01Facts
The suit property was acquired by late P.D. Vadivelu from the Karnataka Housing Board and was admitted to be his self-acquired property.
pp. 3–7He died intestate in 2014, survived by his widow and four children, including late V. Lokesh, the plaintiff’s husband. Lokesh died later that year.
pp. 3–7The plaintiff sought partition and separate possession of the 1/5 share that had devolved on Lokesh, asserting that she was his legally wedded wife.
pp. 3–7The trial court decreed the suit. Vadivelu’s widow and two of his children appealed, disputing the plaintiff’s marriage and entitlement.
pp. 3–702Issues
i.Whether the plaintiff proved that she was the wife of late V. Lokesh.
p. 8ii.Whether the plaintiff proved that the suit property was late P.D. Vadivelu’s self-acquired property and was entitled to a 1/5 share in it by partition.
pp. 8–9iii.Whether the trial court’s judgment and decree suffered from perversity or illegality warranting appellate interference.
p. 903Law Applied
Under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the property of a Hindu male dying intestate devolves upon his Class I heirs.
pp. 10–11The Court applied this rule to hold that Vadivelu’s widow and four children each inherited a 1/5 share.
pp. 10–11It further held that Lokesh’s 1/5 share devolved upon the plaintiff as his widow and Class I legal heir upon his death.
pp. 10–11The Court also considered the ration card and family-member admissions as evidence supporting the plaintiff’s marital relationship with Lokesh.
pp. 9–10Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 96Section 41
Hindu Succession Act, 1956 Section 8
04Reasoning
The ration card identified the plaintiff as Lokesh’s wife, and defendant No. 2 admitted the document and identified Lokesh’s photograph without denying the plaintiff’s photograph.
pp. 9–10Defendant No. 3, Lokesh’s sibling, also admitted that the plaintiff was Lokesh’s wife.
pp. 9–10The appellants produced no contrary evidence sufficient to rebut this evidence; the Court therefore found the marriage proved.
pp. 9–10The registered sale deed and the defendants’ admissions established that the property was Vadivelu’s self-acquired property and that he died intestate.
pp. 10–11Applying Section 8, the Court concluded that Lokesh inherited a 1/5 share from Vadivelu and that the plaintiff inherited that share as Lokesh’s widow.
pp. 10–11Finding no illegality or perversity in the trial court’s decree, the Court declined to interfere.
p. 1205Holding
The Court answered the first two issues in the affirmative and found no ground for appellate interference.
pp. 10–12It dismissed the appeal and upheld the decree for partition, leaving the plaintiff at liberty to pursue mesne profits in the final decree proceedings.
pp. 10–12Original Court PDF
SMT. GUNAMMAvsSMT. ANNAPURNA L
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
