01Facts
The applicant, a Transmission Executive in All India Radio, joined on 30.10.1993, was confirmed in 1995, and retired on 30.04.2023
¶ 2.1She was convicted on 22.08.2023 by the Special Judge, CBI, Ahmedabad, in CBI Special Case No. 31 of 2009 under Section 168 IPC, Sections 420 r/w 120-B IPC, and Section 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988
¶ 2.3She appealed to the Gujarat High Court (Criminal Appeal No. 2168 of 2023). On 08.08.2024 the High Court suspended execution of the sentence during the appeal and ordered her release on bail, "without entering into the merits"
¶ 2.4, 3.2Earlier, a departmental penalty of withholding 10% of monthly pension for one year was imposed by order dated 01.06.2023
¶ 3.3The respondents issued a show-cause memorandum dated 07.05.2024 under Rule 8 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021 read with Rule 19(i) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965
¶ 2.5The applicant replied on 02.07.2024, raising suspension of sentence, double jeopardy, financial hardship, and a demand for personal hearing
¶ 2.5, 4.3By order dated 06.08.2024, the Secretary, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, withheld 100% of monthly pension and the entire gratuity permanently
¶ 2.6, 4.4, 4.9The respondents state that pension was paid without deduction from May 2023 to August 2024
¶ 4.8The applicant's rejoinder asserted that the conviction had been stayed
¶ 5.1The Tribunal found this unsupported by the order itself
¶ 1202Issues
i.1. Whether the permanent withholding of 100% of monthly pension and the entire gratuity under Rule 8 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021, is legally sustainable when the High Court has suspended the sentence pending appeal.
¶ 7, 8, 12ii.2. Whether the failure to grant a personal hearing before passing the impugned order vitiates it.
¶ 9iii.3. Whether the impugned penalty constitutes impermissible double punishment in view of the earlier 10% pension withholding ordered on 01.06.2023.
¶ 1003Law Applied
The Tribunal relied on Rule 8 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021, as amended, which empowers the competent authority to withhold or withdraw pension and gratuity, in full or in part, where a pensioner is found guilty of grave misconduct or negligence in judicial or departmental proceedings, subject to the conditions therein
¶ 4.4, 4.6, 11It also relied on Rule 19(i) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, under which the show-cause action was initiated
¶ 2.5, 5The Tribunal held that suspension of execution of a sentence does not set aside or nullify a conviction; the conviction subsists until set aside in appeal and remains a "finding of guilt in judicial proceedings" under Rule 8
¶ 8, 12Pension and gratuity are valuable retirement benefits, so any permanent deprivation must strictly conform to statutory provisions
¶ 11The two penalties rest on distinct statutory bases (departmental proceedings under Rule 14 versus conviction under Rule 8), so they are assessed separately
¶ 10No case law was cited in the judgment.
Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 168Section 420
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 Section 13
04Reasoning
The Tribunal first examined the applicant's central contention that the High Court's order of 08.08.2024 had stayed the conviction. It found that the operative order suspended only the execution of the sentence and did not touch the conviction, and that no order staying the conviction had been placed on record
¶ 12The conviction under Section 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) PC Act therefore subsisted and qualified as a finding of guilt under Rule 8
¶ 12The Tribunal further noted that the impugned order (06.08.2024) predated the suspension order (08.08.2024). On the date of the impugned order, the sentence had not been suspended, so the later suspension could not invalidate it
¶ 12On the personal hearing issue, the Tribunal observed that a show-cause memorandum had issued and a detailed representation had been filed and considered. Absent material showing a violation of the prescribed procedure or non-consideration of the defence, the lack of a separate personal hearing did not invalidate the order
¶ 9On double punishment, the Tribunal accepted that the earlier 10% penalty arose from separate departmental proceedings and the impugned penalty from the criminal conviction. Both affect pensionary benefits, but the two actions rest on distinct legal grounds and are not double punishment on that basis alone
¶ 10The Tribunal nonetheless required each action to be tested against its own statutory basis
¶ 10Applying that test, it held that the authority acted within jurisdiction, considered the representation (including the stay, double jeopardy, and financial hardship grounds), and reached a legally sustainable decision
¶ 11–12The Tribunal did not separately discuss proportionality beyond this.
05Holding
The Tribunal held that the conviction subsists notwithstanding suspension of sentence, that the impugned order dated 06.08.2024 was passed in accordance with law under Rule 8 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021, and that the absence of a personal hearing and the earlier 10% penalty did not invalidate it
¶ 9, 10, 12, 13The impugned order withholding 100% of monthly pension and the entire gratuity permanently was upheld
¶ 13–15The OA was dismissed without costs.
¶ 13–15The separate penalty order dated 25.09.2024 is the subject of O.A. No. 474/2024 and was not decided here
¶ 5.2Original Court PDF
Ashlesha MehtavsAll India Radio
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![Tribunal Upholds Permanent Withholding of Ex-AIR Employee's Pension and Gratuity Over Corruption Conviction, Says Sentence Suspension Doesn't Undo It. Ashlesha Mehta vs All India Radio. CAT - ['Ahmedabad']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/tribunal-upholds-permanent-withholding-of-ex-air-employee-s-pension-and-gratuity-over-corr-ab77d59715a64dedbbe864d0f9f3878c.webp)