01Facts
The petitioner applied for the post of Constable under the sportsman quota in cross-country sports, against an advertisement dated 12.12.2023 and a relaxation notification dated 03.01.2024. Twelve posts were available in that stream.
¶ 3, 5Of 306 applicants, the petitioner was at Serial No. 228 in the Board's list, while Indrajeet and Ravi Kumar Pal were at Serial Nos. 151 and 245.
¶ 5Document verification was held on 27–28.03.2026, followed by the trial. Ravi Kumar Pal, Ashish Kumar Patel and Rohan Kumar were allowed to participate in the trial although they were not in the verification list.
¶ 3, 3.1By notice dated 03.11.2025, the Board allowed three days for candidates to submit missing documents with reasons, after which no representation would be considered.
¶ 5, 5.1Ten representations were received, and seven candidates were admitted to the trials.
¶ 4.1, 4.2Ravi Kumar Pal, Ashish Kumar Patel and Rohan Kumar submitted their representations with certificates on 27.03.2026, beyond the three-day window, yet were permitted to trial; Ravi Kumar Pal was later declared successful.
¶ 4.2The Board first prepared a list of 120 eligible candidates, in which the petitioner appears at Serial No. 113 and the three disputed candidates do not appear.
¶ 5.2, 5.4A later list of 126 candidates included Indrajeet, Ravi Kumar Pal and Ashish Kumar Patel, without recorded reasons.
¶ 5.5, 5.6The respondents did not place the representations or the orders on them before the Court.
¶ 4.1The petitioner challenged the final list dated 17.07.2026.
¶ 202Issues
i.1. Whether candidates who submitted documents after the expiry of the three-day period fixed by the notice dated 03.11.2025, and who were admitted to the trial without a recorded order, could validly be included in the selection process.
¶ 5.6, 5.7, 6ii.2. Whether the subsequently prepared list of 126 candidates, which added names to the list of 120 eligible candidates without reasons, is legally sustainable.
¶ 5.6, 6iii.3. Whether the petitioner is entitled to the relief of quashing the final list dated 17.07.2026.
¶ 2, 6, 703Law Applied
The Court's reasoning rests on the notice dated 03.11.2025, which fixed a three-day period for submitting missing documents and provided that no representation would be considered after that period.
¶ 5, 5.1The State relied on the U.P. Police (Kushal Khiladiyon Ki Bharti Evam Bina Paari Padonnati) Niyamavali, 2021, and para 9.13 of the Board's Nirdesh Pustika, under which documents not enclosed with the application may be accepted at verification. The judgment does not expressly rule on para 9.13.
¶ 4A selection authority must follow the prescribed procedure, and candidates admitted outside it, without a reasoned order, have no legal standing.
¶ 4.1, 6, 5.7An adverse inference may be drawn from the non-production of the representations and orders.
¶ 4.1, 6, 5.7No precedent is cited in the judgment.
04Reasoning
The Court held that the three-day window in the notice of 03.11.2025 was binding. Once it expired, the Board prepared and published a list of 120 eligible candidates.
¶ 5.2, 5.6Ravi Kumar Pal, Ashish Kumar Patel and Rohan Kumar submitted their representations on 27.03.2026, after that period, yet were permitted to trial.
¶ 4.2The Court found that the Board later added further names to a list of 126 candidates without disclosing reasons.
¶ 5.6The respondents placed no order on record permitting the six candidates to participate, despite the Court's directions.
¶ 5.7The Court held that the admission of Ganesh Kumar Bind, Indra Jeet, Ashish Kumar, Rohan Kumar, Ravi Kumar Pal and Ashish Kumar Patel was illegal, being contrary to the notice of 03.11.2025 and not in accordance with the prescribed procedure, and that the list of persons outside the 120-candidate list was non est.
¶ 6The Court's remedy was to direct selection on the basis of the 120-candidate list, which includes the petitioner at Serial No. 113. The Court did not decide the petitioner's merit on the basis of the twelve posts.
¶ 5.2, 705Holding
Candidates admitted after the expiry of the notice period, without a recorded reasoned order, were illegally included, and the list of persons outside the 120-candidate list is non est.
¶ 6The petition is allowed.
¶ 8The Chairman, U.P. Police Recruitment and Promotion Board, is directed to finalise the selection on the basis of the 120-candidate list published pursuant to the notice dated 03.11.2025. If the petitioner is found suitable, the appointment exercise is to be completed within six weeks by a reasoned and speaking order.
¶ 7The Court did not expressly quash the list of 17.07.2026. Its operative effect is to declare the inclusion of the six candidates non est and to confine selection to the 120-candidate list.
¶ 6, 7Original Court PDF
Nitish KumarvsState Of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home Lko. And 2 Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
