Madras High CourtInsurance LawCivil Law

Permanent disability is not automatically loss of earning capacity; without proof of complete vision loss, the multiplier method is unwarranted.

The Branch Managerv.Sakthivel

Permanent disability is not automatically loss of earning capacity; without proof of complete vision loss, the multiplier method is unwarranted.. The Branch Manager vs Sakthivel. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in fixing 90% negligence on the offending vehicle's driver and 10% on the two-wheeler rider.

The court held

The Court held that the 90:10 negligence apportionment was justified on the record, absent contrary evidence.

It also directed

The multiplier-based future earning capacity award was set aside because the record did not establish complete loss of vision or incapacity; a 30% permanent disability was assessed instead.

The award was reduced from Rs. 14,93,080 to Rs. 7,30,350 (Rs. 8,11,500 less 10% contributory negligence), with interest at 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim petition.

The insurer was directed to deposit the amount with accrued interest within eight weeks, after which the claimant may withdraw it, and any excess deposit may be withdrawn by the insurer.

No order as to costs. The connected C.M.P. was closed.

01Facts

On 02.12.2018, the claimant and a friend were standing near Kadambamaram Temple when a two-wheeler carrying another friend as pillion was struck by the offending vehicle, allegedly driven rashly and negligently by the first respondent's driver.

p. 2

The claimant sustained facial injuries and loss of vision in the left eye, and an FIR was registered against the offending vehicle's driver.

pp. 2–3

The claimant filed a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 for Rs. 2,00,000.

p. 2

The insurer of the offending vehicle disputed liability, alleging negligence by the claimant's side and non-maintainability; the insurer of the two-wheeler contended the offending driver was negligent.

p. 3

The claimant examined P.Ws.1–2 and marked Exs. P1–P8 and Ex. C1 (Disability Certificate); R.W.1 was examined and Exs. R1–R2 were marked.

p. 3

The Tribunal apportioned negligence at 90% (offending driver) and 10% (two-wheeler rider) and awarded Rs. 14,93,080, including Rs. 12,70,080 for permanent disability/loss of future earning capacity.

p. 4

The insurer appealed, contending excessive negligence apportionment against the insured driver, that a higher share should fall on the rider given three persons on the two-wheeler, and that the future earning capacity award was excessive.

pp. 4–5

The claimant, a painter, argued the multiplier method was justified.

p. 5

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in fixing 90% negligence on the offending vehicle's driver and 10% on the two-wheeler rider.

p. 6 · ¶ 7(i) · p. 6 · ¶ 8.2

ii.2. Whether the compensation awarded by the Tribunal requires interference.

p. 6 · ¶ 7(ii) · pp. 7–8 · ¶ 9.1–9.4

03Law Applied

The Court's jurisdiction arises under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.

p. 1

Compensation is claimed under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.

p. 2 · ¶ 2.1

On quantum, the Court relied on Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar, (2011) 1 SCC 343, which holds that the court must determine whether the injury has affected the claimant's earning capacity and, if so, to what extent; future loss of earning capacity is then computed by applying the appropriate multiplier to the percentage of functional disability.

p. 7 · ¶ 9.2

On negligence, the Court applied the principle that, absent contrary evidence, the Tribunal's apportionment based on the oral and documentary record will not be disturbed.

p. 6 · ¶ 8.2

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173Section 166

04Reasoning

On negligence, the Court found the insurer adduced no contrary evidence establishing that the entire fault lay with the two-wheeler rider.

p. 6 · ¶ 8.1–8.2

Since the Tribunal's 90:10 finding rested on P.Ws.1–2 and Ex. P1, the Court confirmed it.

p. 6 · ¶ 8.1–8.2

On quantum, the Court accepted that the claimant suffered facial injuries and impaired vision in the left eye, but held there was no evidence of complete loss of vision or complete incapacity to pursue his avocation.

p. 7 · ¶ 9.1, 9.3

The Court concluded that permanent disability could not automatically be treated as functional disability causing total loss of earning capacity, and therefore set aside the multiplier-based award of Rs. 12,70,080.

p. 7 · ¶ 9.3 · p. 8 · ¶ 9.4

In its place, the Court assessed permanent disability at 30% and awarded Rs. 3,00,000 at Rs. 10,000 per percentage point.

p. 8 · ¶ 9.4

The Court further awarded Rs. 1,00,000 each for loss of amenities and loss of convenience, Rs. 70,000 for future medical expenses, and enhanced attendant charges from Rs. 7,000 to Rs. 25,000.

p. 8 · ¶ 9.4

Pain and suffering (Rs. 2,00,000), extra nourishment (Rs. 10,000), medical expenses (Rs. 1,500) and transportation (Rs. 5,000) were confirmed.

pp. 8–9 · ¶ 10

The Court then applied a 10% deduction for contributory negligence.

p. 9 · ¶ 10

05Holding

The Court held that the 90:10 negligence apportionment was justified on the record, absent contrary evidence.

p. 6 · ¶ 8.2

The multiplier-based future earning capacity award was set aside because the record did not establish complete loss of vision or incapacity; a 30% permanent disability was assessed instead.

pp. 7–8 · ¶ 9.3–9.4

The award was reduced from Rs. 14,93,080 to Rs. 7,30,350 (Rs. 8,11,500 less 10% contributory negligence), with interest at 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim petition.

p. 9 · ¶ 11.2 · p. 9 · ¶ 10

The insurer was directed to deposit the amount with accrued interest within eight weeks, after which the claimant may withdraw it, and any excess deposit may be withdrawn by the insurer.

p. 10 · ¶ 11.3–11.4

No order as to costs. The connected C.M.P. was closed.

p. 10
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

The Branch ManagervsSakthivel

Madras High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment