01Facts
The suit property is house ground and premises at Door No. 46/47, Parri Street, Avvai Nagar, Choolaimedu, Chennai, measuring 1939 sq. ft.
¶ 4The property was released to Narayana Naicker by Release Deed No. 2545/1996 dated 19.08.1966, executed by his brother K.P. Kelappa Naicker.
¶ 4 · Ex.A1 · ¶ 8Narayana Naicker died intestate on 05.01.1995. His wife Lakshmi died intestate on 15.12.2008.
¶ 4The parties are their children: two daughters (plaintiffs), a son (the 1st defendant/appellant) and another daughter (the 2nd defendant).
¶ 4, 13Two daughters filed O.S. No. 2257 of 2014 (XIX Additional City Civil Court, Chennai) seeking partition into four equal shares and possession of two shares. The defendants did not partition despite legal notice.
¶ 4 · Ex.A5 · ¶ 8During pendency, the 1st plaintiff died and her legal representatives were impleaded as 3rd to 5th plaintiffs.
¶ 3The 1st defendant contended that he discontinued his studies to join his father's catering business, that he contributed to acquiring another property at Mogambigai Nagar, Ramapuram, and that he met the family's expenses, including the marriages of the sisters and the mother's medical costs. He also argued that the suit property was indivisible.
¶ 5The 2nd defendant adopted the written statement.
¶ 6The trial court granted a preliminary decree allotting an undivided 1/4 share to each of the surviving and deceased parties' legal heirs.
¶ 9The 1st defendant appealed.
¶ 1002Issues
i.1. Whether the trial court was correct in granting a preliminary decree for an undivided 1/4 share to each of the legal representatives of Narayana Naicker and Lakshmi.
¶ 12ii.2. Whether the 1st defendant's claimed contribution to the Ramapuram property defeats the plaintiffs' claim to a share in the suit property.
¶ 13iii.3. Whether the 1st defendant's contention that the plaintiffs are not entitled to any share can be sustained, given that he was not born when the property vested in his father.
¶ 1403Law Applied
The court did not cite any specific statute, including the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, or any provision of the Code of Civil Procedure governing preliminary and final decrees.
The devolution of property of an intestate passes "naturally" in equal shares to the surviving children, so that the property devolved in equal shares on the two plaintiffs and two defendants after the deaths of Narayana Naicker and Lakshmi, both intestate.
¶ 13A claim of contribution to the acquisition of a different property does not affect a co-heir's share in property that vested earlier in the ancestor.
¶ 13The entitlement of a person not in existence at the time the property vested is a claim that cannot defeat co-heirs' shares.
¶ 14Where the property is indivisible, a co-sharer's purchase of other shares is a matter for the final decree stage.
¶ 15–1604Reasoning
The court first confirmed that the relationship among the parties was undisputed and that Ex.A1 established the father's title.
¶ 13Because both parents died intestate, the property devolved equally on the four children, and the death of the 1st plaintiff during the suit passed her undivided share to her legal representatives (3rd to 5th plaintiffs).
¶ 13The 1st defendant's claim of contribution to the Ramapuram property was held not to affect the plaintiffs' share, because the plaintiffs claimed the property that had vested in their father in 1966, not the Ramapuram property.
¶ 13The 1st defendant was about 45 years old when the suit was filed in 2014, which meant he was not born when the property was released to his father in 1966. His claim that the plaintiffs were not entitled to any share could therefore not be considered.
¶ 14The court did not decide the divisibility objection. It left the question of indivisibility to the final decree stage, where the trial court could consider a purchase of shares by co-sharers if the property was found indivisible and the offer was viable and reasonable.
¶ 15–16The effect of Ex.B1 (a 2015 Release Deed) was left to be examined at the final decree stage.
¶ 1605Holding
The trial court correctly granted a preliminary decree for an undivided 1/4 share to each of the legal representatives of Narayana Naicker and Lakshmi.
¶ 12–14The appeal is dismissed and the preliminary decree is confirmed. The parties are directed to apply for a final decree before the trial court. If the trial court finds the property indivisible, it may explore whether the other parties will purchase the share at a viable and reasonable price. Ex.B1 is to be examined, and shares allotted, at the final decree stage. No costs.
¶ 16Original Court PDF
MOHANvsMALLIGA, (DECEASED)
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
