01Facts
The plaintiffs, the wife and daughter of defendant No. 1, sued for a declaration that a transfer deed dated 04.04.2016, executed by defendant No. 1 in favour of his real brother (defendant No. 2), was illegal, null and void.
¶ 1They pleaded that the suit property was acquired from the father's income and was therefore joint family property.
¶ 2They further alleged matrimonial discord, physical ill-treatment of plaintiff No. 1, and that the transfer was made without legal necessity or consideration to defeat their rights.
¶ 2The defendants contended that defendant No. 1 was the absolute owner, competent to alienate the property, and that the plaintiffs had no subsisting right, title or interest.
¶ 3The Trial Court dismissed the suit, and the First Appellate Court dismissed the plaintiffs' appeal.
¶ 3The plaintiffs then filed the present RSA, which was 13 days late. The delay was condoned.
¶ 1-202Issues
i.1. Whether the 13-day delay in filing the Regular Second Appeal should be condoned under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963.
¶ 1-2ii.2. Whether the suit property is ancestral or joint family property in the hands of defendant No. 1, such that the plaintiffs acquired an enforceable interest that could be defeated by the transfer deed dated 04.04.2016.
¶ 4iii.3. Whether the plaintiffs have locus standi to maintain the suit in the absence of proof of a subsisting legal right in the suit property.
¶ 4.1iv.4. Whether the concurrent findings of the Courts below warrant interference in second appeal.
¶ 4.103Law Applied
The Court applied Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963, read with Section 151 CPC, to condone delay, holding that procedural law is meant to advance substantial justice and should not defeat merits on insignificant delay where no prejudice is shown to the opposite party.
¶ 2A claim to ancestral or joint family character must be established by cogent and legally admissible evidence, and a person lacking proof of a subsisting right in the property lacks locus standi to challenge its alienation.
¶ 4, 4.1Concurrent findings of fact may be disturbed in second appeal only where they are perverse, based on misreading of evidence, or otherwise legally infirm.
¶ 4.1No specific precedent or statutory provision governing the alienation of property or the second appeal jurisdiction is cited in the judgment.
Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 5
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
04Reasoning
The Court condoned the 13-day delay because it was insignificant and no prejudice to the respondents was shown, which it treated as a ground for deciding the appeal on merits.
¶ 2Both Courts had concurrently found that defendant No. 1 was the absolute owner of the suit property. The plaintiffs failed to prove that the property was ancestral or joint family property in defendant No. 1's hands, or that they had acquired any independent right by birth or otherwise.
¶ 4Because the plaintiffs' challenge to the transfer rested entirely on that unproven interest, it failed. Consequently, they had no subsisting legal right and therefore no locus standi to maintain the suit.
¶ 4, 4.1The Court found the concurrent findings free from perversity, misreading of evidence, or legal infirmity, so it declined to interfere.
¶ 4.1The judgment does not expressly frame a substantial question of law under Section 100 CPC, and it does not discuss the authorities on the limits of second appellate jurisdiction.
05Holding
The Court condoned the 13-day delay in filing the RSA.
¶ 2The plaintiffs failed to establish the ancestral or joint family character of the suit property or any enforceable interest in it, and therefore lacked locus standi to challenge the transfer deed dated 04.04.2016. The concurrent findings of the Courts below were upheld as free from perversity or legal infirmity.
¶ 4, 4.1The RSA was dismissed, and the pending miscellaneous applications were disposed of.
¶ 4.1, 5Original Court PDF
Gurvinder Kaur And AnothervsVinderjit Singh And Another
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
