01Facts
Respondent No. 2, Harwinder Kaur Gill, applied for a 400 sq. yd. freehold plot and was successful in the draw of lots held on 30.03.2001. The tentative price was Rs. 15,00,000, and she paid the 15% deposit on 24.05.2001.
¶ 2Fresh allotment proceedings were held on 16.05.2008, and Plot No. 1086 (Corner), Sector 77, Mohali, was allotted by letter dated 25.09.2008.
¶ 3The tentative price was revised to Rs. 18,45,937 on 02.02.2009 due to an additional area.
¶ 3Clause 11 required the allottee to take possession within 60 days, and GMADA relied on this as a deemed possession clause.
¶ 4The land in Sectors 76 to 80 was subject to litigation and a stay order of this Court, and development work was incomplete. GMADA's own reports referred to feasibility, sewerage, drainage and the stay order.
¶ 7Respondent No. 2 sought physical possession by letter dated 17.02.2009.
¶ 6There is no record of any communication fixing a date for possession.
¶ 6, 18GMADA demanded and received Rs. 2,67,775 on 30.04.2012 with no non-construction charges shown.
¶ 8Subsequent demands for non-construction charges were raised on 21.09.2012, 06.11.2012 and 14.03.2013 (Rs. 4,16,726). The allottee's representation of 20.11.2012 was not accepted, and the No Dues Certificate was refused.
¶ 9Physical possession was delivered only on 02.04.2013, more than four years after the request.
¶ 10–11, 15The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Mohali, allowed the complaint on 01.08.2014. The State Commission dismissed GMADA's appeal on 22.09.2016, and the National Commission dismissed its revision on 26.03.2024.
¶ 1GMADA then filed this writ petition under Article 226.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether GMADA can levy non-construction charges on an allottee for failing to raise construction within the stipulated period when GMADA itself failed to deliver physical possession of the plot within that period.
¶ 14ii.2. Whether the deemed possession clause in the allotment letter (Clause 11, 60 days) can be invoked to treat possession as having been delivered, so as to fix the allottee with default.
¶ 4–5, 1803Law Applied
The Court relied on Clause 11 (possession within 60 days) and Clause 13 (construction within three years) of the allotment letter.
¶ 4, 12, 15A deemed possession clause cannot be read in isolation. It presupposes that the authority can deliver an identifiable, demarcated and legally available plot, and it cannot be used to create a fiction contrary to the actual state of affairs, particularly where litigation prevented delivery.
¶ 5The obligation to raise construction cannot be considered independently of delivery of possession. An allottee is responsible for non-construction only if the plot was made available and she failed to build despite a reasonable opportunity. Mere expiry of the construction period does not establish default where possession was not delivered.
¶ 20The authority bears the burden of showing that possession was offered, since a stipulation alone does not prove an offer.
¶ 18The judgment does not cite any statutory provision or precedent.
04Reasoning
The Court read Clause 11 together with GMADA's own stand. GMADA relied on the litigation stay and incomplete development to show the area was not ready, yet it also charged the allottee for failing to build.
¶ 16–17The Court held that if the plot could not be handed over, the allottee could not reasonably be expected to construct on it.
¶ 17Respondent No. 2's written request of 17.02.2009 was unanswered by any communication fixing a date for possession. The physical handover occurred only on 02.04.2013.
¶ 6, 18Meanwhile GMADA continued to collect instalments and raised non-construction demands. The Court therefore held that the deemed possession clause could not establish that the plot was available.
¶ 18The Court found that the Rs. 4,16,726 demand, raised on 14.03.2013 before physical possession, could not be justified on failure to construct, because GMADA cannot attribute to the allottee a default that resulted from circumstances preventing construction.
¶ 21The Court also noted that the State and National Commissions had concurrently recorded findings on feasibility, litigation and the absence of any offer of possession, and the National Commission found no ground for interference.
¶ 1905Holding
The obligation to construct is dependent on delivery of possession, and a deemed possession clause cannot be invoked where the authority did not in fact make a demarcated plot available.
¶ 5, 20The non-construction demand of Rs. 4,16,726 raised before possession on 02.04.2013 was unjustified.
¶ 21The writ petition is dismissed. The directions of the District Forum, as upheld by the State and National Commissions, remain operative and enforceable according to their terms.
¶ 22Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
¶ 23The judgment does not specify the individual directions in the decision itself.
Original Court PDF
Greater Mohali Area Development Authority (Gmada),vsThe National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
