Punjab and Haryana High CourtProperty and Real Estate LawAdministrative and Public Law

P&H HC Upholds Enhanced Compensation For Mewat Road Land, Remands Severance Claims To Reference Court

Suber Ahmedv.State Of Haryana Etc.

P&H HC Upholds Enhanced Compensation For Mewat Road Land, Remands Severance Claims To Reference Court. Suber Ahmed vs State Of Haryana Etc.. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Reference Court was justified in relying on Ex. P-40 and imposing a 70%/75% deduction on its value, or whether the State's sale deeds (Exs. R-11 to R-13) should have been preferred.

The court held

The court held that the Reference Court rightly assessed market value, rejected the State's plea for a higher rate and rejected the State's contention that the Reference Court fixed a higher rate.

It also directed

The court held that market value for both villages is to be determined at par.

The 2009 award could not be mechanically applied.

Severance charges are not to be awarded mechanically at 50%; the matter is remanded to the Reference Court solely to quantify severance charges for claimants who raised and substantiated the claim, without benefit of Section 23(1A) and 23(2) on such charges.

All appeals and cross-objections were disposed of in these terms.

01Facts

The State issued a Section 4 notification under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 on 01.08.2011, followed by a Section 6 notification on 14.10.2011, for acquiring 20.86 acres across villages Nalhar and Nuh, District Mewat, for a new express road linking the Gurgaon-Alwar Road to the Medical College.

¶ 3

The Collector's award dated 30.12.2011 fixed market value at ₹20,00,000/acre (Nalhar) and ₹38,00,000/acre (Nuh).

¶ 4

On reference under Section 18, the Reference Court, by awards dated 02.04.2022, fixed market value at ₹60,50,000/acre (Nalhar) and ₹72,60,000/acre (Nuh).

¶ 6–7

The Reference Court relied on Ex. P-40 (sale deed dated 08.07.2011, ₹2,42,11,000/acre), imposing a 75% cut for Nalhar and 70% for Nuh.

¶ 14

Landowners sought enhancement, contending the cut was excessive and that a 2009 award (₹1,85,14,286/acre) should apply.

¶ 8–10

The State sought reduction, relying on Exs. R-11, R-12 and R-13 (₹36–50 lakh/acre).

¶ 8–10

The Reference Court had also awarded 50% severance charges mechanically.

¶ 27

Delay was condoned by consent.

¶ 11

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Reference Court was justified in relying on Ex. P-40 and imposing a 70%/75% deduction on its value, or whether the State's sale deeds (Exs. R-11 to R-13) should have been preferred.

¶ 8 · ¶ 10 · ¶ 14 · ¶ 21 · ¶ 22

ii.2. Whether a previous award (2009 acquisition, ₹1,85,14,286/acre) could be mechanically relied upon to fix compensation.

¶ 9 · ¶ 15 · ¶ 16

iii.3. Whether different market values could be fixed for the two villages acquired under a common notification for a common purpose.

¶ 23 · ¶ 24 · ¶ 25

iv.4. Whether severance charges were correctly awarded and whether the matter must be remanded for their determination.

¶ 27 · ¶ 28 · ¶ 29

03Law Applied

The court applied Section 18 and Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 as the statutory framework for enhancement appeals.

¶ 1

The court followed Manoj Kumar v. State of Haryana (2018) 13 SCC 96 and Ram Kishan v. State of Haryana (2025 SCC OnLine SC 715), holding that previous awards are only evidence, not binding precedent, and cannot be applied mechanically without examining the similarity, distance, size and bona fides of the underlying transactions.

¶ 15, 16

The court applied Lal Chand v. Union of India (2009) 15 SCC 769, which requires deductions from exemplar sale prices for development, size, location and type of land (agricultural, residential, commercial, industrial), and which prohibits treating small plots as proxies for large agricultural tracts.

¶ 19, 21

The court followed HSIIDC v. Pran Sukh (2010) 11 SCC 175, Ali Mohammad Beigh v. State of J&K (2017) 4 SCC 717, and Surinder Ahuja v. State of Punjab (2026 (4) RCR (Civil) 417), under which lands acquired by common notification for a common purpose, and of similar nature, should receive a uniform rate.

¶ 24, 25

Under Section 23(1A) and 23(2), statutory benefits are not payable on severance charges.

¶ 28

The court relied on the principle that sale deeds executed near the Section 4 date are preferred, and that the Section 51A mandate must be observed.

¶ 22

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Punjab Scheduled Roads and Controlled Areas Restriction of Unregulated Development Act, 1963 Section 4

04Reasoning

The court declined to rely on the 2009 award because 35 exemplar sale deeds executed in 2010–11 were available.

¶ 16

The court held that Ex. P-40 (456 sq. yd., residential, within municipal limits, about 536 m aerial distance) differed from the acquired agricultural land (over 20 acres, linear acquisition) in size, type and location, so a substantial deduction was justified.

¶ 20.2, 21

The court upheld the 70% cut as not unjustified, noting that the Reference Court had assigned several reasons, not all irrelevant.

¶ 14, 21

On the State's sale deeds, the court found that Exs. R-1 to R-10 (executed in 2010) could be ignored, but Exs. R-11 and R-12 (23.02.2011) and R-13 (05.07.2011, within 100 m, within municipal limits) could not be discarded merely for being prior to the Section 4 notification.

¶ 22

Taking R-13's ₹50 lakh/acre and allowing for a generous appreciation over four to five months, the court held that the value could not exceed ₹70 lakh/acre, which supported the Reference Court's deduction from Ex. P-40.

¶ 22

Since the two villages were acquired under one notification for one purpose, the court held that value should be uniform and rejected the State's contention that the Reference Court had assessed higher rates.

¶ 24–26

On severance, the Reference Court's mechanical grant of 50% of market value was unsustainable, because the bifurcated area's size, utility and value must be assessed.

¶ 27

05Holding

The court held that the Reference Court rightly assessed market value, rejected the State's plea for a higher rate and rejected the State's contention that the Reference Court fixed a higher rate.

¶ 26

The court held that market value for both villages is to be determined at par.

¶ 25

The 2009 award could not be mechanically applied.

¶ 16

Severance charges are not to be awarded mechanically at 50%; the matter is remanded to the Reference Court solely to quantify severance charges for claimants who raised and substantiated the claim, without benefit of Section 23(1A) and 23(2) on such charges.

¶ 27–29

All appeals and cross-objections were disposed of in these terms.

¶ 30
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Suber AhmedvsState Of Haryana Etc.

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment