Delhi High Court
Civil LawAdministrative and Public Law

Self-draw allotment recognition requires prior Section 28 membership transfer through the cooperative society.

Manchali Johri vs Registrar, Cooperative Societies & Ors.

Delhi High CourtJUDGMENT: September 10, 20263 MIN READSOURCE JUDGMENT
Self-draw allotment recognition requires prior Section 28 membership transfer through the cooperative society.. Manchali Johri vs Registrar, Cooperative Societies & Ors.. Delhi High Court. LawLens
THE ORIGINAL LAWLENS SUMMARY
01

Facts

The petitioner, Mrs. Manchali Johri, sought confirmation of the allotment of Flat No. 89, Shankar Co-operative Group Housing Society Ltd., Plot No. 4, Sector-15, Rohini, Delhi.

Source reference: p.1, para. 3

Her husband, Mr. Mukesh Johri, was the original member of the Society and was allotted the flat through a self-draw of lots on 22 December 1996; possession was delivered on 13 June 1999.

Source reference: p.1, para. 3

He died on 10 October 2019, leaving behind the petitioner and their daughter, Ms. Neelika Johri, who had no objection to transfer of the flat in the petitioner’s favour.

Source reference: p.1, paras. 3–4

Although the Society had issued a share certificate to the petitioner’s husband, the Registrar of Co-operative Societies (“RCS”) had not confirmed the allotment.

Source reference: p.2, para. 5

The RCS stated that the Society had not forwarded the husband’s membership details and that the transfer and confirmation process had to be routed through the Society.

Source reference: p.2, para. 6

During the proceedings, the RCS relied on its Circular dated 4 June 2026, providing a one-time opportunity for recognition of self-draw allotments made by eligible co-operative group housing societies.

Source reference: p.2, para. 7
02

Issues

1. Whether the petitioner could obtain transfer of her deceased husband’s membership and interest in the Society under Section 28 of the Delhi Co-operative Societies Act, 2003.

Source reference: p.3, para. 8

2. Whether, after such transfer and issuance of a share certificate in her favour, the petitioner could apply through the Society for recognition of the self-draw allotment and confirmation of the flat allotment under the RCS Circular dated 4 June 2026.

Source reference: p.3, paras. 7–9
03

Law Applied

The Court applied Section 28 of the Delhi Co-operative Societies Act, 2003, which governs the transfer of a member’s interest in a co-operative society, including the procedural requirement of obtaining transfer through the Society.

Source reference: no citation

It further applied the RCS Circular dated 4 June 2026, under which eligible co-operative group housing societies that had conducted self-draws up to 2010 could submit requisite information for recognition and regularisation of such allotments.

Source reference: p.2, para. 7

The Court treated these provisions as requiring a two-stage process: first, transfer of the deceased member’s membership and interest to the petitioner; and second, submission through the Society for recognition of the self-draw and issuance of an allotment letter.

Source reference: p.3, para. 8
04

Reasoning

The Court accepted that the petitioner could not obtain direct confirmation from the RCS because the Society had not transmitted the original allottee’s membership particulars.

Source reference: p.2, para. 6

Accordingly, the statutory mechanism under Section 28 had to be followed first, requiring the petitioner to apply to the Society for transfer of her husband’s membership and interest and requiring the Society to verify the supporting documents.

Source reference: p.3, para. 8

Once the petitioner obtained the share certificate, the Court permitted her to submit an application through the Society under the RCS Circular.

Source reference: no citation

Although the circular’s original deadline had expired, the Court extended permission in view of the undisputed initial allotment in favour of the petitioner’s husband and the petitioner’s status as his wife.

Source reference: p.4, para. 9(iii)

The RCS was thereafter directed to confirm the allotment upon receipt and verification of the complete application.

Source reference: p.4, para. 9(iv)
05

Holding

The petition was disposed of with directions that the petitioner apply to the Society under Section 28 within 15 days for transfer of Mr. Mukesh Johri’s membership in her favour; the Society decide the application by 15 October 2026; and, after issuance of the share certificate, the petitioner apply through the Society by 30 November 2026 under the RCS Circular for recognition of the self-draw and issuance of an allotment letter.

The RCS was directed to confirm the allotment in the petitioner’s favour by 31 January 2027 after receiving and verifying the complete application.

Source reference: p.4, para. 9(iv)

The petitioner was granted liberty to approach the Court if the directions were not complied with.

Source reference: p.4, para. 11
06

Acts & Sections Cited

2 provisions across 1 statute referred to in this judgment. Linked provisions open on LawLens.

Delhi Co-Operative Societies Act, 20032

Section 77Section 28
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Manchali JohrivsRegistrar, Cooperative Societies & Ors.

Delhi High Court · September 10, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment