01Facts
The appellant-claimant, a lab assistant in a sugar mill who worked as a seasonal employee for four months a year at Rs.4,400/- per month, was injured in a motor accident on 26.12.1998 caused by the rash and negligent driving of the respondent-driver's truck (HR-26-A-5785).
¶ 1, 8The respondents did not challenge the Tribunal's finding on negligence, so only quantum was in issue.
¶ 2The Tribunal (Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Gurgaon) awarded Rs.3,19,000/-, comprising loss of income (multiplier 8), Rs.3,000/- for treatment, Rs.80,000/- for pain and suffering, and Rs.1,00,000/- for 70% permanent disability.
¶ 3The claimant suffered multiple injuries, including amputation of the left leg below the knee. He was treated at Safdar Jung Hospital and AIIMS, New Delhi, and was admitted from 26.12.1998 to 01.01.1999.
¶ 5Dr. Alokveer (PW2) and Dr. A. Gaini (PW7) proved the injuries, hospitalisation and discharge summary, and Dr. Akhlaq Ahmed (PW1) certified 70% disability.
¶ 6The claimant was 48 years old at the time of accident, which was not rebutted.
¶ 802Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal erred in not assessing loss of earning capacity on the basis of functional disability, given 70% permanent disability.
¶ 4, 7ii.2. Whether the Tribunal erred in fixing the claimant's annual income at Rs.17,600/- (four months' seasonal wages) rather than the pleaded income, and whether a higher income should be assessed.
¶ 4, 8iii.3. Whether future prospects (25%) should be added to income while computing loss of earning capacity.
¶ 4, 8iv.4. Whether the Tribunal erred in not applying a multiplier, and what multiplier applies.
¶ 4, 8v.5. Whether compensation for loss of future prospects and amenities of life, and for future medical expenses, is payable.
¶ 4, 10, 11vi.6. Whether enhancement of compensation under the heads of medical expenses, pain and suffering, and loss of income during treatment is warranted.
¶ 4, 1003Law Applied
Compensation for loss of earning capacity must be assessed by considering the extent of permanent disability together with the nature of the claimant's pre-accident occupation, so that functional disability, not merely physical disability, governs the assessment.
¶ 7National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, 2017 (16) SCC 680, was applied to add 25% future prospects for a claimant aged 40–50 at the time of accident.
¶ 8Smt. Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation, 2009 (6) SCC 121, was applied to fix the multiplier of 13 according to the claimant's age.
¶ 8Compensation must be just and reasonable for pain and suffering, loss of amenities, medical costs, and loss of income during treatment, having regard to the nature of injuries, treatment, hospitalisation, and permanent disability.
¶ 10, 11Where the income is seasonal, the court treated a skilled worker's remaining months as earning at least minimum wages.
¶ 804Reasoning
The court accepted that amputation below the knee, with 70% disability, would significantly impair the claimant's future earning capacity, so functional disability was fixed at 70%.
¶ 7, 8Since the claimant had only four months of seasonal work, the court held that his skilled status as a lab assistant supported an inference of earnings for the remaining eight months at least at minimum wages. It therefore fixed the annual income at Rs.35,200/-.
¶ 8Applying 25% future prospects (Rs.44,000/-), 70% functional disability (Rs.30,800/-), and a multiplier of 13 yielded loss of earning capacity of Rs.4,00,400/-.
¶ 9, 12The court enhanced pain and suffering to Rs.1,00,000/- and awarded Rs.1,00,000/- for loss of future prospects and amenities, given the 70% disability.
¶ 10It fixed Rs.30,000/- for medical, transport, diet and attendant expenses, Rs.27,000/- for nine months' loss of income during treatment (Rs.3,000/- × 9), and Rs.1,00,000/- for future medical expenses, relying on the artificial limb quotation of Rs.85,000/- (Ex.P28) and the fact of amputation.
¶ 10, 11, 12The court did not expressly reconsider the Tribunal's treatment of the 4,400/- monthly figure beyond adopting the seasonal-income analysis.
¶ 805Holding
The claimant's income should be assessed at Rs.35,200/- per annum, with 25% future prospects, 70% functional disability, and a multiplier of 13, and compensation under the additional heads (future prospects and amenities, future medical expenses, medical expenses, loss of income during treatment, and pain and suffering) was payable as computed.
¶ 8–12The total compensation was re-worked at Rs.7,57,400/-, against the Tribunal's Rs.3,19,000/-, a net enhancement of Rs.4,38,400/-.
¶ 12The appeal was allowed, and the claimant is entitled to interest at 7.5% on the enhanced amount from the date of filing the claim petition until realisation, with the respondents' liability to be determined as per the award.
¶ 13, 14Original Court PDF
(O&M) Girraj SinghvsPhool Singh
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
