01Facts
The review petitioner, an Advocate appearing in person, was empanelled with the Basic Shiksha Parishad and appointed Special Counsel on 23.04.2009 to conduct Special Appeals.
¶ 26 (impugned order)He relied on Government Orders dated 23.04.2009 and 02.03.2011 to claim fees of about Rs. 4.8 crore with penal interest, and invoked Article 21 and Article 23(1) of the Constitution.
¶ 14 (quoting impugned order · ¶ 9)By a common judgment dated 14.08.2026 in Writ-C Nos. 5832, 5828, 6045 and 8217 of 2025, the writ petitions were dismissed.
¶ 2–3The impugned order held that a writ petition was not maintainable for recovery of professional fees, that the engagement was contractual, that the fee claims were disputed and not admitted, and that the matter involved complex disputed facts requiring a civil suit.
¶ 2–3 (quoting impugned order · ¶ 26–30)The petitioner was given liberty to sue, with the benefit of Section 14 of the Limitation Act.
¶ 3The petitioner sought review on five grounds: (i) his written submissions dated 10.07.2026 and compilation of judgments were ignored; (ii) para. 25 of the impugned order wrongly found no admission of fee bills, although letters dated 16.09.2025 and 26.09.2025 forwarded his bills; (iii) reliance on a per incuriam judgment; (iv) non-decision of Article 21 and 23(1) grounds; and (v) non-decision on the applicability of the two Government Orders.
¶ 4–902Issues
i.1. Whether the alleged non-consideration of the petitioner's written submissions and case compilation constitutes an error apparent on the face of the record warranting review.
¶ 13–14ii.2. Whether the observation in para. 25 of the impugned order, that no document showed admission of the fee bills, is an error apparent on the face of the record.
¶ 17–20iii.3. Whether the impugned order relied on a per incuriam judgment, such that review is warranted.
¶ 21iv.4. Whether non-adjudication of the Article 21 and Article 23(1) contentions is a ground for review.
¶ 22–23v.5. Whether non-adjudication of the applicability of the Government Orders dated 23.04.2009 and 02.03.2011 is a ground for review.
¶ 24vi.6. Whether, in substance, the review petitions are maintainable or are an appeal in disguise.
¶ 25–2603Law Applied
The Court's power of review is governed by Chapter V Rule 12 of the Allahabad High Court Rules, 1952, read with Section 114 CPC and Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC.
¶ 11Review lies only for (a) new and important matter not previously available despite due diligence, (b) an error apparent on the face of the record, or (c) any other sufficient reason analogous to these.
¶ 11Following Sanjay Kumar Agarwal v. State Tax Officer (2024) 2 SCC 362, an error apparent must be self-evident, not requiring a long process of reasoning; a review is not an appeal in disguise; and a judgment cannot be reheard or re-argued under the guise of review.
¶ 11A decision is per incuriam only when rendered in ignorance of a binding statutory provision or binding authority, as held in A.R. Antulay v. R.S. Nayak (1988) 2 SCC 602 and Punjab Land Development and Reclamation Corporation v. Presiding Officer (1990) 3 SCC 682.
¶ 21Non-decision of a contention that cannot affect the result is an implied rejection.
¶ 23Article 142 orders in Gopal K. Verma are not binding precedent on maintainability, as reasoned in the impugned order.
¶ 15 (quoting impugned order · ¶ 17)Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 14
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 114
04Reasoning
Written submissions aid oral arguments and do not displace judicial reasoning; omission of cited authorities is not self-evidently an error, and the petitioner did not show that any cited authority would alter the outcome.
¶ 13–14The grievance that fundamental rights cannot be enforced by a civil court was rejected because the writ court decided the enforceability of the fee claim on merits, and re-agitating that finding is impermissible in review.
¶ 16Forwarding a bill for examination is an administrative step and is not admission of liability, quantum, or entitlement.
¶ 18Even if admission were assumed, entitlement would still depend on the terms of engagement and the Government Orders, which are disputed questions of fact.
¶ 19The observation in para. 25 was not the foundation of the decision; the dismissal rested on maintainability and on complex disputed facts, so the error, if any, did not affect the result.
¶ 20The petitioner identified no ignorance of a binding authority; challenging a precedent the court applied is a matter for appeal.
¶ 21The Article 21 and 23(1) contentions were not decided, but once the writ was held non-maintainable they did not survive; further, a fee dispute under a professional engagement is contractual, not forced labour, and no deprivation of life or livelihood was shown.
¶ 22–23The Government Order contentions were implicitly decided, since the impugned order held that entitlement under them required trial, and the petitioner's objection to the interpretation is a plea of erroneous interpretation, not an error apparent.
¶ 24The petitions sought re-hearing of decided issues, which defeats the principle of finality.
¶ 2505Holding
No error apparent on the face of the record and no sufficient reason for review exists, and the review petitions are an appeal in disguise.
¶ 25–26All four Civil Misc. Review Applications (Nos. 119, 120, 121 and 122 of 2026) are dismissed as devoid of merit.
¶ 27The original order of 14.08.2026, including its liberty to file a civil suit and the grant of Section 14 Limitation Act benefit, remains in force.
¶ 3 (quoting impugned order · ¶ 30)Original Court PDF
Jyotinjay VermavsState Of U.P. Thru. Its Secy. Basic Education Lko. And 6 Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
