Rajasthan High CourtTax LawInsurance Law

Rajasthan HC Full Bench: Motor Accident Interest Up To Award Not Taxable, Insurers Cannot Deduct TDS

SATYA NARAYAN S/O SHRI KHARBUJA,v.THE H.D.F.C IRGO GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED

Rajasthan HC Full Bench: Motor Accident Interest Up To Award Not Taxable, Insurers Cannot Deduct TDS. SATYA NARAYAN S/O SHRI KHARBUJA, vs THE H.D.F.C IRGO GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY  LIMITED. Rajasthan High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether interest awarded under Section 171 of the MV Act is exigible to income tax and, consequently, whether the insurer is required to deduct TDS under Section 194A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ("1961 Act").

The court held

(a) Section 171 MV Act interest, for the period from the claim petition to the award (or to the appellate judgment), is an integral part of compensation, is not "interest" under Section 2(28A), is not chargeable under Sections 56(1) or 56(2)(viii) read with Section 145B(1), and therefore attracts no TDS under Section 194A.

It also directed

(b) Kailash Narain Gupta and Sharda Pareek do not lay down the correct law to the extent contrary.

(c) For post-award interest received before 01.04.2026, no TDS is deductible on credit. On payment, TDS is deductible only if the aggregate paid to a claimant in the financial year exceeds ₹50,000, without prejudice to the claimant's right to establish non-taxability and seek a refund.

(d) From 01.04.2026, MV Act interest received by an individual or legal heir is exempt under Section 11 read with Schedule III of the 2025 Act, irrespective of the period it covers, and no TDS is deductible under Section 393. The reference is disposed of accordingly, and the matter is to be placed before the appropriate roster Bench for disposal of the writ petitions.

01Facts

The claimants obtained a Motor Accident Claims Tribunal award comprising compensation and simple interest under Section 171 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 ("MV Act"). At payment, the insurer deducted tax at source (TDS) on the interest component. The claimants contended that the interest is not taxable income and that no TDS was deductible.

¶ 1

A coordinate Division Bench in Sharda Pareek held such interest taxable. The Bombay High Court in Rupesh Rashmikant Shah held interest up to the date of the award non-taxable. The Madras High Court referred a similar question to a Larger Bench.

¶ 2

The Division Bench referred the question to a Full Bench.

¶ 2–3

During hearing, the Bar sought early adjudication.

¶ 4

The Income Tax Act, 2025 ("2025 Act"), effective 01.04.2026, and the Finance Act, 2026 introduced an exemption for MV Act interest received by an individual or legal heir (Schedule III, Sl. No. 38B) and removed TDS on such interest paid to individuals (Section 393(4)).

¶ 4(v), 9

02Issues

i.1. Whether interest awarded under Section 171 of the MV Act is exigible to income tax and, consequently, whether the insurer is required to deduct TDS under Section 194A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ("1961 Act").

¶ 2 · ¶ 70(a)

ii.2. Whether the statutory exemption introduced by the Finance Act, 2026 (with effect from 01.04.2026) alters the position for interest for periods before that date, and how it operates going forward.

¶ 66–68 · ¶ 70(c)–(d)

03Law Applied

The principle of restitution in MV Act compensation applies, under which compensation is damages for loss and not income.

¶ 10–12, 15

A sum paid to compensate for destruction of a source of income is a capital receipt and not income, as relied upon in Senairam Doongarmall and Sutherland.

¶ 16–17

Section 171 of the MV Act makes interest an addition to compensation, computed on it and recoverable only as part of the award.

¶ 6, 18–19

Per Abati Bezbaruah, Dharampal, and Kaushnuma Begum, such interest is compensatory.

¶ 20–25

Per CIT v. Ghanshyam (HUF), interest that accretes to compensation takes the character of compensation and is not "interest".

¶ 28–29

Under Section 2(28A) of the 1961 Act, "interest" requires moneys borrowed or a debt incurred, i.e., a debtor–creditor relationship.

¶ 46–48

Under Union of India v. Raman Iron Foundry and Central Bank of India v. Ravindra, no debt exists for unliquidated damages until adjudication.

¶ 40–42

Sections 56(2)(viii), 57(iv) and 145B(1) presuppose income and are not charging provisions, and Section 194A is a machinery provision that applies only to income in the payee's hands.

¶ 55, 57–59

Kailash Narain Gupta and Sharda Pareek were examined as contrary authority.

¶ 62–63

Under CIT v. Vatika Township, a subsequent beneficial legislation may be treated as a parliamentary exposition.

¶ 68(d)

Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 166Section 168Section 171Section 173Section 174

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 34

National Tax Tribunal Act, 2005 Section 751

04Reasoning

The Court first held that the principal compensation is restitutive and not income, and that Section 171 interest is an integral, inseparable and inalienable part of that compensation: it is computed on the heads of loss, has no independent existence, and is recovered only under the award. Because it accretes to a capital receipt, it shares that character.

¶ 18–27, 37–38

The Court then held that this interest is not "interest" in common parlance. Common-parlance interest presupposes use of another's money or a sum already due, and neither exists during adjudication.

¶ 39–45

The statutory definition in Section 2(28A) is not satisfied because there is no debtor–creditor relationship or pre-existing debt. The word "claim" in that definition does not cover statutory tort claims.

¶ 46–51

Land acquisition authorities (Ghanshyam, Movaliya) were distinguished because the land compensation regime is itself taxable under capital gains, whereas MV compensation is not.

¶ 29–31, 56

The Court held that Sections 56(2)(viii) and 145B(1) only fix the charge or timing for income that is already taxable, and Section 194A cannot create a charge.

¶ 55–59, 61

Sharda Pareek was distinguished as treating interest as a yield on capital, which ignores the absence of any debt during adjudication. The Court noted that the Karnataka and Madhya Pradesh High Courts had reached the same result on the anterior question.

¶ 62–63

The Finance Act, 2026 exemption was treated as legislative recognition of the compensatory nature of such interest, with a benefit-conferring provision that warrants purposive construction. It does not govern pre-2026 periods, where the position rests on non-taxability itself.

¶ 66–68

05Holding

(a) Section 171 MV Act interest, for the period from the claim petition to the award (or to the appellate judgment), is an integral part of compensation, is not "interest" under Section 2(28A), is not chargeable under Sections 56(1) or 56(2)(viii) read with Section 145B(1), and therefore attracts no TDS under Section 194A.

¶ 70(a)

(b) Kailash Narain Gupta and Sharda Pareek do not lay down the correct law to the extent contrary.

¶ 70(b)

(c) For post-award interest received before 01.04.2026, no TDS is deductible on credit. On payment, TDS is deductible only if the aggregate paid to a claimant in the financial year exceeds ₹50,000, without prejudice to the claimant's right to establish non-taxability and seek a refund.

¶ 70(c)

(d) From 01.04.2026, MV Act interest received by an individual or legal heir is exempt under Section 11 read with Schedule III of the 2025 Act, irrespective of the period it covers, and no TDS is deductible under Section 393. The reference is disposed of accordingly, and the matter is to be placed before the appropriate roster Bench for disposal of the writ petitions.

¶ 70(d) · ¶ 71–72
Rajasthan High Court

Original Court PDF

SATYA NARAYAN S/O SHRI KHARBUJA,vsTHE H.D.F.C IRGO GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED

Rajasthan High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment