01Facts
Two persons were fatally shot on 07.11.1986 in Village Malak-Doshi Patti, P.S. Chanda, District Sultanpur, while ploughing disputed agricultural land (Chak No. 338, Plot No. 907).
¶ 4–7The deceased were Farooq, husband of the informant Smt. Tahrun Nisa (P.W.-1), and Quddoos, their son.
¶ 4–7The accused were Mohammad Islam Khan (single-barrel 12-bore gun), Riazuddin Khan (double-barrel 12-bore gun) and Samruddin Khan (lathi), all sons of Muneer Khan.
¶ 4–7The dispute arose from a 1973 registered gift deed (hibanama) of Sher Ali's land by his widow in favour of her two daughters, followed by prolonged mutation litigation and threats.
¶ 4–5, 73, 76Per the prosecution, Samruddin exhorted, Islam shot Farooq, and Riazuddin shot Quddoos when he rushed to lift his father.
¶ 7The Chik FIR was registered at 11:00 A.M. on the informant's dictated tahrir, for an incident at about 9:00 A.M.
¶ 8, 26–28Quddoos was referred to the District Hospital, Sultanpur, where he died.
¶ 8The investigation recovered four 12-bore pellets and two licensed guns deposited with arms dealers, but no ballistic examination was conducted.
¶ 9–10, 19, 67The autopsy noted firearm injuries on both deceased and also blunt-force lacerated wounds on the skull/mastoid region.
¶ 55–58The accused pleaded false implication and denied presence at the spot.
¶ 13–14The Sessions Judge rejected the alleged dying declaration (Ex. Ka-13), accepted the eyewitness testimony of P.W.-1 to P.W.-3, acquitted Samruddin Khan by giving him the benefit of doubt, and convicted Islam Khan and Riazuddin Khan under Section 302 IPC simpliciter and Section 302 r/w 34 IPC, sentencing each to life imprisonment.
¶ 3, 15–1602Issues
i.1. Whether the FIR (Ex. Ka-11) was prompt or ante-timed, and whether discrepancies between the Chik FIR, G.D. and inquest report affect the core of the prosecution case.
¶ 24(i), 26–31ii.2. Whether the eyewitness testimony of P.W.-1, P.W.-2 and P.W.-3 is credible and trustworthy.
¶ 24(ii), 32–53iii.3. Whether there is an irreconcilable conflict between ocular and medical evidence, and whether the non-explanation of blunt-force lacerations affects the prosecution case.
¶ 24(iii), 54–66iv.4. Whether non-examination of the seized guns and pellets by a ballistic expert is fatal to the prosecution.
¶ 24(iv), 67–69v.5. Whether the acquittal of Samruddin Khan entitles the appellants to parity.
¶ 24(v), 70–71vi.6. Whether the findings of conviction warrant interference in appeal.
¶ 24(vi), 76–7803Law Applied
The court applied Section 302 IPC and Section 34 IPC on common intention.
¶ 3, 78Under Section 134 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, quality, not quantity, of evidence governs; oral testimony is classified as wholly reliable, wholly unreliable, or neither, and the third category requires corroboration in material particulars (Vadivelu Thevar, Lallu Manjhi, Khema @ Khem Chandra).
¶ 33Rustic and illiterate witnesses should not be discredited on technical grounds for imprecision in time or distance (State of U.P. v. Chhotey Lal; Dimple Gupta; State of Punjab v. Hakam Singh), and inconsistencies arising from prolonged cross-examination of a rustic witness are not to be magnified (State of U.P. v. Krishna Master).
¶ 36–37Presence of "chance witnesses" is not suspicious, since murders occur without notice (Rana Pratap v. State of Haryana).
¶ 46Falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus is not a rule of law in India; the court separates grain from chaff (Ugar Ahir; Gangadhar Behera).
¶ 42–44Under Abdul Sayeed, ocular evidence prevails over medical opinion unless medical evidence completely rules out the ocular version; the same principle is reflected in Harban Sahai and Thaman Kumar.
¶ 61–64Non-examination by a ballistic expert is not fatal where ocular testimony is credible (Maqbool; Dhanna Singh).
¶ 68–69An inquest report under Section 174 CrPC is not substantive evidence, and omissions in it do not render the FIR ante-timed (Brahm Swaroop).
¶ 29–30Parity in acquittal depends on identical roles (Javed Shaukat Ali Qureshi).
¶ 70–71Enmity is a double-edged weapon that may supply motive (State of U.P. v. Kishanpal; Ramashish Rai).
¶ 75Dying declarations under Section 32(1) of the Evidence Act require credible recording and are not admissible where the statement is implausible (Pakala Narayana Swami).
¶ 22, 72Provisions in the judgment · 9 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 374Section 209Section 161Section 313Section 233Section 174
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 302Section 307Section 34
04Reasoning
On the FIR, the court held that the 12 km/17 km distance discrepancy between the Chik FIR and inquest report did not show ante-timing, since the inquest already recorded the case crime number and sections, and the discrepancies are immaterial under Brahm Swaroop.
¶ 27, 29–31P.W.-1 was held to be a rustic, illiterate witness whose presence was established because her parental property lay in the village; her inability to state precise distances was not material.
¶ 34–40Her false statement about Rukmuddin's presence was treated as an error regarding an uncharged person, which did not discredit the remainder of her testimony.
¶ 42, 44P.W.-2 and P.W.-3 were held to be natural witnesses whose presence was explained (tracing a village Pradhan and going to a market) and who were not relatives; minor discrepancies were held immaterial.
¶ 45–53On medical evidence, the court reasoned that injuries sustained during dynamic ploughing or a fall onto hard ridges or the water channel could account for the lacerations, and the autopsy surgeon could not rule this out.
¶ 59–60The pellet recoveries from both bodies matched the firearm testimony, and absence of tattooing was held not to negate the ocular account.
¶ 63, 66Since the ballistic examination was omitted but ocular evidence was credible, the omission was not fatal.
¶ 69Samruddin's role (lathi and exhortation only) was materially different from the appellants' role of firing lethal shots, so parity was refused.
¶ 71The alleged dying declaration was rejected because the structured, lengthy narrative was inconsistent with the injuries described in the autopsy, and its rejection did not affect the ocular case.
¶ 72Enmity over the land was admitted by the defence and was held to furnish motive.
¶ 74–7505Holding
The court held that the FIR was lodged promptly and was not ante-timed, that P.W.-1 to P.W.-3 are wholly reliable and their presence is established, that no irreconcilable conflict exists between ocular and medical evidence, that non-examination of weapons by a ballistic expert is not fatal, and that the acquittal of Samruddin Khan does not entitle the appellants to parity.
¶ 76The conviction under Section 302 IPC simpliciter and Section 302 r/w 34 IPC is upheld, and the appeal is dismissed.
¶ 77–78The Sessions Court judgment dated 05.09.1992 in Sessions Trial No. 47 of 1987 is affirmed. The appellants' bail bonds are cancelled, their sureties discharged, and the CJM, Sultanpur, is directed to ensure their arrest and custody to serve the life sentence. The trial court record is to be transmitted forthwith.
¶ 79–80Original Court PDF
Mohd. Islam Khan And AnothervsState Of U.P.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
