Odisha High CourtCriminal LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Orissa HC Puts Two Men on Probation for 1987 Attack, Upholding Hurt Conviction as They Stayed Out of Crime

BHUBANESSWAR NAGv.STATE

Orissa HC Puts Two Men on Probation for 1987 Attack, Upholding Hurt Conviction as They Stayed Out of Crime. BHUBANESSWAR NAG vs STATE. Odisha High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the concurrent findings of the Trial Court and the Appellate Court, as modified, are perverse or otherwise warrant interference in revisional jurisdiction.

The court held

The revision is disposed of. The Court answered Issue 1 in the negative: the findings warrant no interference under the Kuntegowda standard, and the conviction under Sections 324/34 IPC is affirmed.

It also directed

On Issue 2, the Court held that the petitioners are entitled to the benefit of probation. It directed their release on probation under Section 4 of the P.O. Act, on conditions to be settled by the Trial Court, and waived the fine in view of the facts and circumstances.

The judgment does not expressly state whether the two-year R.I. imposed by the Appellate Court is set aside or substituted, which should be checked against the order sheet.

01Facts

On 24.12.1987, at village Kasaipani, the petitioners allegedly attacked Jido @ Jagat Harijan (P.W.2), the father of the informant (P.W.1).

pp. 2–3

Petitioner No. 2 allegedly assaulted him with a stick and Petitioner No. 1 with a tangia, causing multiple injuries.

pp. 2–3

A charge-sheet was filed under Section 307 read with Section 34 IPC.

p. 3

The prosecution examined ten witnesses and exhibited documents Exts. 1–9/2 and two weapons (M.O.I and II).

pp. 3–4

The defence led no evidence and pleaded complete denial and false implication.

pp. 3–4

The Trial Court (Asst. Sessions Judge, Nuapada, 18.03.2005) convicted the petitioners under Section 307/34 IPC and sentenced them to three years' R.I. and a fine of Rs. 10,000.

p. 2 · pp. 4–5

On appeal, the Additional District & Sessions Judge, Nuapada (Crl. Appeal No. 22 of 2005, 18.05.2006) modified the conviction to Section 324/34 IPC and imposed two years' R.I. and a fine of Rs. 10,000, with set-off of detention undergone.

p. 1 · p. 5

The petitioners filed this revision under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. alleging perversity in the appreciation of evidence.

pp. 5–6

At the hearing, counsel for the petitioners stated that they had undergone 29 days' incarceration, that the occurrence dates to 1987, that they are now about 58 and 52 years old, and that they have not been involved in any other criminal activity.

pp. 8–9

02Issues

i.1. Whether the concurrent findings of the Trial Court and the Appellate Court, as modified, are perverse or otherwise warrant interference in revisional jurisdiction.

pp. 6–8, paras 5–8

ii.2. Whether the petitioners, having been convicted under Section 324/34 IPC, are entitled to be released on probation under the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958.

pp. 8–9, paras 9–12

03Law Applied

The Court exercised revisional jurisdiction under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C.

p. 1

The Court applied the contours laid down in Kuntegowda v. Thurubaiah, 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1485. Under that decision, the High Court may interfere only where the lower court's order or finding is perverse, grossly erroneous, glaringly unreasonable, wholly unreliable or untenable in law, is based on immaterial or irrelevant material or no material, or fails to consider relevant material or reflects arbitrary or capricious exercise of discretion.

pp. 6–7, para 7.3

The offence provisions applied were Sections 307, 324 and 34 IPC.

p. 2 · p. 5

For sentencing, the Court relied on Section 4 of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958, which permits release on probation of offenders not punishable with death or life imprisonment, on conditions fixed by the court.

p. 9, para 12

The Court treated Chellammal v. State represented by the Inspector of Police, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 870 as supporting the invocation of the P.O. Act in a fit case.

p. 9, para 11

Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 397Section 401

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 324Section 34Section 307

Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 Section 4

04Reasoning

The Court noted that a perversity challenge could not be examined without reference to the evidence, so it scanned the record for that limited purpose.

p. 6, para 7

It found no infirmity in the Appellate Court's modification of the conviction from Section 307 to Section 324/34 IPC. This conclusion rested on the testimony of the injured witness (P.W.2) and the opinion of the medical officer (P.W.10) that the injuries were simple in nature.

p. 8, para 8

Because the Appellate Court's reappraisal of the injury evidence was reasonable and rested on relevant material, it did not meet the threshold for revisional interference under Kuntegowda.

p. 8, para 8

On sentence, the Court accepted the petitioners' submissions on the period of custody already undergone, the lapse of nearly four decades since the offence, their advanced age, and the absence of any subsequent offence. The State did not seriously oppose this and did not dispute the absence of intervening offences.

pp. 8–9, paras 9–10

Weighing these factors against the nature of the offence and the punishment prescribed, the Court held this to be a fit case for invoking the P.O. Act, in line with Chellammal.

pp. 9, paras 11–12

05Holding

The revision is disposed of. The Court answered Issue 1 in the negative: the findings warrant no interference under the Kuntegowda standard, and the conviction under Sections 324/34 IPC is affirmed.

p. 8, para 8

On Issue 2, the Court held that the petitioners are entitled to the benefit of probation. It directed their release on probation under Section 4 of the P.O. Act, on conditions to be settled by the Trial Court, and waived the fine in view of the facts and circumstances.

pp. 9, paras 11–13

The judgment does not expressly state whether the two-year R.I. imposed by the Appellate Court is set aside or substituted, which should be checked against the order sheet.

Odisha High Court

Original Court PDF

BHUBANESSWAR NAGvsSTATE

Odisha High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment