01Facts
The petitioners are the brothers of Anil Kumar Pathak, who died intestate.
¶ 2The date of death is recorded as 04.12.2016.
¶ 2The date of death is recorded as 14.12.2016.
¶ 12His wife, Sheela Pathak, died on 04.08.2009.
¶ 12Respondent no. 5 was born on 08.05.1997 and claims to be Anil's son.
¶ 12On 04.05.2017, the petitioners' names were recorded through an uncontested P.A. entry.
¶ 3Respondent no. 5 later applied to the Tehsildar, which set aside that entry on 05.11.2024 and declared him Anil's son.
¶ 3The petitioners' appeal was allowed on 08.08.2025 and the matter was remanded.
¶ 4On remand, the Tehsildar again ruled for respondent no. 5 on 13.02.2026.
¶ 4The Sub-Divisional Officer upheld this on 10.04.2026, and the Additional Commissioner dismissed the revision on 22.10.2026.
¶ 4Evidence relied upon included respondent no. 5's school admission record (2001), in which Anil and Sheela are recorded as parents.
¶ 13Respondent no. 5 was described as son in a life insurance nomination and a Punjab National Bank account of Anil.
¶ 13The Assistant Municipal Commissioner rejected the petitioners' objections and entered respondent no. 5's name in a municipal mutation order.
¶ 14The petitioners relied on an affidavit allegedly filed by Anil before the Nagar Nigam after Sheela's death, stating he was her only heir. The court noted this affidavit was not on record.
¶ 6, 12The petitioners contended that respondent no. 5 never held actual possession of the land.
¶ 702Issues
i.1. Whether "possession" under Section 33 of the U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 in succession-based mutation means legal (de jure) possession or actual and physical possession.
¶ 7, 8, 18–21ii.2. Whether the mutation courts acted without jurisdiction by adjudicating heirship and title in proceedings under Sections 33/34 of the Code.
¶ 5, 16–17, 26iii.3. Whether the writ petition is maintainable against the impugned mutation orders.
¶ 8, 1003Law Applied
Section 33 of the U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 governs mutation on succession. Under Section 33(2)(a), uncontested succession is recorded directly, while under Section 33(2)(b) a contested case requires inquiry.
¶ 15, 17The word "possession" in Section 33 is not qualified by "actual" or "physical," so it means legal possession, and succession by operation of law carries de jure possession even without physical occupation.
¶ 18–19The court distinguished de facto possession (actual control) from de jure possession (legal entitlement).
¶ 20Under Section 39 of the Code, rights in land may be established by a suit under Section 144, and mutation orders remain subject and subservient to adjudication in regular proceedings.
¶ 26The court relied on the Smt. Kalawati exception for orders passed without jurisdiction.
¶ 10The precedents Sahed Jan @ Bonde, Smt. Hadisul Nisha, and Amar Nath Arora were considered and distinguished on facts or scope.
¶ 7, 22–25Provisions in the judgment · 6
U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 Section 9Section 33Section 34Section 39Section 144
U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1950 Section 229B
04Reasoning
A contested succession necessarily requires the mutation court to examine whether the deceased left a successor, so heirship is a permissible incident of inquiry under Section 33(2)(b).
¶ 17Treating physical occupation as decisive would give undue advantage to the successor in possession and exclude other lawful successors.
¶ 21The authorities had assessed the school record, insurance nomination, bank nomination and municipal entry, and had not ignored material evidence.
¶ 13–14, 24, 26The unregistered affidavit was given little weight because it was not on record and was filed when respondent no. 5 was a minor, so it did not require him to be named.
¶ 12The court treated the Section 34 reference in the orders as a misdescription that did not alter the Section 33 nature of the proceedings.
¶ 16Sahed Jan and Hadisul Nisha were distinguished because of their different facts, including a revisional finding based on a lekhpal report and a title-deed-based mutation.
¶ 22–23Amar Nath Arora concerned transfer under Section 34 and was held inapplicable.
¶ 25Because the authorities considered the evidence and acted within the Section 33 framework, no jurisdictional error arose, so the Kalawati exception was not attracted.
¶ 10, 2605Holding
In succession-based mutation under Section 33, "possession" means legal (de jure) possession, not merely actual physical possession.
¶ 18–20The mutation authorities had jurisdiction to determine contested heirship, and their orders were not without jurisdiction.
¶ 17, 26The writ petition was dismissed, and the orders dated 13.02.2026, 10.04.2026 and 22.10.2026 were not interfered with.
¶ 27The dismissal is without prejudice: if the petitioners establish in regular proceedings before a revenue or civil court that respondent no. 5 did not succeed to the estate, the mutation orders will abide by that adjudication. Until then, the orders remain operative and their consequences follow.
¶ 27Original Court PDF
Rakesh Kumar Pathak And AnothervsThe State Of U.P. And 4 Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
