CAT - ['Ahmedabad']Administrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Acquitted In CBI Case, Govt Employee Denied Legal Fee Reimbursement As Charges Were Not Linked To Official Duty

ASHLESHA MEHTAv.All India Radio

Acquitted In CBI Case, Govt Employee Denied Legal Fee Reimbursement As Charges Were Not Linked To Official Duty. ASHLESHA MEHTA vs All India Radio. CAT - ['Ahmedabad']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the communication dated 15.10.2019 confers upon the applicant a right to reimbursement of legal expenses incurred in defending Special CBI Case No. 06/2009.

The court held

The applicant is not entitled to reimbursement of legal expenses in Special CBI Case No. 06/2009. The communication dated 15.10.2019 confers no such right, and the proceedings did not arise from acts done in the discharge of official duties, so the OM dated 08.01.1959 does not apply.

It also directed

Reliefs (B) and (C) are refused, and the OA is dismissed as devoid of merit, with no order as to costs and pending MAs disposed of.

01Facts

The applicant, a permanent Transmission Executive with All India Radio (AIR), Ahmedabad, was prosecuted by the CBI on a complaint by the then Station Director, in Special CBI Case No. 06/2009.

¶ 2.2

She was acquitted on 04.05.2019.

¶ 2.2

By communication dated 15.10.2019, the Directorate General, AIR, advised that Travelling Allowance (TA) for attending the CBI cases could be granted only if the legal expenses were reimbursed in full or part by the Department, and that the periods of attendance were not to be treated as on duty.

¶ 7.2

The applicant submitted a claim of ₹14,50,000 for legal expenses directly to the Director General on 21.07.2020.

¶ 2.3 · ¶ 7.11

The respondents contend the claim never passed through proper official channels.

¶ 4.2 · ¶ 7.1

The respondents also rely on a separate case (Special Case No. 31/2009), arising from the same FIR, in which the applicant was convicted on 22.08.2023.

¶ 4.3 · ¶ 7.8

The CBI's appeal against the acquittal in Case No. 06/2009 is pending before the Gujarat High Court.

¶ 7.10

The applicant sought a declaration on non-payment and a direction to settle the claim under the Ministry of Home Affairs OM dated 08.01.1959 and Article 320(3)(d) of the Constitution.

¶ 1 · ¶ 2.4

02Issues

i.1. Whether the communication dated 15.10.2019 confers upon the applicant a right to reimbursement of legal expenses incurred in defending Special CBI Case No. 06/2009.

¶ 7, Point (i) · ¶ 7.2–7.5

ii.2. Whether the proceedings in Special CBI Case No. 06/2009 arose out of acts done by the applicant in the discharge of her official duties, bringing her claim within the MHA OM dated 08.01.1959.

¶ 7, Point (ii) · ¶ 7.6–7.7

03Law Applied

The governing framework is the MHA OM No. F-45/5/53-Ests.(A) dated 08.01.1959.

¶ 7.6

Paragraph 2(a) bars government assistance for defence in proceedings instituted by the State over matters arising out of or connected with official duties, permitting reimbursement only if the proceedings conclude in the employee's favour and the government is satisfied the employee was subjected to proceedings without proper justification.

¶ 7.6

Paragraph 2(b) bars assistance entirely for matters not connected with official duties, regardless of outcome.

¶ 7.6

Paragraph 4 requires that the act bear a real relation to official duties, not a "pretended or fanciful" claim.

¶ 7.6

Paragraph 5 vests the decision in the administrative Ministry, after consulting Finance and Law where necessary.

¶ 7.4, 7.6

Article 320(3)(d) of the Constitution applies only to costs of defending acts "done or purporting to be done in the execution of his duty".

¶ 7.9

No estoppel or legitimate expectation can arise against the governing instructions.

¶ 7.5

Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 168Section 420

Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 Section 13

04Reasoning

The 15.10.2019 communication is not a grant or assurance of legal expenses. Its subject is TA and duty treatment. Its language ("only if," "Otherwise, TA will not be granted") treats reimbursement as uncertain, and it refers to no amount.

¶ 7.3

The communication was advice to the Head of Office, not a decision under OM Para 5, and it cannot override the OM.

¶ 7.4–7.5

The nature of the allegations controls, not the outcome. The charges of private trade through a firm in another's name, cheating and pecuniary advantage by abuse of position are personal conduct, and the official position merely supplied the opportunity.

¶ 7.8

Such acts cannot be "pretended" as official duties under OM Para 4, so Para 2(b) applied, and the acquittal did not change the character of the proceedings.

¶ 7.8–7.9

Even under Para 2(a), the proceedings had not concluded in her favour, given the pending CBI appeal and the conviction in the connected case arising from the same complaint.

¶ 7.10

The Tribunal did not decide the representation's procedural defect, because the claim failed on merits. The consolidated, unitemised claim was also noted as a further deficiency.

¶ 7.1 · ¶ 7.11

05Holding

The applicant is not entitled to reimbursement of legal expenses in Special CBI Case No. 06/2009. The communication dated 15.10.2019 confers no such right, and the proceedings did not arise from acts done in the discharge of official duties, so the OM dated 08.01.1959 does not apply.

¶ 7.12–7.13

Reliefs (B) and (C) are refused, and the OA is dismissed as devoid of merit, with no order as to costs and pending MAs disposed of.

¶ 7.13 · ¶ 8–10
CAT - ['Ahmedabad']

Original Court PDF

ASHLESHA MEHTAvsAll India Radio

CAT - ['Ahmedabad'] · October 30, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment

Related judgments

Recent judgments that share this one’s subject or court. Hover a card to read what was held.

All Administrative and Public Law judgments →