with the rejection of the representation was upheld, and no perversity or illegality was found. The Writ Appeal is dismissed without costs.

01Facts

The appellant, a former CRPF employee who appeared in person, tendered his resignation on 23.06.2001. The authorities did not accept it and granted leave from 20.07.2001 to 17.09.2001. He resubmitted his resignation on 26.09.2001, which was accepted on 15.11.2001.

p. 3

His writ petition challenging the acceptance (W.P.(MD) No. 5148 of 2006) was allowed on 18.11.2009. He was reinstated on 28.04.2010, subject to the outcome of the writ appeal.

p. 3

On 12.06.2010 the authorities treated 10.11.2001 to 28.05.2010 as "dies non." The appellant did not challenge that order.

p. 3

In W.A.(MD) No. 520 of 2010, the Division Bench on 14.02.2012 set aside the single judge's order and restored the discharge. He was relieved on 30.04.2012.

p. 3

His review application was dismissed on 01.08.2013. His SLPs were dismissed on 02.04.2012 and 28.02.2014. Later proceedings, including a review withdrawn on 19.07.2018, a recall application dismissed on 16.02.2022, and an SLP dismissed on 09.12.2022, also failed.

p. 4

In W.P.(MD) No. 7487 of 2012 the Court confirmed the relieving order on 08.04.2019 but permitted him to submit a representation for benefits payable to a discharged person.

p. 4

His representation of 13.05.2019, which sought service and monetary benefits for April 1991 to 2012 and pensionary/family pension benefits, was rejected on 21.06.2019.

pp. 4–5

W.P.(MD) No. 5196 of 2023 was dismissed by the learned Single Judge on 18.11.2024.

p. 5

The appellant appealed under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent, contending that he worked for over ten years and is entitled to consequential and terminal benefits.

p. 2

02Issues

i.1. Whether the appellant, whose resignation acceptance was ultimately restored by the Division Bench, can claim the period from 15.11.2001 to 28.05.2010 as regular service for monetary, terminal, and pensionary benefits merely because he worked during that period under a conditional reinstatement.

p. 2, 6

ii.2. Whether the liberty granted to submit a representation for benefits payable to a discharged person permitted him to reopen his discharge or seek regularisation of the disputed period, and whether the rejection of that representation warrants interference.

pp. 4, 6–7

03Law Applied

Reinstatement ordered pending an appeal is conditional and does not create an indefeasible right to count the interim period as regular service once the underlying order is set aside.

p. 6

The Division Bench judgment in W.A.(MD) No. 520 of 2010, which confirmed the acceptance of resignation, is final and was not disturbed by subsequent review, recall, or SLP proceedings.

p. 4, 6

An unchallenged administrative order (the 12.06.2010 "dies non" order) stands and cannot be collaterally revived.

p. 6

A liberty to make a representation does not confer any fresh substantive right to reopen settled orders.

pp. 6–7

04Reasoning

The Court found that the appellant's continuation in service from 2010 to 2012 rested on a reinstatement expressly made subject to the outcome of the writ appeal. Once the Division Bench set aside the single judge's order and confirmed the discharge, the interim service could not ripen into a regular or qualifying period merely because the appellant actually worked during it. The Court further noted that the 12.06.2010 "dies non" order was never challenged. The Division Bench's confirmation of the resignation had also attained finality after repeated unsuccessful challenges before this Court and the Supreme Court.

p. 4, 6

The 2019 liberty to submit a representation was therefore limited to benefits payable to a discharged person. It could not be used to reopen the discharge or secure regularisation of the 2001–2010 period. The learned Single Judge had rightly declined to interfere with the rejection of the representation, and the Court found no perversity or illegality in that reasoning.

pp. 6–7

05Holding

The appellant cannot treat the conditional interim service (15.11.2001–28.05.2010) as regular service, and cannot reopen his discharge through a subsequent representation, because the orders on the resignation and the "dies non" period have attained finality.

pp. 6–7

The learned Single Judge's refusal to interfere with the rejection of the representation was upheld, and no perversity or illegality was found. The Writ Appeal is dismissed without costs.

pp. 7–8
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

T.MurugesanvsThe Additional Deputy Inspector General of Police

Madras High Court · November 16, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment