01Facts
The appeals arise from a common award dated 06.08.2002 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ludhiana, concerning a vehicular accident on 04.12.1996 caused by the rash and negligent driving of respondent-driver's vehicle (PB-10-B-9949).
¶ 1Negligence was not challenged, and no cross-objection was filed, so the appeals concern quantum only.
¶ 2FAO-5501-2002 (MACT No. 30/1997): The deceased, Rajinder Kaur, was 24 years old and, per the claimant, earned Rs. 3,000 per month from stitching and embroidery work.
¶ 5FAO-5501-2002 (MACT No. 30/1997): The Tribunal awarded Rs. 90,000 as lump-sum compensation.
¶ 3FAO-5501-2002 (MACT No. 30/1997): No documentary proof of income or vocation was produced.
¶ 5FAO-5501-2002 (MACT No. 30/1997): The claimant (son) sought enhancement.
¶ 3-4FAO-5539-2002 (MACT No. 31/1997): The deceased, Nirmal Singh, was 28 years old and served in the Indian Army. The Tribunal assessed income at Rs. 2,000 per month, applied a multiplier of 15, and awarded Rs. 3,60,000.
¶ 9-10FAO-5539-2002 (MACT No. 31/1997): A salary certificate proved by PW-3 showed a monthly salary of Rs. 3,057.
¶ 12FAO-5539-2002 (MACT No. 31/1997): The claimants (son and mother) sought enhancement.
¶ 9, 1102Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal erred in assessing the deceased's income in FAO-5501-2002, where no documentary evidence was produced, and whether the notional income should be fixed at the 1996 minimum wage for a skilled worker.
¶ 4, 5ii.2. Whether the Tribunal erred in assessing the deceased's income in FAO-5539-2002 at Rs. 2,000 per month instead of the Rs. 3,057 shown in the salary certificate.
¶ 11, 12iii.3. Whether future prospects, the applicable multiplier, and the deduction for personal expenses were correctly applied in each case.
¶ 4, 6, 11, 13iv.4. Whether the claimants are entitled to conventional heads (funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of consortium) under the law laid down by the Supreme Court.
¶ 4, 7, 11, 1403Law Applied
Where income is not proved by documentary evidence, the notional income should be the minimum wage payable to a skilled worker in the relevant year.
¶ 5National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680 is relied on for future prospects: 40% for a deceased with fixed or self-employed income below 40 years, and 50% for a permanent employee below 40 years.
¶ 6, 13Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121 is relied on for the multiplier based on age.
¶ 6, 13Personal-expense deductions are made as one-third where there is one dependant and one-third where there are two.
¶ 6, 13Conventional heads are awarded at Rs. 15,000 for funeral expenses, Rs. 15,000 for loss of estate, and Rs. 40,000 each for parental and filial consortium.
¶ 7, 14A pending reference in Hasina Yasmin & Ors. v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2919, on conventional heads may be relied on by seeking a separate application.
¶ 7, 1404Reasoning
In FAO-5501-2002, the absence of any documentary proof of the Rs. 3,000 income claim led the Court to reject the oral assertion and adopt the 1996 skilled-worker minimum wage of Rs. 1,600.
¶ 5In FAO-5501-2002, adding 40% future prospects (age 24) gave Rs. 2,240. After a one-third deduction, the monthly figure was Rs. 1,493. Applying a multiplier of 18 produced a loss of dependency of Rs. 3,22,488.
¶ 6-8In FAO-5501-2002, with funeral expenses, loss of estate, and parental consortium, the total award was Rs. 3,92,488, an enhancement of Rs. 3,02,488 over the Tribunal's Rs. 90,000.
¶ 7-8In FAO-5539-2002, the Court preferred the documentary salary certificate (Rs. 3,057) over the Tribunal's unexplained Rs. 2,000 figure.
¶ 12, 14In FAO-5539-2002, because the deceased was a permanent Army employee aged 28, the Court applied 50% future prospects, a multiplier of 17, and a one-third deduction for two dependants (son and mother). This yielded Rs. 3,057 as the net monthly dependency and a loss of dependency of Rs. 6,23,628.
¶ 13-15In FAO-5539-2002, with conventional heads of Rs. 15,000 each for funeral expenses and loss of estate, and Rs. 40,000 each for parental and filial consortium, the total award was Rs. 7,33,628, an enhancement of Rs. 3,73,628.
¶ 1505Holding
Both appeals are allowed.
¶ 17In FAO-5501-2002, compensation is enhanced to Rs. 3,92,488, an enhancement of Rs. 3,02,488.
¶ 8, 17In FAO-5539-2002, compensation is enhanced to Rs. 7,33,628, an enhancement of Rs. 3,73,628.
¶ 15, 17Enhanced compensation on the loss of dependency carries 7.5% interest from the date of filing of the claim petition until realization. Conventional heads carry interest from August 2017 until realization. Apportionment and liability follow the Tribunal's award.
¶ 16The claimants may seek the additional conventional-head amounts by application if the Supreme Court decides Hasina Yasmin in their favour.
¶ 7, 14Original Court PDF
Manpreet SinghvsSohan Singh
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
