01Facts
The appellant, then a minor, alleged that on 15 July 2011 she was severely injured when she came into contact with a live electric wire hanging close to the ground, and that her right hand was later amputated
pp. 2–3The trial court accepted her claim and awarded ₹8,70,000 in compensation with 6% interest
p. 4On JVVNL’s appeal, the Rajasthan High Court set aside the decree, finding the occurrence suspicious and the evidence insufficient
pp. 4–5The appellant challenged that decision before the Supreme Court
pp. 1–202Issues
i.1. Whether the High Court was justified in reversing the trial court’s factual findings on the basis of suspicion about the occurrence, without finding the appellant’s witnesses unreliable or identifying a material defect in their evidence?
pp. 5–8ii.2. Whether the evidence established, on a preponderance of probabilities, that the appellant suffered electrocution injuries due to the respondents’ negligence, entitling her to compensation?
pp. 6–803Law Applied
In civil proceedings, facts are determined on the standard of preponderance of probabilities; under Section 3 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, a fact is proved when the court believes it exists or considers its existence so probable that a prudent person would act on that supposition.
p. 8Sections 146 and 155 permit cross-examination and the impeachment of a witness’s credit.
pp. 5–6A civil appellate court may interfere with findings of fact where, for example, they involve material irregularity, inadmissible evidence, or misreading of evidence, but should not reverse them merely on suspicion or minor inconsistencies.
p. 5, 8The Court also held that the respondents’ liability in this case attracted the principle of strict liability.
p. 9Provisions in the judgment · 4
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 Section 146Section 155Section 4Section 3
04Reasoning
The trial court had assessed the parties’ evidence and accepted the appellant’s account, which remained unshaken on material aspects.
pp. 3–6The respondents’ witness had not seen the incident, was not on duty that day, and offered a version that was hearsay; the respondents also produced no affirmative evidence that the lines were properly maintained.
pp. 3–6The High Court instead treated the occurrence as suspicious, relying on matters such as the alleged improbability of survival and delay in reporting, without establishing that the appellant’s witnesses were unreliable or that the trial court had materially misread the evidence.
pp. 2, 4–8Applying the civil standard of proof and the limits on appellate interference, the Supreme Court concluded that suspicion alone could not displace the trial court’s findings.
pp. 6–805Holding
The Supreme Court held that the High Court erred in setting aside the trial court’s decree on suspicion and without a proper evidentiary basis.
pp. 7–9It set aside the High Court’s judgment dated 10 May 2024, restored the trial court’s judgment and decree awarding ₹8,70,000 with 6% interest, and allowed the appeal.
p. 9Original Court PDF
RekhavsJaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
