Allahabad High CourtEmployment and Labour LawAdministrative and Public Law

Silence of the compassionate appointment scheme on upper age relaxation is no absolute bar to considering such claims.

Divya Jyoti Mukherjeev.Union Of India And 5 Others

Silence of the compassionate appointment scheme on upper age relaxation is no absolute bar to considering such claims.. Divya Jyoti Mukherjee vs Union Of India And 5 Others. Allahabad High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the 2019 Compassionate Appointment Scheme, which is silent on upper age relaxation, permits relaxation of the upper age limit for a dependant aged over 30 years.

The court held

The Scheme's silence on upper-age relaxation does not bar relaxation, and rejecting the petitioner's claim solely on the ground of age was arbitrary.

It also directed

The orders dated 20.01.2025 and 30.08.2025 are quashed, and the matter is remitted to the respondent authority to decide the petitioner's claim afresh, expeditiously and preferably within one month of receiving a certified copy, in light of the Court's observations. The writ petition is allowed, with no order as to costs.

01Facts

The petitioner's father, a Class-IV employee of Banaras Hindu University (BHU), died in harness on 27.09.2024.

¶ 3

The petitioner was temporarily engaged as Project Research Scientist (I) on an honorarium basis by order dated 03.12.2024.

¶ 3

On 07.01.2025, the petitioner's mother applied through the Registrar, BHU, for compassionate appointment for the petitioner, her only son.

¶ 3

On 20.01.2025, the Assistant Registrar declined to supply the application proforma because the petitioner had crossed the general-category upper age limit of 30 years.

¶ 4

A second application was rejected on 30.08.2025 on the same ground.

¶ 4

The petitioner relied on the Single Judge's order in Nameirakpam Shangbanabi v. BHU (Writ A No. 3844 of 2020, dated 05.02.2025).

¶ 5

The petitioner relied on the Division Bench decision in Special Appeal No. 820 of 2025 affirming the relief granted therein.

¶ 6

The University contended that the Division Bench had declined to permit upper-age relaxation, that the 2019 Scheme prescribes 18–30 years for the General Category with no upper relaxation, and that the impugned orders were therefore lawful.

¶ 8

The governing scheme is the BHU compassionate appointment rules approved vide ECR No. 154 dated 07.12.2019.

¶ 12

02Issues

i.1. Whether the 2019 Compassionate Appointment Scheme, which is silent on upper age relaxation, permits relaxation of the upper age limit for a dependant aged over 30 years.

¶ 14, 16, 21

ii.2. Whether the orders dated 20.01.2025 and 30.08.2025 rejecting the petitioner's claim solely on the ground of age are sustainable.

¶ 19, 20, 23

03Law Applied

The BHU Compassionate Appointment Scheme (ECR No. 154, 07.12.2019) provides that the age limit follows the applicable Recruitment Rules (18–30 years for the General Category), that the minimum age is not relaxable, and that the Scheme is silent on upper-age relaxation, whereas the earlier rules expressly permitted it.

¶ 12, 14

The Scheme permits consideration of claims where an earning member exists, subject to an overall assessment of the family's finances, and requires a "balanced and objective assessment" of the family's condition.

¶ 12, 13, 15

The Division Bench in Special Appeal No. 820 of 2025 held that compassionate rules address sudden financial hardship and that Recruitment Rules cannot be used to defeat their object, though upper-age relaxation is not to be abandoned merely because of the Recruitment Rules.

¶ 6, quoting DB paras. 16, 17, 19, 21

In Nameirakpam Shangbanabi, the Single Judge observed that direct-recruitment rules do not govern compassionate appointment.

¶ 5, quoting paras. 9–10 of that order

The Executive Council cannot limit the Committee's discretion under the Scheme, which has statutory force.

¶ 6, quoting DB para. 17

04Reasoning

The Court found that the 2019 Scheme's silence on upper-age relaxation cannot be treated as an absolute embargo, because the earlier rules expressly provided for such relaxation and the later Scheme retains the same welfare objective.

¶ 21

Reading the Scheme purposively, the Court held that the Division Bench's position, that upper-age relaxation cannot be done away with, governs the present case.

¶ 16

Applying this to the facts, the Court noted that the petitioner is the son and sole dependant of the deceased employee, with a surviving mother, and that the family's financial needs were not examined before rejection.

¶ 19, 22

Rejecting the claim solely because the petitioner exceeded 30 years was held arbitrary, as it ignored the Scheme's objective of relieving penury and its requirement of a holistic assessment.

¶ 18–20

The Court did not record a separate finding on the petitioner's temporary honorarium engagement, nor did it expressly determine the petitioner's entitlement to the application proforma or the specific age relaxation; those questions were left to the competent authority.

¶ 23

05Holding

The Scheme's silence on upper-age relaxation does not bar relaxation, and rejecting the petitioner's claim solely on the ground of age was arbitrary.

¶ 21, 19–20

The orders dated 20.01.2025 and 30.08.2025 are quashed, and the matter is remitted to the respondent authority to decide the petitioner's claim afresh, expeditiously and preferably within one month of receiving a certified copy, in light of the Court's observations. The writ petition is allowed, with no order as to costs.

¶ 23, 24, 25
Allahabad High Court

Original Court PDF

Divya Jyoti MukherjeevsUnion Of India And 5 Others

Allahabad High Court · November 16, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment