01Facts
The petitioner, a businessman and de facto complainant, alleged that accused Nos. 1 and 7 (respondents 2 and 3) and others falsely represented that they could secure him a party ticket for the 2023 Assembly elections from Byndoor Constituency, Udupi
¶ 2He alleged he paid ₹50,00,000 to accused No. 2, ₹3,00,00,000 to accused No. 7 at accused No. 1's instruction, and ₹1,50,00,000 to accused No. 3
¶ 2–3A complaint was lodged, and an FIR was registered for offences under Sections 406, 419, 420, 170, 506 and 120B IPC
¶ 5Police seized cash and articles, which were placed under PF No. 25/2023 and PF No. 30/2023
¶ 5PF No. 30/2023 comprised four items recovered from accused No. 7's house on 17.09.2023: ₹41,00,000 in cash and a gold-plated ring
¶ 8, 19The petitioner and accused No. 1 sought release of the seized property under Sections 451 and 457 CrPC. The Magistrate (order dated 29.01.2024) rejected the petitioner's claim as to PF No. 30/2023 and partly allowed accused No. 1's claim. The Revision Court dismissed the revision on 10.09.2024
¶ 6The petitioner's claim rested on bank statements, Income Tax Returns, and a 2022 ICICI loan of ₹10,00,00,000
¶ 11, 25Accused No. 7 claimed the cash belonged to his mother, who had obtained a loan from Akshyamurtha Credit Co-operative Society, and relied on a deposit ledger dated 09.11.2026
¶ 14The Investigating Officer's report stated that the seized amount is ₹1,81,21,030 in total and is deposited in SBI (Criminal Court Deposit)
¶ 16The petitioner's claim over PF No. 25/2023 was not pressed
¶ 2102Issues
i.1. Whether the Magistrate and the Revision Court erred in rejecting the petitioner's claim for release of the cash and gold ring seized under PF No. 30/2023, where the Investigating Officer reported that the articles belonged to the petitioner and were recovered at the accused's instance.
¶ 8, 16, 22ii.2. Whether accused No. 7's claim of ownership over the PF No. 30/2023 cash, based on his mother's loan from a credit society, is sustainable in the absence of supporting documents predating the alleged offence.
¶ 14, 25, 28–2903Law Applied
The court's reasoning rests on Sections 451 and 457 CrPC, which govern interim custody and release of seized property pending trial.
¶ 6Section 482 CrPC is the source of the High Court's inherent power to set aside the impugned orders.
¶ 1An accused cannot claim a right over seized property on a self-serving defence unsupported by at least prima facie documentary evidence.
¶ 29Release may be granted pending trial, subject to conditions, where prima facie material shows the claimant's ownership, including panchanama, photographs, serial-number recording, and an indemnity bond with two sureties to secure redeposit if the claimant is ultimately found not entitled.
order · ¶ v(a)–(c)The court distinguished Rajput Vijaysinh Natwarsinh v. State of Gujarat, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2012, relied on by the accused, as a case involving a proprietary firm and business transactions between the parties, which is not comparable to a serious cheating prosecution.
¶ 28The express articulation of the general rule beyond para. 29.
Provisions in the judgment · 9 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482Section 451Section 457
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 528
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 406Section 419Section 420Section 170Section 506
04Reasoning
The court first confined the controversy to PF No. 30/2023, because the petitioner did not press his claim as to PF No. 25/2023.
¶ 21It then found that the Magistrate and the Revision Court had rejected the petitioner's claim without cogent reasons, despite the Investigating Officer's report supporting it.
¶ 22On the charge-sheet material, the court found that CWs 2 to 4 corroborated the petitioner's account that ₹3,00,00,000 was handed to accused No. 7 at Mangaluru on 29.10.2022.
¶ 24The petitioner's ICICI loan sanction and disbursement (25.10.2022), loan statements, and ITR entries showing advances to accused Nos. 1–3 supported that account. Accused No. 7's documents, by contrast, related to 2023, which is after the September 2023 seizure and after the alleged transactions. They could not establish prior ownership.
¶ 25The court held that the accused's claim was self-serving and unsupported by prima facie documents.
¶ 28–29Because the money was prima facie the petitioner's, the court held that retaining it in the bank until trial concludes merely to test ownership was unwarranted.
¶ 27The court therefore found interference warranted for PF No. 30/2023.
¶ 2905Holding
Issue 1 is answered in the affirmative: the rejection of the petitioner's claim over PF No. 30/2023 was unsustainable.
¶ 22, 27Issue 2 is answered in the negative: accused No. 7's ownership claim, lacking contemporaneous documentary support, could not be accepted.
¶ 25, 28–29The petition was allowed in part. The orders of 29.01.2024 and 10.09.2024 were set aside insofar as they concerned PF No. 30/2023, and they remain undisturbed as to PF No. 25/2023.
order · ¶ ii–iiiThe Magistrate was directed to release Items 1 to 3 (the ₹41,00,000 cash) to the petitioner, subject to: (a) recording the denominations and serial numbers of the notes in the panchanama, with photographs at the petitioner's expense; (b) photographing every currency note by the Investigating Officer; and (c) the petitioner executing an indemnity bond for the same sum with two sureties, undertaking to redeposit if held not entitled in the final judgment.
order · ¶ v(a)–(c)The trial court was requested to conclude trial expeditiously, since the offence dates to 2022.
order · ¶ vThe gold-plated ring (Item 4) is not expressly addressed in the operative directions.
Original Court PDF
SRI GOVINDA BABU POOJARIvsSTATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
