Madras High CourtInsurance LawCivil Law

Treatment period alone does not establish loss of income; actual earnings and incapacity must be proved.

The Branch Managerv.Nainar

Treatment period alone does not establish loss of income; actual earnings and incapacity must be proved.. The Branch Manager vs Nainar. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Tribunal correctly fixed negligence on the driver of the insured JCP, in the absence of contrary evidence from the insurer.

The court held

The finding of negligence against the JCP driver is affirmed, as the insurer adduced no contrary evidence.

It also directed

The loss-of-income award is reduced from Rs. 1,08,000 to Rs. 54,000 for want of documentary proof of income and incapacity period. All other heads are confirmed.

The appeal is partly allowed. Total compensation is reduced from Rs. 3,27,000 to Rs. 2,73,027, and the modified award carries 7.5% interest from the claim petition date until deposit.

The insurer must deposit the modified amount with accrued interest and costs within eight weeks of receiving the judgment, after which the claimant may withdraw it in accordance with law. There is no order as to costs.

01Facts

The claimant, a lorry driver aged about 31, was riding his two-wheeler (TN-76-K-4042) on the Tirunelveli–Tenkasi Main Road on 08.06.2022 when the insured JCP (TN-34-RW-173), coming from the opposite direction, dashed against him and caused multiple grievous injuries, including tibia and lower-limb injuries requiring plates and nails.

¶ 2.1 · pp. 2–3

He claimed Rs. 15,00,000 with interest, alleging that he could not resume his avocation.

¶ 2.2 · pp. 2–3

The Insurance Company disputed negligence and quantum, alleging the claimant's own negligence.

¶ 2.3 · p. 3

The claimant examined himself (P.W.1) and one other witness (P.W.2); Exs. P1–P9 and a Medical Board disability certificate (Ex. C1) were marked.

¶ 2.4 · p. 3

The Tribunal fixed negligence on the JCP driver and awarded Rs. 3,22,027 with 7.5% interest, comprising disability (Rs. 1,00,000), loss of income (Rs. 1,08,000, based on Rs. 18,000/month for six months), medical expenses, pain and suffering, loss of amenities, and other minor heads.

¶ 3.1 · pp. 3–4

The Tribunal's itemised table totals Rs. 3,27,000, which does not match the Rs. 3,22,027 stated in the text.

¶ 3.1 · pp. 3–4

The Insurance Company appealed under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act.

¶ 3.2 · p. 4

The claimant relied on the FIR, final report, and the JCP driver's guilty plea in the criminal court, and the insurer led no contra evidence.

¶ 5.1 · pp. 4–5

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Tribunal correctly fixed negligence on the driver of the insured JCP, in the absence of contrary evidence from the insurer.

¶ 7.1–7.3 · p. 5

ii.2. Whether the Rs. 1,08,000 award for loss of income during the treatment period was sustainable, given the absence of documentary proof of income and of the period of incapacity.

¶ 8.4–8.5 · pp. 6–7

iii.3. Whether the remaining heads of compensation (disability, medical, pain and suffering, loss of amenities, and other expenses) warranted interference.

¶ 8.3 · p. 6

03Law Applied

The court's jurisdiction arises under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, which governs appeals against Motor Accident Claims Tribunal awards.

p. 1

The judgment cites no precedent.

A finding of negligence rests on the evidence, and where the claimant's testimony is corroborated by the FIR and final report and the insurer adduces no contrary evidence, the finding stands.

¶ 7.2–7.3 · p. 5

Loss of income must be proved by reliable evidence of actual earnings and of the period during which the claimant was genuinely incapacitated; the length of medical treatment is not, by itself, equivalent to the period of lost earning capacity.

¶ 8.5–8.6 · pp. 6–7

Heads of compensation supported by the disability certificate and treatment records are sustained where no sufficient ground for interference is shown.

¶ 8.3 · p. 6

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173

04Reasoning

The insurer pleaded the claimant's contributory fault but led no oral or documentary evidence to support that plea. The claimant's account was corroborated by the FIR, the final report, and the driver's guilty plea before the criminal court, so the Tribunal's finding was affirmed.

¶ 7.2–7.3 · p. 5

The court accepted the disability award, medical expenses, pain and suffering, loss of amenities, and incidental heads as supported by the disability certificate and treatment records.

¶ 8.3 · p. 6

The Tribunal had assumed a monthly income of Rs. 18,000 and six months' loss, yet no documentary evidence of earnings was on record, and no sufficient evidence showed the claimant was unable to work for the full six months. Treating the hospitalisation period as the period of lost earnings was therefore unsupported.

¶ 8.5 · pp. 6–7

The court fixed the loss-of-income head at Rs. 54,000, which effectively reduces the assumed period to three months at the same rate, without stating the arithmetic.

¶ 8.6 · p. 7

The court did not address the arithmetic discrepancy in the Tribunal's own total, nor did it resolve the difference between its own Rs. 2,73,000 table total and the Rs. 2,73,027 figure in the operative paragraph.

¶ 9.1 · p. 7 · ¶ 10.1 · p. 8

05Holding

The finding of negligence against the JCP driver is affirmed, as the insurer adduced no contrary evidence.

¶ 7.3 · p. 5

The loss-of-income award is reduced from Rs. 1,08,000 to Rs. 54,000 for want of documentary proof of income and incapacity period. All other heads are confirmed.

¶ 8.7 · p. 7

The appeal is partly allowed. Total compensation is reduced from Rs. 3,27,000 to Rs. 2,73,027, and the modified award carries 7.5% interest from the claim petition date until deposit.

¶ 10.1 · p. 8

The insurer must deposit the modified amount with accrued interest and costs within eight weeks of receiving the judgment, after which the claimant may withdraw it in accordance with law. There is no order as to costs.

¶ 10.2–10.3 · p. 8
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

The Branch ManagervsNainar

Madras High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment