01Facts
The appellant's predecessor-in-interest was a landowner whose land was acquired by the State.
The Additional District Judge, Fazilka (Reference Court), by award dated 29.04.2016, declined the compensation claimed.
RFA para. 1The appeal was filed with a delay of 3461 days.
CM para. 1 · RFA para. 4The appellant attributed the delay to inability to file along with similarly situated landowners, whose appeals this Court had allowed, and sought parity with them.
CM para. 2The State counsel conceded that the appellant's claim is covered by the judgment in Inderpal v. State of Punjab (RFA No. 1573 of 2018), but argued that the appellant was not entitled to statutory benefits and interest for the period of delay, relying on Supreme Court authority.
CM paras. 3–4 · RFA para. 3On being confronted with the Supreme Court judgments, the appellant's counsel did not contest that, given the inordinate delay, the appellant was not entitled to statutory benefits and interest.
CM para. 702Issues
i.1. Whether the delay of 3461 days in filing the appeal should be condoned in a land acquisition matter.
CM paras. 2, 8–9ii.2. Whether the appellant, whose claim is squarely covered by the earlier decision in Inderpal, is entitled to enhanced compensation at par with similarly situated landowners.
RFA paras. 2–3 · CM para. 2iii.3. Whether the appellant is entitled to statutory benefits and interest under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 for the period of delay.
CM paras. 3–4, 7, 9 · RFA para. 403Law Applied
The Court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in New Okhla Industrial Development Authority v. Rameshwar (2022 SCC OnLine SC 1599), which holds that delay in filing land acquisition appeals may be condoned and enhanced compensation granted, but the acquiring body and beneficiary cannot be saddled with statutory benefits and interest, including the 15% p.a. interest under the Act, for the delayed period.
CM paras. 4–5The Court applied Suresh Kumar v. State of Haryana (2025 SCC OnLine SC 896), which requires a justice-oriented, liberal approach to condonation of delay, with the discretion under limitation law exercised to advance substantial justice; claimants who delay are not to be granted interest for that period (citing Dhiraj Singh, Huchanagouda, and Executive Engineer, Nimna Dudhna Project as examples).
CM para. 5The Court relied on Urban Improvement Trust v. Vidhya Devi (2024 SCC OnLine SC 3725), which deprecates a hyper-technical approach and follows Vidya Devi v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2020) 2 SCC 569 and Maharashtra SRTC v. Balwant Regular Motor Service (1969) 1 SCR 808, holding that delay cannot defeat the right to property under Article 300A, and that laches is an equitable doctrine to be tested on the length of delay and the effect on the parties.
CM para. 6The Court noted that cases of landowners are not to be treated at par with other cases, and that delay is to be condoned irrespective of its length.
CM para. 804Reasoning
The Court first accepted the State's concession that the appellant's claim is covered by Inderpal.
RFA paras. 2–3The Court applied Okhla and Suresh Kumar to hold that the 3461-day delay, though substantial, should be condoned because the appellant's grievance is a claim to just compensation for land lost, and delay alone cannot defeat that right.
CM paras. 2, 6, 8The appellant's reason for delay, namely that landowners were not able to file along with similar cases, was accepted as a basis for parity with landowners whose appeals had been allowed.
CM para. 2To balance the equities and avoid burdening the acquiring body and beneficiary with a financial liability that would increase project costs against public interest, the Court limited relief: the appellant obtains enhanced compensation at par with Inderpal but is excluded from interest and other statutory benefits for the delayed period.
CM para. 9 · RFA para. 4The appellant's counsel's acceptance of this position foreclosed any contest on that point.
CM para. 705Holding
The Court held that the delay of 3461 days is condoned, and the application (CM-4444-CI-2026) is allowed, subject to the condition that the appellants are not entitled to statutory benefits and interest for the delayed period.
CM para. 9In RFA-1747-2026, the appeal is disposed of in terms of the order in Inderpal (RFA No. 1573 of 2018), with the clarification that the appellant is not entitled to interest for the delayed period of 3461 days or other statutory benefits. The judgment does not expressly state the enhanced compensation rate granted and refers only to Inderpal for it. Pending applications stand disposed of.
RFA para. 4 · RFA para. 5Original Court PDF
Lichhma Devi Since Deceased Through LrvsState Of Punjab And Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
