01Facts
The petitioner, the complainant in a Section 138 Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 case, challenged the order dated 25.09.2026 of the Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Ratia, dismissing its application under Section 311 CrPC (Section 348 BNSS).
¶ 1The respondent-accused disputed the signatures on cheque Ex. C-1 and pleaded forgery. The Trial Court permitted him to examine a handwriting expert on 12.12.2025.
¶ 2The respondent examined DW-1, the Registry Clerk, Tehsil Ratia, who produced the original record of registered document No. 3392 dated 20.12.2017, exhibited as Ex. D-1. DW-2, handwriting expert Paras Malik, then compared the disputed signatures with those on Ex. D-1.
¶ 3The petitioner applied on 03.04.2026 under Section 311 CrPC for comparison with the respondent's signatures on the judicial order sheets. Its core grievance was that DW-2 relied on a photocopy of Ex. D-1 and ignored later signatures.
¶ 4The respondent opposed the application.
¶ 5The Trial Court dismissed it. It held that Ex. D-1 predated the cheque and was an available standard, that the petitioner had not shown why the order-sheet signatures were more reliable, and that the photocopy objection went to the weight of the evidence, not to the need for fresh examination.
¶ 602Issues
i.1. Whether further expert comparison of the disputed signatures with the respondent's signatures on the judicial order sheets was essential for the just decision of the case under Section 311 CrPC, such that the refusal warranted interference under Section 528 BNSS.
¶ 803Law Applied
The Court relied on Section 311 CrPC (Section 348 BNSS), which confers a discretionary power to summon or recall witnesses at any stage, coupled with a mandatory obligation where the evidence is essential for a just decision.
¶ 9Under Rajaram Prasad Yadav v. State of Bihar (2013) 14 SCC 461, the paramount consideration is whether the evidence is essential to a just decision, and the discretion must be exercised judiciously.
¶ 10K.P. Tamilmaran v. State by DSP, 2025 INSC 576, holds that the necessity must be assessed on the facts of each case. Mere relevance or usefulness is insufficient, and a party has no unqualified entitlement to successive evidentiary opportunities.
¶ 11–12Under Murari Lal v. State of Madhya Pradesh (1980) 1 SCC 704, an expert opinion must be evaluated against its reasons and the other evidence, and the ultimate determination rests with the Court.
¶ 17Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 528Section 348
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 311
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 Section 138
04Reasoning
The Court held that the disputed signatures had already undergone expert examination through DW-2, so the authorship controversy was not unexplored.
¶ 13Ex. D-1 was suitable as a standard: its source was traceable to an official record through DW-1, and its signatures predated the cheque and the dispute.
¶ 14The order-sheet signatures were admissible but were executed after the dispute arose. Their availability did not, by itself, show superior reliability or make their comparison indispensable, and the Trial Court's finding that no cogent reason was shown was not arbitrary.
¶ 15The photocopy objection goes to the probative value of DW-2's opinion, which is a matter of appreciation of evidence, not a ground establishing the statutory necessity for fresh examination.
¶ 16Because the petitioner retained the right to challenge DW-2's opinion on all permissible grounds, its rights were not foreclosed.
¶ 18Applying K.P. Tamilmaran, the mandatory limb of Section 311 was not triggered, since the petitioner had not shown that the proposed comparison was essential.
¶ 19The impugned order rested on a rational nexus to the relevant circumstances and disclosed no patent illegality, perversity, or disregard of material facts, so the Court would not substitute its own discretion.
¶ 2105Holding
The Court held that the proposed further comparison was not essential for the just decision of the case, and that the Trial Court's refusal disclosed no failure of justice warranting interference under Section 528 BNSS.
¶ 23The petition was dismissed and the order dated 25.09.2026 upheld.
¶ 24The Court clarified that rejection of the application does not accept the respondent's forgery defence. The genuineness of the signatures remains for determination on the entire evidence, and the Trial Court must weigh the statutory presumptions and the evidentiary worth of DW-2's opinion independently.
¶ 22, 25The Trial Court was directed to expedite disposal of the complaint from 2020 in accordance with law.
¶ 26Original Court PDF
M/S Madan Lal Tarsem ChandvsThandu Singh
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
