01Facts
The plaintiffs, Narender and Sheela, are children of Smt. Shanti, a daughter of Hukam Chand.
¶ 2–3The plaintiffs sued for a declaration that a registered release deed dated 13.09.2001 in favour of defendants 1 to 3 (Hukam Chand's daughters Phooli, Angoori and Kamla), mutation No. 4262, and two sale deeds dated 05.05.2004 (in favour of defendants 5 to 10) and their mutations were illegal, null and void.
¶ 2–3The plaintiffs claimed a 1/4th share, joint possession, and a permanent injunction.
¶ 2–3The plaintiffs alleged that the release deed was obtained by fraud and misrepresentation, that Hukam Chand was an habitual drinker and was not in his senses when he executed it, and that Smt. Shanti's share was ignored.
¶ 3, 12Defendants 1 to 3 pleaded that Hukam Chand executed the release deed voluntarily, out of love and in return for services rendered, and that the plaintiffs were barred by limitation, estoppel and misjoinder.
¶ 4Defendants 5 to 10 pleaded that they were bona fide purchasers for consideration.
¶ 5Defendant 4 claimed under an agreement to sell dated 19.10.2011.
¶ 6The Trial Court framed seven issues on 25.07.2014.
¶ 8Smt. Shanti died on 23.05.1979; Hukam Chand died in 2003.
¶ 3, 15The plaintiffs first filed suit on 27.02.2012.
¶ 15The Trial Court dismissed the suit on 08.02.2016.
¶ 11The First Appellate Court (Additional District Judge, Sonepat) affirmed on 07.08.2018.
¶ 1, 1102Issues
i.1. Whether the property in the hands of Hukam Chand was joint Hindu family coparcenary (ancestral) property, such that Smt. Shanti and, through her, the plaintiffs acquired an interest by birth.
¶ 13ii.2. Whether the release deed dated 13.09.2001 was vitiated by fraud, misrepresentation, or Hukam Chand's lack of mental capacity or competence to execute it.
¶ 14iii.3. Whether the plaintiffs' prolonged silence and failure to challenge the release deed, the mutation, and the 2004 sale deeds bars or defeats their claim.
¶ 15iv.4. Whether the subsequent sale deeds dated 05.05.2004 are valid, given that defendants 1 to 3 held title under the release deed.
¶ 1503Law Applied
The Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, under which a daughter became a coparcener by birth, does not affect any disposition or alienation made before 20.12.2004.
¶ 13Property which is not joint Hindu family coparcenary property is the self-acquired property of its holder, who may dispose of it as he wishes.
¶ 14A party alleging fraud, misrepresentation, or incapacity bears the burden of leading convincing evidence to prove it.
¶ 14Once a transferee becomes owner under a registered deed, he is competent to further transfer the property.
¶ 15Concurrent findings of fact by the courts below may be interfered with in second appeal only if they are perverse.
¶ 16The judgment does not cite any specific precedent, and it does not separately discuss the bona fide purchaser doctrine (Issue 4 of the Trial Court) or the limitation question.
04Reasoning
The Court first found that Hukam Chand's property was not coparcenary property, since the plaintiffs conceded this during arguments. Smt. Shanti therefore had no interest by birth, and the 2005 amendment could not apply to a disposition executed in 2001.
¶ 13The property was thus Hukam Chand's self-acquired property, which he could validly release to his daughters.
¶ 14On the fraud and incapacity plea, the Court held that the plaintiffs did not prove that Hukam Chand was a drunkard or otherwise incompetent. The attesting witnesses, including the Nambardar, supported due execution, and the plaintiffs' own witnesses conceded the release deed and its mutation.
¶ 14On delay, the Court noted that the release deed was duly reflected in revenue records and that the two 2004 sale deeds and their mutations were also sanctioned without challenge. The plaintiffs did not sue until 2012 and gave no explanation for their silence.
¶ 15Because defendants 1 to 3 had become owners under the release deed, they were competent to sell the property in 2004.
¶ 15Finding no perversity in the concurrent findings, the Court declined to interfere in second appeal.
¶ 1605Holding
The Court held that the property in Hukam Chand's hands was self-acquired, that the plaintiffs failed to prove fraud, misrepresentation or incapacity in the execution of the release deed dated 13.09.2001, and that their unexplained delay in challenging the release deed and the 2004 sale deeds was unexplained.
¶ 14–15The Court found no perversity in the concurrent findings of the courts below.
¶ 16The Regular Second Appeal was dismissed, and the judgments and decrees of the Additional District Judge, Sonepat (07.08.2018) and the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Gohana (08.02.2016) were upheld. Pending miscellaneous applications were disposed of accordingly.
¶ 16–17Original Court PDF
Narender And AnrvsPhooli And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
