01Facts
The petitioner was appointed to a Class-IV post by the Committee of Management of Khemraj Smarak Rashtriya Vidyapeeth Inter College, Khemapur, Ambedkar Nagar, by order dated 30.12.1995.
¶ 3The District Inspector of Schools (DIOS) approved the appointment on 30.08.1996.
¶ 4On the date of the selection, the petitioner's father, Babban Singh, was the Principal of the institution and remained so until 30.06.2009.
¶ 5By order dated 06.08.2016 and communication dated 21.09.2016, the petitioner was denied salary for the Class-IV post.
¶ 2–3In a parallel matter (Dharmendra Singh), the High Court on 21.05.2015 quashed a DIOS disapproval order and directed fresh consideration, noting that the post had earlier been held by the petitioner, who had been paid salary from 1996 to 2009.
¶ 6The petitioner sought quashing of the 2016 orders, payment of arrears of salary for seven years with consequential benefits, and interest.
¶ 2The petitioner contended that he was not heard and that the DIOS had acknowledged that cancellation was not in accordance with law.
¶ 902Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner's appointment, made in violation of Regulation 4 of Chapter III of the U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921, is void and can be sustained.
¶ 7, 11(i)–(ii)ii.2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to protection against termination, reinstatement, and payment of arrears and interest on the ground of long service, relying on Rajendra Prasad Srivastava (1994).
¶ 8, 11(iii)–(v)iii.3. Whether the petitioner's contentions regarding denial of hearing and the DIOS's stated view on legality warrant interference.
¶ 9, 11(ii)03Law Applied
Regulation 4 of Chapter III of the U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921, bars appointment of a teacher, Principal or Headmaster who is related to a Committee of Management member.
¶ 7Regulation 22 extends this bar to clerks, and Regulation 100 extends it to peons, so the prohibition covers Class-IV posts.
¶ 8 (¶4), 11(ii)An appointment dehors the rules is void.
¶ 11(i)Division Bench decision in Rajendra Prasad Srivastava v. DIOS (1994) declined to unsettle long-serving employees whose appointments were irregular.
¶ 8Man Singh v. State of U.P. (SC, 31.03.2022) denied reinstatement but granted pensionary benefits and protection against recovery of salary for work done.
¶ 11(iii)District Basic Education Officer v. Dhananjai Kumar Shukla (2008) holds that an appointment contrary to mandatory rules is a nullity, and that conduct designed to defeat statutory provisions amounts to fraud on the administration.
¶ 11(v)The maxim dura lex sed lex was invoked.
¶ 11(viii)Provisions in the judgment · 1
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 Section 56
04Reasoning
The petitioner's father was the Principal, and therefore an ex officio member of the Committee of Management at the time of appointment. The petitioner thus fell within the prohibited category of relatives under Regulation 4, read with Regulations 22 and 100, and the appointment was void.
¶ 11(i)–(ii)The defect could not be cured by the petitioner's subsequent service. Rajendra Prasad Srivastava was distinguished on the facts: the employee there served about 20 years, whereas the petitioner served about 13 years (until 2009).
¶ 11(v)Dhananjai Kumar Shukla and Man Singh precluded the relief granted in Rajendra Prasad Srivastava.
¶ 11(v)Under Man Singh, even a long-serving employee whose appointment was cancelled was entitled only to pensionary benefits and protection from recovery, not reinstatement.
¶ 11(iii)The defect surfaced only when the father retired, and the father's appointment of his own children reflected an illegality that could not be allowed to continue.
¶ 11(vi)–(vii)Since the appointment was void, the petitioner's hearing and DIOS-view grounds need not be examined.
¶ 11(ii)05Holding
The petitioner's appointment, being in breach of Regulation 4 of Chapter III (read with Regulations 22 and 100) of the 1921 Act, is void and cannot be saved.
¶ 11(i)–(ii)Long service does not entitle the petitioner to the protection granted in Rajendra Prasad Srivastava, which is not applicable here in light of Man Singh and Dhananjai Kumar Shukla. The prayers for quashing the impugned orders, reinstatement and continuation in service, arrears of salary, and interest are rejected. The court directed that no recovery be made by the authorities, including State authorities, of any amount paid for work already done. The writ petition is dismissed.
¶ 11, 11(iv), 11(v), 12Original Court PDF
Pradeep Kumar SinghvsState Of U.P. Thru. Secy. Secondary Education And Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
