01Facts
The appellants, the wife (Roshni) and daughters of defendant No. 1 Multan Singh, sued for a declaration that a release deed dated 03.07.2018 (Document No. 4719), executed by Multan Singh in favour of defendant Nos. 2 and 3, was illegal, null and void, with consequential permanent injunction.
¶ 2They claimed the suit property was ancestral and coparcenary property, since Multan Singh had inherited it from his father, so that his daughters acquired a birthright in it
¶ 2The defendants contested the suit, asserting that Multan Singh was the absolute and exclusive owner and could validly release his interest
¶ 3Both courts below concurrently held that the property was Multan Singh's individual, self-acquired property. The succession to his father Jagat Singh opened on 10.11.1974, after the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 came into force, and devolved under Section 8 on Class-I heirs (sons, daughters and wife) in equal 1/6th shares
¶ 4The suit was dismissed.
¶ 4The appellants filed a Regular Second Appeal, along with CM-2476-C-2026 seeking condonation of a 15-day delay, which the Court allowed in the interest of substantial justice
CM paras. 1–202Issues
i.1. Whether property inherited by Multan Singh from his father under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 retains an ancestral or coparcenary character, conferring a birthright on his daughters so as to render the release deed dated 03.07.2018 void.
¶ 4, 4.1, 4.2ii.2. Whether the concurrent findings of the courts below warrant interference in second appeal.
¶ 4.203Law Applied
The Court relied on Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, under which property inherited by a Hindu from a male intestate is taken in his individual capacity and does not become Hindu undivided family property vis-à-vis his own children
¶ 4, 4.1It applied the principle in Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Kanpur v. Chander Sen, 1986(3) SCC 567, and Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar, 1987(1) PLR 11, which hold that such property does not form coparcenary property in the hands of the heir
¶ 4.1It also relied on J. Rajesh (Minor) v. M. Kumaran (Dead) through LRs, 2026 INSC 1208, which reaffirmed that inherited property does not, by reason of its ancestral origin, confer an independent birthright on descendants while the holder is alive and holds it individually
¶ 4.1Consequently, an heir in whose individual hands the property stands may alienate it lawfully
¶ 4.2On the second appeal, the Court applied the standard of perversity, illegality or material infirmity in concurrent findings
¶ 4.2On delay, it applied the principle that procedural rules should advance substantial justice and not defeat it on technical grounds
CM para. 2Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 5
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
Hindu Succession Act, 1956 Section 8
04Reasoning
The Court first found that the courts below correctly identified the succession to Jagat Singh's estate as opening in 1974, after the 1956 Act, so Section 8 governed and Multan Singh took a 1/6th share in his individual capacity
¶ 4Applying Chander Sen, Yudhishter and J. Rajesh, the Court held that the appellants' argument that the inherited ancestral character gave them a birthright failed as a matter of law, because the property was not coparcenary property in Multan Singh's hands vis-à-vis his descendants
¶ 4.1, 4.2Since Multan Singh held the property individually, he could validly execute the release deed, and the appellants had no subsisting right on which to challenge it
¶ 4.2The Court therefore found no perversity or material infirmity in the concurrent findings, so no interference was warranted in second appeal
¶ 4.205Holding
The Court held that property devolving upon Multan Singh under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 was his individual property and did not confer any birthright or coparcenary interest on the appellants, so the release deed dated 03.07.2018 could not be challenged on that basis
¶ 4.2The concurrent findings of the courts below were not perverse or illegal, so the Regular Second Appeal was dismissed
¶ 4.2The 15-day delay in filing was condoned
CM para. 2No further directions were issued and pending applications stood disposed of
¶ 5Original Court PDF
Roshni And AnothervsMultan Singh Through His Lrs Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
