Punjab and Haryana High CourtCivil LawInsurance Law

P&H HC Raises Compensation For Registered Medical Practitioner's Road Death To Rs 22.77 Lakh, Using District Wage Rates

Sanita Devi And Othersv.Ram Kumar And Anothers

P&H HC Raises Compensation For Registered Medical Practitioner's Road Death To Rs 22.77 Lakh, Using District Wage Rates. Sanita Devi And Others vs Ram Kumar And Anothers. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the deceased's notional income should be assessed on the District Commissioner's rates for skilled workers (Rs. 18,589/- per month) rather than on the minimum wage notification applied by the Tribunal.

The court held

Issue 1 is answered in the affirmative: the deceased's notional income is Rs. 18,589/- per month, as fixed by the DC rates, which are preferred over minimum wages where higher.

It also directed

Issue 2 is answered in the affirmative to the extent of enhancement: total compensation is recomputed at Rs. 22,77,341/-, with consortium awarded to all five claimants.

Issue 3 is answered in the negative: the 7.5% per annum interest from the date of the claim petition is upheld.

The appeal is partly allowed, and the Tribunal's award dated 17.11.2023 in MACP No. 236 of 2022 is modified accordingly. Interest is payable at 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim petition until realisation. Apportionment and withdrawal are to follow the Tribunal's directions at paras. 35-39 of its award, and the enhanced amount is to be paid within eight weeks.

01Facts

On 01.04.2022, Salinder Singh, a 53-year-old Registered Medical Practitioner, was riding a motorcycle when a car (HR-71D-3034), driven by respondent No. 1 (Ram Kumar), struck it from behind. He sustained fatal head injuries and died at LNJP Hospital, Kurukshetra. An FIR was registered under Sections 279 and 304-A IPC.

¶ 2

The claimants (wife, children and parents) filed a claim under Sections 166 and 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, seeking Rs. 60,00,000.

¶ 3

Respondent No. 1 and the insurer (respondent No. 2, Royal Sundaram General Insurance Co.) denied the accident and alleged a collusive FIR.

¶ 4-5

The Tribunal held the accident was caused by respondent No. 1's rash and negligent driving.

¶ 8

Finding no proof of income, the Tribunal assessed the deceased's notional income at Rs. 13,073/- per month under the Haryana minimum wage notification for skilled workers.

¶ 9

The Tribunal applied 10% future prospects, a one-fourth personal expense deduction, and a multiplier of 11. It awarded conventional heads and Rs. 44,000 for spousal consortium, totalling Rs. 15,95,528/- with 7.5% interest.

¶ 9.1-9.2

The claimants appealed on four grounds: (a) income should have been based on District Commissioner (DC) rates; (b) income should have been Rs. 18,589/- per month; (c) no consortium was awarded to the children; and (d) interest at 7.5% was inadequate.

¶ 10

02Issues

i.1. Whether the deceased's notional income should be assessed on the District Commissioner's rates for skilled workers (Rs. 18,589/- per month) rather than on the minimum wage notification applied by the Tribunal.

¶ 13-15.1

ii.2. Whether, on the revised income, the claimants are entitled to enhanced compensation, including the award of loss of consortium to all dependants under the conventional heads.

¶ 16-17.3

iii.3. Whether the 7.5% per annum interest awarded by the Tribunal warrants enhancement.

¶ 18

03Law Applied

Section 171 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, leaves the rate of interest on compensation to the Tribunal's discretion.

¶ 18

Sonia Sharma v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (Civil Appeal No. 8029 of 2026, decided 20.05.2026), following Saroj v. IFFCO Tokio (2024 SCC OnLine SC 3038), holds that DC-notified wage rates, where higher, may be preferred over minimum wages as a measure of notional income, since they better reflect current wages and cannot be confined to one district.

¶ 14

Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) governs multiplier selection (age 51-55: M-11) and personal expense deductions (one-fourth where dependants number four to six).

¶ 16

National Insurance Co. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) governs future prospects (10% for self-employed or fixed-income deceased aged 50-60), conventional heads (Rs. 15,000/- estate, Rs. 40,000/- consortium and Rs. 15,000/- funeral expenses as of 2017, escalated by 10% every three years), and the multiplier's dependence on age.

¶ 16.1

Under Magma General v. Nanu Ram (2018), consortium includes spousal, parental and filial consortium.

¶ 16.2

Under United India Insurance v. Satinder Kaur (2020), consortium is the sole legitimate non-pecuniary head, with loss of love and affection subsumed within it.

¶ 16.3

Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 279

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 166Section 140Section 171

Interest Act, 1978 Section 3

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 34

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 31

04Reasoning

The Tribunal's use of minimum wages was held unsustainable in light of Sonia Sharma. Because the DC rate (Rs. 18,589/-) exceeded the minimum wage (Rs. 13,073/-) and the deceased was a Registered Medical Practitioner, the court adopted the higher DC figure as the notional income.

¶ 15.1

On that income, the court recomputed compensation: annual income of Rs. 2,23,068 plus 10% future prospects (Rs. 2,45,375), less one-fourth personal expenses (Rs. 1,84,031), multiplied by 11 to give Rs. 20,24,341 for loss of dependency.

¶ 17.3

Conventional heads were enhanced per Pranay Sethi for the 4½ years elapsed since 2017: Rs. 16,500 each for loss of estate and funeral expenses. Consortium was awarded at Rs. 44,000 to each of the five claimants, totalling Rs. 2,20,000, which answered ground (c) by extending consortium to the children as well as the spouse.

¶ 17.1-17.2

The court held that the 7.5% interest was a matter of judicial discretion and not arbitrary or inadequate, so no enhancement was warranted.

¶ 18.1

The resulting total of Rs. 22,77,341 exceeds the Tribunal's award by Rs. 6,81,813.

¶ 17.3

05Holding

Issue 1 is answered in the affirmative: the deceased's notional income is Rs. 18,589/- per month, as fixed by the DC rates, which are preferred over minimum wages where higher.

¶ 14, 15.1

Issue 2 is answered in the affirmative to the extent of enhancement: total compensation is recomputed at Rs. 22,77,341/-, with consortium awarded to all five claimants.

¶ 17.2-17.3

Issue 3 is answered in the negative: the 7.5% per annum interest from the date of the claim petition is upheld.

¶ 18.1, 19

The appeal is partly allowed, and the Tribunal's award dated 17.11.2023 in MACP No. 236 of 2022 is modified accordingly. Interest is payable at 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim petition until realisation. Apportionment and withdrawal are to follow the Tribunal's directions at paras. 35-39 of its award, and the enhanced amount is to be paid within eight weeks.

¶ 19-19.2
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Sanita Devi And OthersvsRam Kumar And Anothers

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 13, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment