01Facts
On 17.07.2013 at about 9:30 a.m., the complainant Badami Jatav was allegedly assaulted with lathis and sticks by eight neighbours, including the three petitioners, Suresh (Petitioner No. 1), Ramdas (Petitioner No. 2) and Rajaram (Petitioner No. 3), at Village Noharikala.
p. 1He sustained injuries to his wrists, head and legs, and his son Sobran Jatav was also injured.
p. 1A report was lodged at Police Station Kotwali the same day at 10:00 a.m., and Crime No. 458/2013 was registered under Sections 452, 323, 294, 147, 148 and 149 IPC.
pp. 1–2The petitioners were arrested on 18.07.2013 (Suresh) and 30.07.2013 (Ramdas and Rajaram).
p. 2The charge-sheet was filed before the CJM, Shivpuri, and the case was tried by the JMFC, Shivpuri, which convicted the accused. On appeal, the First Additional Sessions Judge, Shivpuri, by judgment dated 24.09.2016, acquitted some co-accused, modified the petitioners' conviction from Section 325 r/w 149 IPC to Section 325 r/w 34 IPC, and maintained a sentence of one year's rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 700 each.
pp. 2–3The petitioners approached this Court. Their counsel did not press the revision on merits and confined his prayer to reducing the substantive sentence to the period already undergone (about 20 days of custody), citing the nearly decade-long pendency of the case. The State opposed.
p. 302Issues
i.1. Whether the conviction of the petitioners under Section 325 r/w Section 34 IPC, which is not challenged before the Court, is sustainable on the evidence on record.
p. 4ii.2. Whether the substantive sentence of one year's rigorous imprisonment should be reduced to the period already undergone, having regard to the period of incarceration, the prolonged pendency of the proceedings, and the petitioners' conduct on bail.
pp. 4–5iii.3. Whether the fine should be enhanced, and if so, to what amount and for what disposal.
p. 503Law Applied
Section 325 IPC, which punishes voluntarily causing grievous hurt, and Section 34 IPC, which attributes criminal liability for an act done in furtherance of a common intention, form the modified basis of conviction after the appellate court's alteration from Section 149 IPC.
pp. 2–3The Court relied on its sentencing discretion to reduce a substantive sentence and enhance a fine, taking into account the period of custody, the delay in the proceedings, and the absence of any misuse of bail.
pp. 4–5The Court directed that the enhanced fine be paid to the complainant "as compensation in accordance with law," without identifying the specific provision.
p. 5No judicial precedents were cited.
Provisions in the judgment · 9 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 325Section 34Section 452Section 323Section 294Section 147Section 148Section 149
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 161
04Reasoning
Because counsel abandoned the challenge to conviction, the Court examined the evidence only to confirm that the findings of the Courts below were supported. It found that a bare perusal of the record justified the conviction, so no interference was warranted.
p. 4On sentence, the Court treated the petitioners' custody of about 20 days, the proceedings pending since 2013 with their resulting mental agony, and the absence of any record evidence of misuse of bail as sufficient grounds to reduce the substantive jail term to the period already undergone.
p. 4To preserve the punitive and compensatory character of the sentence, the Court increased the fine from Rs. 700 to Rs. 5,000 each, and linked it to the complainant's compensation.
pp. 4–5The Court expressly limited this relief to the "peculiar facts and circumstances" of the case, so it should not be treated as a general sentencing principle.
p. 505Holding
The Court held that the conviction under Section 325 r/w Section 34 IPC is maintained.
p. 4The one-year rigorous imprisonment imposed on each petitioner is reduced to the period already undergone.
p. 5The fine is enhanced to Rs. 5,000 each, to be deposited before the Trial Court within one month, after adjusting any fine already paid, and then paid to the complainant as compensation in accordance with law.
p. 5The petitioners are to be released forthwith unless required in any other case, and the revision is partly allowed and disposed of accordingly.
p. 5Original Court PDF
SureshvsThe State Of Madhya Pradesh
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
