Madhya Pradesh High CourtSocial Security and PensionsCivil Procedure and Evidence

Employee who voluntarily accepted the New Pension Scheme cannot later claim Old Pension Scheme benefits

Ghanshyam Kulmiv.The State Of Madhya Pradesh

Employee who voluntarily accepted the New Pension Scheme cannot later claim Old Pension Scheme benefits. Ghanshyam Kulmi vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh. Madhya Pradesh High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the appellant, appointed before 1 January 2005 and having opted for the pension scheme in 1995, is entitled to the benefit of the old pension scheme, despite his later appointments and his acceptance of the New Pension Scheme.

The court held

The appellant's pre-2005 project service did not count towards pension, his later contractual and probationary appointments were governed by the New Pension Scheme, and his voluntary acceptance of that scheme barred the claim to the old pension scheme.

It also directed

No illegality had been shown in the Single Judge's order, so no case warranted interference, and the Letters Patent appeal court declined to re-examine the concurrent findings of fact.

The appeal was dismissed, and the Single Judge's dismissal of W.P. No. 1226/2025 was affirmed.

01Facts

The appellant was temporarily appointed as Technical Assistant in an Operational Research Project at Sidhi on 15 July 1986.

¶ 2

The appellant was later transferred to the College of Agriculture, Mandsaur (1993) and engaged on contract as Training Organizer at Krishi Vigyan Kendra, Khargone on 11 August 2004 on a consolidated pay of Rs. 17,000.

¶ 2 · ¶ 9

The appellant was appointed Training Associate (Agronomy) on probation on 22 January 2007, on terms that placed him under the New Pension Scheme.

¶ 2 · ¶ 10

On 16 October 2010, as stated in the order at p.2, the appellant was appointed temporarily as Programme Coordinator by Rajmata Vijayaraje Scindia Krishi Vishwa Vidyalaya (RVSKVV), following the bifurcation of JNKVV.

¶ 2 · ¶ 6

On 19 January 1995 the appellant opted for the Pension and Gratuity Scheme and Contributory Provident Fund Scheme of JNKVV, and counsel conceded that this was not an option for the old pension scheme, as the new scheme had not yet been introduced.

¶ 3

JNKVV's order of 1 February 2007 made the defined-contribution scheme ("Paribhashit Anshdan Pension Pranali") applicable to employees appointed after 1 January 2005.

¶ 4

On retirement, the appellant was given New Pension Scheme benefits and not the Old Pension Scheme benefits.

¶ 5

The appellant filed W.P. No. 1226/2025, which the learned Single Judge dismissed on 24 December 2025.

¶ 1 · ¶ 5

The appellant then filed this writ appeal under Section 2(1) of the MP Uchcha Nyayalaya (Khand Nyaypeeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005.

¶ 1

02Issues

i.1. Whether the appellant, appointed before 1 January 2005 and having opted for the pension scheme in 1995, is entitled to the benefit of the old pension scheme, despite his later appointments and his acceptance of the New Pension Scheme.

¶ 5 · ¶ 8–12

ii.2. Whether the Letters Patent (writ) appeal court may re-examine the Single Judge's concurrent findings of fact on the nature of the appellant's service and his pension option.

¶ 14

03Law Applied

Section 2(1) of the MP Uchcha Nyayalaya (Khand Nyaypeeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 provides the statutory basis for the intra-court appeal.

¶ 1

Posts in ICAR-sponsored schemes are coterminous with the scheme and cannot be treated as permanent, so service in such posts does not count towards pensionary benefits, as laid down in Jawaharlal Nehru Krishi Vishwavidyalaya v. Bal Kishan Soni (1997) 5 SCC 86.

¶ 8

Contract engagements carry no pension or gratuity entitlement under the contractual terms of the appointment orders.

¶ 9

A voluntary, unprotested acceptance of the New Pension Scheme cannot later be challenged.

¶ 10–12

A Letters Patent Bench may interfere with a writ court's findings of fact only where they are demonstrably erroneous and the mistake is glaring on the face of the record, and cannot interfere merely because some error of fact or law is shown, as laid down in R. Saravanan v. Periyar University (SC, Civil Appeal arising from SLP (C) No. 4216 of 2020).

¶ 14

Provisions in the judgment · 1

M.P. Uchcha Nyayalaya (Khand Nyayapeeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 Section 2

04Reasoning

The appellant's 1986 project service was coterminous with ICAR-funded schemes and could not be counted for pension, following Bal Kishan Soni.

¶ 8

The 2004 contractual engagement expressly excluded pensionary benefits.

¶ 9

The 2007 appointment as Training Associate placed the appellant under the New Pension Scheme, which he accepted without demur and continued to accept until 2023. He also submitted a New Pension Scheme option showing 27 January 2007 as his date of appointment.

¶ 10–11

The Single Judge rejected the appellant's claim that these options were made under compulsion.

¶ 12

In the writ appeal, counsel could not identify any perversity in the Single Judge's order.

¶ 13

Applying Saravanan, the Division Bench held that the findings were not demonstrably erroneous and that no glaring illegality was shown, so there was no basis to interfere with the concurrent findings of fact.

¶ 14–15

05Holding

The appellant's pre-2005 project service did not count towards pension, his later contractual and probationary appointments were governed by the New Pension Scheme, and his voluntary acceptance of that scheme barred the claim to the old pension scheme.

¶ 8–13

No illegality had been shown in the Single Judge's order, so no case warranted interference, and the Letters Patent appeal court declined to re-examine the concurrent findings of fact.

¶ 14–15

The appeal was dismissed, and the Single Judge's dismissal of W.P. No. 1226/2025 was affirmed.

¶ 16
Madhya Pradesh High Court

Original Court PDF

Ghanshyam KulmivsThe State Of Madhya Pradesh

Madhya Pradesh High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment