Delhi High Court
Administrative and Public LawHuman Rights Law

Provisional food vendors may operate from an alternative site subject to strict safety and non-obstruction conditions.

Sona Wati vs Municipal Corporation Of Delhi And Ors

Delhi High CourtJUDGMENT: September 10, 20263 MIN READSOURCE JUDGMENT
Provisional food vendors may operate from an alternative site subject to strict safety and non-obstruction conditions.. Sona Wati vs Municipal Corporation Of Delhi And Ors. Delhi High Court. LawLens
THE ORIGINAL LAWLENS SUMMARY
01

Facts

The Petitioner held a provisional Certificate of Vending (CoV), URI No. 4494050, under the category “Food/Snack with gas cylinder/fire,” with the place of vending identified as Central Zone, Ward-S-82.

Source reference: p.1, para.3

She sought directions permitting her to vend peacefully at the Open Space, Madhya Marg, adjoining the Booster Pump Boundary Wall, Tughlakabad Extension, New Delhi.

Source reference: p.1, para.2

The Petitioner alleged that the Respondents were disrupting her vending activities.

Source reference: p.2, para.4

The Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) opposed unrestricted vending at the site, contending that the road was narrow and that pedestrian and vehicular movement was impeded.

Source reference: p.2, para.5

It further stated that vendors gathered in the evening and placed benches and stools for customers.

Source reference: p.2, para.6

The Court also considered photographs of the vending activity placed on record.

Source reference: p.3, para.7; p.4, para.8
02

Issues

1. Whether the Petitioner, holding a provisional CoV for vending food/snacks using a gas cylinder or fire, should be permitted to continue vending at or near the stated vending site, subject to regulatory and public-safety conditions.

Source reference: p.1, paras.2–4; p.4, para.8

2. Whether the MCD should identify an alternative vending space in the vicinity so that the Petitioner’s vending does not obstruct pedestrian or vehicular movement.

Source reference: p.2, paras.5–6; p.5, para.8(i)

3. Whether restrictions should be imposed concerning the size of the gas cylinder, maintenance of cleanliness, prevention of obstruction, transfer or subletting of the CoV, and construction at the vending site.

Source reference: p.5, paras.8(ii)–(viii)
03

Law Applied

The Court applied the Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Act, 2014, particularly Section 21, under which the Town Vending Committee may formulate a vending plan governing the location and regulation of street vending.

Source reference: p.6, para.10

The Court also applied the conditions attached to the Petitioner’s provisional CoV, while directing that Condition No. 11 would not apply subject to compliance with the safeguards imposed by the Court.

Source reference: p.5, para.8(vi)

The governing principles were that a vendor holding a provisional CoV may vend subject to public-safety, traffic, hygiene and non-obstruction requirements, and that such permission does not create a vested right or permit creation of third-party interests, subletting, or permanent or temporary construction.

Source reference: p.5, paras.8(ii)–(viii); p.6, para.10

The Court also followed the approach adopted in Rajendra Singh v. Commissioner of Police & Ors., W.P.(C) 15082/2025, order dated 2 February 2026; Mohd Badruddin v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi & Ors., W.P.(C) 19391/2025, order dated 8 January 2026; and Rihana v. MCD & Ors., W.P.(C) 1609/2026, order dated 5 February 2026, concerning vendors operating under the category “Food/Snack with gas cylinder/fire”.

Source reference: p.4, para.8
04

Reasoning

The Court balanced the Petitioner’s entitlement to vend under her provisional CoV against the MCD’s legitimate concerns regarding obstruction and public safety.

Source reference: no citation

Since the vending site was situated near a narrow road where vendors allegedly congregated and placed seating for customers, unrestricted vending could impede pedestrian and vehicular movement.

Source reference: p.2, paras.5–6

Following the safeguards imposed in similar cases, the Court directed the concerned Assistant Commissioner to identify an alternative site in the vicinity within two weeks.

Source reference: p.5, para.8(i)

At the same time, it permitted the Petitioner to operate her vend, subject to use of only a small gas cylinder, restriction of the vend to a defined space, prevention of traffic or pedestrian obstruction, maintenance of cleanliness and hygiene, and provision of a dustbin.

Source reference: p.5, paras.8(ii)–(v)

The Court further protected the regulatory character of the provisional CoV by prohibiting transfer, subletting, third-party interests and construction, and by making the directions subject to any vending plan formulated under Section 21 of the 2014 Act.

Source reference: p.5, para.8(vii)–(viii); p.6, para.10
05

Holding

The petition was disposed of with directions that the concerned Assistant Commissioner identify an alternative vending space for the Petitioner within two weeks.

The Petitioner was permitted to operate her food/snack vend subject to the provisional CoV and the Court-imposed conditions, including use of only a small gas cylinder, vending within a defined non-obstructive space, maintenance of hygiene and a dustbin, and compliance with all CoV conditions other than Condition No. 11.

Source reference: p.5, paras.8(ii)–(vi)

She was prohibited from creating any third-party interest, subletting or handing over possession of the CoV, and from undertaking any permanent or temporary construction.

Source reference: p.5, paras.8(vii)–(viii)

The Petitioner was directed to approach the concerned Assistant Commissioner on 17 September 2026 at 11:30 a.m.

Source reference: p.6, para.9

The directions were made subject to the vending plan of Town Vending Committee-II under Section 21 of the 2014 Act, with no vested rights being created.

Source reference: p.6, para.10
06

Acts & Sections Cited

1 provisions across 1 statute referred to in this judgment. Each provision opens on LawLens.

Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Act, 20141

Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Sona WativsMunicipal Corporation Of Delhi And Ors

Delhi High Court · September 10, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment