01Facts
The petitioner challenged a parallel record of rights (RoR/patta) recorded under Sikimi Khata No. 04-4 over Plots 1568 and 1569 in Mouza Rampei, Tahasil Athagarh, Cuttack.
pp. 1-2 / para. 1His grandfather, Moulabi Abdul Ahad, was recorded as the original Sthitiban tenant under Khata No. 28 in the settlement RoR published on 14.01.1963.
p. 2 / para. 2After his death, Mutation Case No. 6965 of 2024 was initiated in favour of his heirs.
p. 2 / para. 2The National Highway Authority of India (NHAI) acquired part of Plot 1568 (Ac. 0.50 out of Ac. 5.40). Part of the compensation was paid to Opp. Parties 5-8, who claim through Krushna Chandra Khuntia and Gobinda Khuntia under the Sikimi Khata entry.
p. 2 / para. 2Opp. Parties 5-8 stated that title was adjudicated in Civil Suit No. 74 of 2012, decided on 14.08.2023 by the Senior Civil Judge, Athagarh.
p. 3 / para. 3That court upheld the sikimi tenancy and the validity of transfers from Plot 1568 (RSD Nos. 1312 and 1311) and held sikimi rights heritable and transferable, relying on Daitary Swain v. Kartika Swain.
p. 3 / para. 3The civil judgment is under challenge in RFA No. 12 of 2024, which is pending at the stage of condonation of delay.
p. 3 / para. 3The petitioner contended that the settlement authorities lacked jurisdiction to create sikimi tenancy without proceedings under the OLR Act, rendering the entry void ab initio, and that the NHAI compensation was fraudulently disbursed.
p. 4 / para. 5Opp. Parties argued that the petitioner, having not challenged the entry within limitation for about 62 years, lacked locus standi.
p. 5 / para. 602Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner can, by writ petition, challenge the parallel sikimi RoR and seek to have it quashed as void ab initio for want of OLR Act proceedings, when title over the same land has been adjudicated in Civil Suit No. 74 of 2012.
pp. 7-8 / para. 8, 12ii.2. Whether the revenue entries and the consequential disbursement of NHAI compensation, which depend on adjudication of proprietary rights, can be reopened through Article 226 jurisdiction while the civil judgment subsists and the appeal is pending.
pp. 9-10 / para. 13-1403Law Applied
Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, under which the writ court's extraordinary jurisdiction cannot be used as a parallel forum to interfere with subsisting civil court findings or to circumvent the statutory appellate hierarchy.
p. 10 / para. 14The principle from Jitendra Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2021 SCC OnLine SC 802) that a mutation entry confers no right, title or interest and is made only for fiscal purposes, and that where title is disputed, the claimant must obtain a civil court adjudication before any mutation can follow.
pp. 9-10 / para. 13-14The civil court's judgment in Civil Suit No. 74 of 2012 is binding and in full force while the RFA remains pending at the threshold stage.
pp. 7-8 / para. 11The civil court's recognition of sikimi heritability rested on Daitary Swain v. Kartika Swain, 2019(I) ILR-CUT 659, as relied on by the parties and the trial court.
p. 3 / para. 3 · p. 7 / para. 1004Reasoning
The court first examined the civil judgment and found that the trial court did not award the title of Khata No. 28 to the petitioner. It rejected his claim over Plots 1568 and 1569, upheld the sikimi tenancy of Gobinda and Krushna Chandra Khuntia, and recognised valid registered transfers from Plot 1568.
p. 7 / para. 10As to Plot 1579, the trial court recognised it as the property of Moulabi Abdul Ahad but granted no declaration because the other legal heirs were not joined. Because the RFA had not been admitted, the trial judgment remained operative.
p. 8 / para. 11On the void ab initio plea, the court held it "wholly untenable" because the petitioner was a party to Civil Suit No. 74 of 2012, in which the validity of Sikimi Khata No. 04-4 and the resulting transfers were adjudicated on merits. Having contested the issue there, he could not bypass that adjudication by alleging a void entry, particularly as heritability of such tenancy stands recognised by precedent.
p. 8 / para. 12Applying Jitendra Singh, the court held that since title over Khata No. 28 plots had been adjudicated by a competent civil court, it could be finally settled only through the civil court hierarchy. The petitioner could not independently seek quashing of the RoR or of the NHAI compensation claim, which depended on the determination of proprietary rights.
p. 10 / para. 1405Holding
The court held that the challenge to the sikimi RoR and the NHAI compensation disbursement cannot be entertained under Article 226 where title has been adjudicated by a competent civil court and that adjudication is under appeal.
pp. 10 / para. 14-15The writ petition is dismissed. No interference with the impugned RoR was warranted. The dismissal does not preclude the petitioner from pursuing available remedies in the pending Regular First Appeal (RFA No. 12 of 2024). The court did not adjudicate the merits of title over the suit land.
p. 10 / para. 15Original Court PDF
ALLI AHADvsSTATE OF ODISHA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
