Rajasthan High CourtEmployment and Labour LawFamily Law

Tribal Women Need Court Divorce Decree, Not Customary Certificate, By Application Deadline For Divorcee Quota

MANJU BAI MEENA D/O KAILASH CHAND MEENAv.THE STATE OF RAJASTHAN

Tribal Women Need Court Divorce Decree, Not Customary Certificate, By Application Deadline For Divorcee Quota. MANJU BAI MEENA D/O KAILASH CHAND MEENA vs THE STATE OF RAJASTHAN. Rajasthan High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the last date for submission of the application form is sacrosanct, such that proof of dissolution of marriage cannot be furnished after that date.

The court held

A ST female candidate is not entitled to appointment under the divorcee category on the strength of a customary divorce unless a decree of dissolution from a jurisdictional court establishing her divorced status exists on or before the last date for submitting the application form.

It also directed

Section 2(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 does not relieve such a candidate of the proof requirement. A customary divorce must be pleaded and proved before a competent court and cannot be adjudicated by the recruiting body.

Sangeeta Varhat lays down the law correctly. Sunita Meena is confined to its own facts.

The reference is disposed of, and the individual appeal is to be placed before the appropriate roster Bench for decision on its merits.

01Facts

A Division Bench (Anoop Kumar Dhand, J.) referred a question to the Chief Justice because it conflicted with two earlier Division Bench decisions: RPSC v. Sunita Meena (D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 829/2017) and Secretary, RPSC v. Sangeeta Varhat.

¶ 1

The reference was framed as: whether a ST female candidate may claim appointment under the divorcee category without a decree of dissolution from a competent court before the last date of application.

¶ 1

In Sunita Meena, a Scheduled Tribe candidate relied on a customary dissolution of marriage dated 11.05.2008 and a community-issued dissolution certificate, both said to predate the recruitment cut-off. The Family Court and civil court had refused her suit for declaration.

¶ 2

The Single Judge (order dated 17.01.2017) kept the post vacant for six months and granted liberty to obtain a Family Court declaration that the marriage stood dissolved on 11.05.2008. The Division Bench declined to interfere.

¶ 2

In Sangeeta Varhat, a different Division Bench held that a competent court's divorce decree existing on the last date of application is a sine qua non for the divorce category, that custom cannot override recruitment terms, and treated Sunita Meena as per incuriam.

¶ 3

02Issues

i.1. Whether the last date for submission of the application form is sacrosanct, such that proof of dissolution of marriage cannot be furnished after that date.

¶ 9(1)

ii.2. Whether a customary divorce record issued by the community authority is sufficient proof of divorce under the reservation rule, or whether a court decree is required.

¶ 9(2)

03Law Applied

The women's reservation rule (Rajasthan Various Service (Amendment) Rules, 2011) reserves 2% of direct-recruitment posts for divorced women and requires "proof of divorce".

¶ 4, 8

Eligibility and suitability are judged with reference to the last date for receiving applications, unless the rules or advertisement provide otherwise, per Dr. M.V. Nair v. Union of India, Ashok Kumar Sonkar v. Union of India, Shankar K. Mandal v. State of Bihar, and Rekha Chaturvedi and Bhupinderpal Singh.

¶ 10, 11, 12, 14

Dolly Chandra v. Chairman, JEE distinguishes possession of eligibility (which must exist by the cut-off date) from proof of it (which may in some cases be relaxed).

¶ 13

Section 2(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 saves tribal custom but does not exempt candidates from recruitment terms; custom must be pleaded and proved.

¶ 16

Section 7(1), Explanation (b) of the Family Courts Act, 1984 vests Family Courts with jurisdiction over declarations of matrimonial status.

¶ 7, 16, 20

Yamanaji H. Jadhav v. Nirmala requires a customary divorce to be specifically pleaded and proved.

¶ 18

Sanjana Kumari v. Vijay Kumar holds that reliance on a customary divorce deed requires proof of an established, uniformly observed custom, which is a question of fact ordinarily for a civil court.

¶ 19

Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 Section 2Section 3Section 11Section 13Section 29

Family Courts Act, 1984 Section 7

04Reasoning

On Issue 1, the Court held that the cut-off date is binding because a candidate must possess the eligibility condition by that date. A decree obtained afterwards cannot retrospectively establish eligibility.

¶ 10–14

Under Dolly Chandra, only the mode of proof may be relaxed in some cases. The divorce itself, as a legal status, must exist and be verifiable on the last date.

¶ 13, 15

On Issue 2, the Court reasoned that Section 2(2) of the HMA preserves customary divorce but does not relieve a candidate of recruitment conditions. A recruiting body reviewing large volumes of documents cannot adjudicate the existence of a custom, its application to the individual, or the date of dissolution.

¶ 16

Under Yamanaji and Sanjana Kumari, the custom must be pleaded and proved before a competent court. The Family Court is the forum for such a declaration under Section 7 of the Family Courts Act.

¶ 17, 18, 19, 20

The Court found Sunita Meena confined to its facts. There, the Single Bench had itself required a Family Court declaration, and the Division Bench did not lay down a general proposition that a community divorce suffices.

¶ 20

05Holding

A ST female candidate is not entitled to appointment under the divorcee category on the strength of a customary divorce unless a decree of dissolution from a jurisdictional court establishing her divorced status exists on or before the last date for submitting the application form.

¶ 21(1)

Section 2(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 does not relieve such a candidate of the proof requirement. A customary divorce must be pleaded and proved before a competent court and cannot be adjudicated by the recruiting body.

¶ 21(2)

Sangeeta Varhat lays down the law correctly. Sunita Meena is confined to its own facts.

¶ 21(3)

The reference is disposed of, and the individual appeal is to be placed before the appropriate roster Bench for decision on its merits.

¶ 22–23
Rajasthan High Court

Original Court PDF

MANJU BAI MEENA D/O KAILASH CHAND MEENAvsTHE STATE OF RAJASTHAN

Rajasthan High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment