01Facts
The applicant is the widow of Shri Bhaiju U. Solanki, a Gangman with Western Railway at Kanjari-Boriyavi Railway Station, who joined service on 26.11.1982.
¶ 2.1A charge-sheet dated 27.02.2006 under the Railway Servants (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1968, alleged unauthorised absence from 23.04.2003 to 31.12.2005.
¶ 2.2The Inquiry Officer's report dated 17.07.2008 held the charge proved, and the Disciplinary Authority imposed removal from service by order dated 17.11.2008.
¶ 2.2The employee's appeal, filed on 04.06.2013, was rejected on 05.02.2014. His revision was rejected on 13.03.2015.
¶ 2.3He died on 23.02.2016. The OA was filed on 21.08.2018 with M.A. No. 392/2018 seeking condonation of delay.
¶ 2.3The applicant contended that the inquiry was effectively ex parte, documents were not supplied, no defence assistant or cross-examination was allowed, absence was due to illness, a voluntary retirement request dated 15.02.2008 was ignored, and no Presenting Officer was appointed.
¶ 3, 3.1The respondents contended that notices were duly served, the employee did not attend, and the appellate and revisional authorities examined and upheld the penalty.
¶ 402Issues
i.1. Whether the delay in filing the OA deserves to be condoned.
¶ 7(i) · ¶ 8, 8.1ii.2. Whether, on merits, the penalty of removal and the appellate and revisional orders call for interference.
¶ 7(ii) · ¶ 9–9.1003Law Applied
Section 21 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, which requires an OA within one year of the final order.
¶ 8B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India (1995): the disciplinary and appellate authorities are the fact-finding authorities, courts do not reappreciate evidence, and interference is limited to procedural violations, findings based on no evidence, or perverse conclusions.
¶ 9.1State Bank of India v. Ajai Kumar Srivastava (2021): judicial review is confined to decision-making process, natural justice, statutory compliance, and evidentiary sufficiency at the level of "some evidence," and strict rules of evidence do not apply.
¶ 9.2State of Karnataka v. Umesh (2022).
¶ 9.3Union of India v. Subrata Nath (2022): interference with penalty is warranted only where it shocks the conscience.
¶ 9.4State Bank of Bikaner and Jaipur v. Nemi Chand Nalwaya and Union of India v. P. Gunasekaran (2015): the limited scope of review under Articles 226/227.
¶ 9.4Krushnakant B. Parmar v. Union of India (2012): unauthorised absence must be wilful and not caused by compelling circumstances.
¶ 9.7The applicant's authorities, Union of India v. Ram Lakhan Sharma and Satish Agnihotri v. Union of India, were distinguished.
¶ 3.1, 9.8Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19Section 21
04Reasoning
The cause of action arose on the revisional order of 13.03.2015, so the OA was due by March 2016 but was filed on 21.08.2018, about two years and five months late.
¶ 8The illness plea was rejected because the husband was alive for most of the limitation period, no medical record was produced, and no reason was given for the two-and-a-half-year delay after his death. The M.A. for condonation was therefore rejected.
¶ 8.1The employee was given five hearing dates and notices by registered post, to his permanent address, and by pasting, and he chose not to participate. A party who abstains cannot later complain of lack of documents, defence assistance or cross-examination.
¶ 9.6Distinguishing Krushnakant, the Tribunal noted the absence of any explanation or medical evidence and the absence of any showing that compelling circumstances prevented attendance.
¶ 9.7The fact of absence was admitted, and the evidence of the Station Superintendent and records only proved that admitted fact. Unlike Satish Agnihotri, the appellate and revisional authorities had considered the matter and given reasons.
¶ 9.8The voluntary retirement plea was unsubstantiated, as no copy of the request or any order was placed on record.
¶ 9.9On proportionality, removal for about two years and eight months of unauthorised absence was not found so disproportionate as to shock the conscience.
¶ 9.1005Holding
The delay was unexplained and not shown to be due to sufficient cause, so M.A. No. 392/2018 is rejected and the OA is barred by limitation.
¶ 8.1, 10Even on merits, the inquiry was conducted in accordance with natural justice, the finding of unauthorised absence was supported by admitted facts, and the penalty of removal was not disproportionate. The penalty order dated 17.11.2008, the appellate order dated 05.02.2014, and the revisional order dated 13.03.2015 are upheld.
¶ 10The OA is dismissed with no order as to costs, pending M.A.s are disposed of, and the prayer for release of retirement or death benefits (relief 8.2) fails.
¶ 10, 11, 12Original Court PDF
Kamlaben B SolankivsM/o Railways
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![Widow's Plea Against Gangman's Removal Fails: Tribunal Cites Delay of Over Two Years, Upholds Penalty. Kamlaben B Solanki vs M/o Railways. CAT - ['Ahmedabad']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/widow-s-plea-against-gangman-s-removal-fails-tribunal-cites-delay-of-over-two-years-uphold-6fe7be8571e24256bf4b4cd6087b0b6e.webp)