Allahabad High CourtAdministrative and Public LawContract Law

Bidder Who Refused To Match Rival's Rate Has No Right To Contract, Allahabad HC Rules, But Allows Acceptance Within A Week

M/S Shiv Anant Enterprisesv.State Of U.P. And 3 Others

Bidder Who Refused To Match Rival's Rate Has No Right To Contract, Allahabad HC Rules, But Allows Acceptance Within A Week. M/S Shiv Anant Enterprises vs State Of U.P. And 3 Others. Allahabad High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the petitioner, as L-2 bidder whose L-1 rival was found technically non-responsive, acquired an enforceable right to be awarded the contract at his own quoted rate.

The court held

The petitioner, even if treated as the highest bidder, has no indefeasible right to the contract, and the writ petition, as framed, fails.

It also directed

The cancellation of the earlier tender and the fresh tender were neither arbitrary nor mala fide, and the Block Nath Nagar case provides no parity.

The petitioner was granted liberty to file a fresh representation consenting to execute the work at the L-1 rate offered by M/s Hamara Pump within one week, and the State authorities were directed to honour such consent and execute the work order promptly, if there is no other legal impediment.

The writ petition was disposed of, and costs were made easy.

01Facts

The State Food Controller's office (Basti Division) invited a very short-term e-tender (single-stage door-step delivery) on 08.09.2026 for transporting food grains to public distribution points in Block Bansi, District Siddharth Nagar.

¶ 3.7 · ¶ 4

Three bidders participated: M/s Hamara Pump (L-1), the petitioner (L-2), and M/s Om Traders (L-3).

¶ 3.8 · ¶ 3.9

The technical bids were found responsive, but the petitioner objected that Hamara Pump's vehicle was a registered tanker used for petroleum products, not a food-grain carrier, which contravened Appendix-1 of the tender.

¶ 3.9 · ¶ 38

A work order was issued to Hamara Pump on 23.09.2026, and was later cancelled on the technical-bid complaint.

¶ 3.10–3.11

The Court notes the cancellation date is stated as 26.09.2026 in one place and 24.09.2026 in the State's pleading.

¶ 3.11 · ¶ 6

On 26.09.2026, the Department asked L-2 and L-3 to consent to perform at L-1's rate.

¶ 3.12 · ¶ 5

The petitioner refused, insisting that as L-2 he was effectively L-1 and should receive the contract at his own rate.

¶ 9 · ¶ 13–14

On 29.09.2026, the Department cancelled the earlier tender (Letter No. 1387) and issued a fresh tender (Letter No. 1386), both dated the same day, with the letter numbers apparently interchanged.

¶ 30–31

The petitioner sought parity with Block Nath Nagar, where the L-1 bidder was disqualified and the L-2 bidder (M/s Pratap Enterprises) accepted the L-1 rate and was awarded the work.

¶ 7–8 · ¶ 27–28 · ¶ 32

The petitioner challenged both orders and sought a direction to award him the contract at his rate.

¶ 2

02Issues

i.1. Whether the petitioner, as L-2 bidder whose L-1 rival was found technically non-responsive, acquired an enforceable right to be awarded the contract at his own quoted rate.

¶ 38–41

ii.2. Whether the cancellation of the earlier tender and issuance of a fresh tender were arbitrary, mala fide, or violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.

¶ 13 · ¶ 30–33 · ¶ 36–37

iii.3. Whether the petitioner is entitled to parity with the Block Nath Nagar tender process.

¶ 27–29

03Law Applied

Article 14 of the Constitution requires the State to act fairly, transparently, and without arbitrariness even in contractual dealings.

¶ 36–37

The Uttar Pradesh Procurement Manual (Procurement of Goods), Chapters 13 and 14, permit rejection of unresponsive bids, require reasons for annulling a bidding process, and restrict post-tender negotiation with L-1.

¶ 10 · ¶ 14.22

Under U.P. Avas Evam Vikas Parishad v. Om Prakash Sharma (2013) 5 SCC 182, drawing on Meerut Development Authority and Rajasthan Housing Board, a bidder has only a right to equality and fair treatment, the authority may decline the highest bid, and no vested right arises until the bid is accepted.

¶ 35

Under State of Orissa v. Harinarayan Jaiswal (1972) 2 SCC 36, the State may validly reject a bid in protection of public revenue.

¶ 35

Under Section 4 of the Indian Contract Act, a contract is not concluded until acceptance is communicated.

¶ 40

Under Save Mon Region Federation v. State of Arunachal Pradesh, 2026 SCC OnLine SC 526, public procurement must be transparent and non-arbitrary.

¶ 26

The authorities relied on by the petitioner (Inderjit Mehta, S.B. Transport, and West Bengal Electricity Board v. Patel Engineering) were cited, but the Court did not expressly adopt them in its reasoning.

¶ 17–19

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Indian Contract Act, 1872 Section 4

04Reasoning

The Court accepted that the petitioner could be treated as the de facto highest bidder once Hamara Pump's technical bid was found flawed, but held that this status conferred no indefeasible right to the contract, since no order accepting the bid had been passed and no concluded contract existed.

¶ 38 · ¶ 40

The petitioner's remaining entitlement was limited to equality and fair treatment, together with the opportunity to negotiate, which the Department offered on 26.09.2026 and the petitioner refused.

¶ 38–39

The Court found no mala fides, since none was alleged or evident from the record, and cancellation was justified because no bidder would perform at the L-1 rate, with the Department acting in the public interest and to protect revenue.

¶ 38

The Court treated the Block Nath Nagar parity claim as factually distinct: there the L-2 bidder accepted the L-1 rate and the contract was awarded in accordance with the rules, whereas here the petitioner declined.

¶ 27–28 · ¶ 32

The same-day issuance of the cancellation and fresh-tender orders, with interchanged letter numbers, was treated as an inadvertent error that did not prejudice the petitioner, and the authorities were cautioned to take greater care in future.

¶ 30–31

Because the technical bids under the fresh tender had not yet been opened, no rights had crystallised for any bidder.

¶ 34 · ¶ 41

05Holding

The petitioner, even if treated as the highest bidder, has no indefeasible right to the contract, and the writ petition, as framed, fails.

¶ 41

The cancellation of the earlier tender and the fresh tender were neither arbitrary nor mala fide, and the Block Nath Nagar case provides no parity.

¶ 30–33 · ¶ 38

The petitioner was granted liberty to file a fresh representation consenting to execute the work at the L-1 rate offered by M/s Hamara Pump within one week, and the State authorities were directed to honour such consent and execute the work order promptly, if there is no other legal impediment.

¶ 42–43

The writ petition was disposed of, and costs were made easy.

¶ 44 · ¶ 45
Allahabad High Court

Original Court PDF

M/S Shiv Anant EnterprisesvsState Of U.P. And 3 Others

Allahabad High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment