01Facts
The claimant, Surinder Pal Singh, was injured in a motor accident on 27.09.1999 involving bus PB-06-1050, driven by respondent No. 1.
¶ 1The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Jalandhar, awarded Rs.72,971 on 06.02.2002.
¶ 1 · ¶ 3The Tribunal's findings on rash and negligent driving were not challenged, so only quantum was in issue.
¶ 2The claimant suffered multiple injuries, including fractures, was treated at Guru Teg Bahadur Hospital and then at DMC Hospital, Ludhiana, and claimed treatment expenses of Rs.1,00,000.
¶ 5Paragraph 5 gives the hospitalisation period as 27.09.1996 to 14.10.1996, which conflicts with the accident date of 27.09.1999 in para. 1; this appears to be a typographical error.
¶ 1 · ¶ 5PW-1, Dr. H.L. Mehmi, proved a fracture of the right arm and elbow joint and 20% permanent disability (Ex.P1).
¶ 6PW-2 proved the discharge certificate (Ex.P2).
¶ 6Medicine bills total Rs.12,206 in para. 6 but Rs.12,176 in the Tribunal's award table.
¶ 3 · ¶ 6The claimant pleaded that he was 49 years old, an agriculturist cultivating 10 acres, earning Rs.15,000 per month, and employing a driver for his tractor at Rs.1,000 per month.
¶ 8No revenue record, tractor ownership proof, or driving licence was produced.
¶ 8The Tribunal awarded medicines Rs.12,176; treatment Rs.35,415; arm sling Rs.380; pain and suffering Rs.5,000; and permanent disability Rs.20,000.
¶ 302Issues
i.1. Whether the claimant's loss of earning capacity should be assessed by applying a functional disability of 20% and, if so, on what income base.
¶ 4 · ¶ 7 · ¶ 8ii.2. Whether future prospects should be added to the income for computing loss of earning capacity, and at what percentage.
¶ 4 · ¶ 8iii.3. Whether a multiplier should be applied, and which multiplier applies given the claimant's age.
¶ 4 · ¶ 8iv.4. Whether the claimant is entitled to compensation under the heads of loss of future prospects and amenities, loss of income during treatment, future medical expenses, medical and attendant expenses, and pain and suffering, and if so, in what amounts.
¶ 4 · ¶ 1003Law Applied
Functional disability is determined by the extent of permanent disability together with the nature of the job the injured person performed before the accident.
¶ 7Where income is not proved, the court may adopt the minimum wage for an unskilled worker in the relevant year, here Rs.1,749 per month for 1999.
¶ 8Future prospects of 25% are to be added to income for a claimant aged 49 years, following National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, 2017 (16) SCC 680.
¶ 8The multiplier of 13 is applied according to the claimant's age, following Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation, 2009 (6) SCC 121.
¶ 8Compensation for loss of future prospects and amenities, loss of income during treatment, and medical, transport, special diet and attendant expenses is awarded as a matter of reasonable assessment.
¶ 10No authority is cited for these heads.
Interest at 7.5% from the date of filing the claim petition until realisation is awarded; no authority is cited.
¶ 1204Reasoning
The court found that the injuries to the right arm and elbow joint caused permanent disability and impaired the claimant's earning capacity.
¶ 7Because the claimant produced no proof of income, tractor ownership, or land records, the court rejected the pleaded Rs.15,000 income and adopted the minimum wage of Rs.1,749 per month.
¶ 8The court then applied a functional disability of 20%, which it equated with the medical permanent disability, taking into account the injured limb and the claimant's agricultural occupation.
¶ 8Future prospects of 25% were added to the Rs.1,749 base, giving Rs.2,186; 20% of that figure gives Rs.437 per month.
¶ 8 · ¶ 11Applying the multiplier of 13 and 12 months per year produces Rs.68,172 for loss of earning capacity.
¶ 11The court awarded four months' loss of income during treatment (Rs.6,996) on the basis of the hospitalisation period and the nature of the injuries.
¶ 10The court declined future medical expenses because no evidence of need was produced.
¶ 10Pain and suffering was raised from Rs.5,000 to Rs.50,000, given the nature of the injuries, the treatment, the permanent disability, and the length of hospitalisation.
¶ 10The court granted Rs.75,000 for loss of future prospects, including marriage prospects and amenities of life, and Rs.55,000 as consolidated medical, transport, diet and attendant expenses.
¶ 10The Rs.55,000 figure replaces the Tribunal's Rs.47,971 for these heads.
¶ 1105Holding
The court holds that the claimant is entitled to a total compensation of Rs.2,55,168, against Rs.72,971 awarded by the Tribunal, and so an enhancement of Rs.1,82,197.
¶ 11 · ¶ 13The breakdown is loss of earning capacity Rs.68,172; loss of income during treatment Rs.6,996; medical and attendant expenses Rs.55,000; pain and suffering Rs.50,000; and loss of future prospects and amenities Rs.75,000.
¶ 11The appeal is allowed. Interest at 7.5% per annum runs on the enhanced amount from the date of the claim petition until realisation, and the respondents' liability is to be discharged as per the award.
¶ 12Pending miscellaneous applications are disposed of.
¶ 14Original Court PDF
Surinder Pal SinghvsSulakhan Singh And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
