CAT - ['Ahmedabad']Employment and Labour LawAdministrative and Public Law

CAT Sets Aside Rejection of Financial Upgradation for Retired ITAT Driver Relying on Uncommunicated Adverse Entries

Vakhtaram S Solankiv.Income Tax Appellate Tribunal

CAT Sets Aside Rejection of Financial Upgradation for Retired ITAT Driver Relying on Uncommunicated Adverse Entries. Vakhtaram S Solanki vs Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. CAT - ['Ahmedabad']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether this Bench has territorial jurisdiction and whether the OA fails for non-joinder of a necessary party.

The court held

The Tribunal held that it has territorial jurisdiction, that the OA is not defective for non-joinder, and that it is not barred by limitation.

It also directed

The Tribunal held that the impugned order dated 09.02.2018 cannot be sustained because the adverse and integrity entries on which it relied were never communicated to the applicant.

The OA is partly allowed, with no order as to costs and no interest.

The Tribunal directed the respondents to communicate all adverse and below-benchmark entries, including integrity remarks, within four weeks.

The Tribunal directed the respondents to permit the applicant to represent within four weeks, with a reasoned decision by the competent authority within four further weeks.

The Tribunal directed the respondents to convene a review DPC within six weeks of that decision to consider ACP/MACP upgradation as on each due date.

The Tribunal directed that, if the applicant is found fit, his pay be fixed notionally from the due dates, his pension and retiral dues be revised, and arrears be paid limited as per para. 8.10 within two months of the review DPC's decision.

01Facts

The applicant served as a Staff Car Driver in the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), joining on 13.01.1982 and retiring on 31.12.2012. He received no regular promotion or financial upgradation during service.

¶ 2.1

On 28.08.2012, while in service, he sought benefits under the ACP/MACP Schemes. When no decision was taken, he filed O.A. No. 394/2013, which the Tribunal disposed of on 06.03.2017 by directing consideration of his claim and, if rejected, a reasoned order.

¶ 2.2

The respondents rejected the claim by order dated 09.02.2018 (Annexure A/1), relying on DPC proceedings from 2002 to 2012 and the DoPT OM dated 19.05.2009.

¶ 2.3

The respondents raised three preliminary objections: territorial jurisdiction (pension records showed a Rajasthan address), non-joinder of the last office, and limitation.

¶ 4

On merits, the respondents relied on adverse or average ACRs and integrity doubts recorded by various DPCs.

¶ 4.2–4.3

The applicant contended that these adverse entries were never communicated to him, and he put the respondents to strict proof.

¶ 2.3, 5

02Issues

i.1. Whether this Bench has territorial jurisdiction and whether the OA fails for non-joinder of a necessary party.

¶ 7(i) · ¶ 8–8.1

ii.2. Whether the OA is barred by limitation.

¶ 7(ii) · ¶ 8.2

iii.3. Whether the impugned order rejecting the ACP/MACP claim is sustainable when the adverse entries relied upon were not communicated to the applicant.

¶ 7(iii) · ¶ 8.4–8.6

iv.4. To what relief, if any, the applicant is entitled.

¶ 7(iv) · ¶ 8.7–8.10, 9

03Law Applied

Rule 6(1) and (2) of the Central Administrative Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 1987, which permit filing before the Bench where the applicant is posted or where the cause of action arose, or, for retired persons, where he ordinarily resides at the time of filing.

¶ 8

Section 21 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 prescribes the one-year limitation period.

¶ 8.2

Union of India v. M.K. Sarkar, (2010) 2 SCC 59: a direction to consider a stale claim does not revive limitation, but this principle does not apply where the claim was live and was decided on merits under a court direction.

¶ 8.2

Under the ACP and MACP Schemes, notified by the DoPT OM dated 19.05.2009, upgradation is not automatic and is subject to fitness and benchmarks.

¶ 8.3

Dev Dutt v. Union of India, (2008) 8 SCC 725, affirmed in Sukhdev Singh v. Union of India, (2013) 9 SCC 566: every adverse ACR entry must be communicated within a reasonable time, and an uncommunicated entry cannot be used against the employee in promotion matters.

¶ 8.5

The DoPT OM dated 13.04.2010 is to the same effect as the principle in Dev Dutt and Sukhdev Singh.

¶ 8.5

Union of India v. Tarsem Singh, (2008) 8 SCC 648, limits arrears in recurring pay-fixation claims to three years before the filing of proceedings.

¶ 8.10

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19Section 21

04Reasoning

On jurisdiction, the Tribunal held that a Pension Payment Order records only the address furnished for pension purposes and does not establish ordinary residence at the time of filing. Because the applicant gave an Ahmedabad address in the OA and the respondents produced no contrary material, he validly exercised the Rule 6(2) option.

¶ 8

The non-joinder objection failed because the ITAT, which passed the impugned order, was already a respondent and could give the relief sought.

¶ 8.1

On limitation, the claim was raised while the applicant was in service, was pursued through O.A. No. 394/2013, and was decided on merits under the Tribunal's direction. It was therefore not stale, and the OA, filed within one year of the impugned order, was within Section 21.

¶ 8.2

On merits, the Tribunal noted that most cited DPCs were held for confirmation or promotion rather than screening under the ACP/MACP Schemes, and nothing showed that a Screening Committee had examined the applicant.

¶ 8.4

The respondents held the service records but produced no communication, endorsement, or acknowledgment of the adverse entries, so the Tribunal held that they were not communicated.

¶ 8.6

Applying Dev Dutt and Sukhdev Singh, those entries could not be used to deny upgradation, and the impugned order, which rested substantially on them, could not stand.

¶ 8.5–8.6

The educational-qualification remark from the 2009–2010 DPC did not save the order, because the order did not examine whether that qualification is a scheme condition and the order rested on the DPCs taken together.

¶ 8.7

Since fitness is for the competent authority, the Tribunal directed a structured procedure instead of deciding fitness itself.

¶ 8.8

Interest at 12% was refused because entitlement was yet to be determined.

¶ 8.9

Under Tarsem Singh, arrears were confined to three years before the filing of O.A. No. 394/2013, with notional fixation from the due dates.

¶ 8.10

05Holding

The Tribunal held that it has territorial jurisdiction, that the OA is not defective for non-joinder, and that it is not barred by limitation.

¶ 8, 8.1, 8.2

The Tribunal held that the impugned order dated 09.02.2018 cannot be sustained because the adverse and integrity entries on which it relied were never communicated to the applicant.

¶ 8.6, 9(i)

The OA is partly allowed, with no order as to costs and no interest.

¶ 8.9, 10–11

The Tribunal directed the respondents to communicate all adverse and below-benchmark entries, including integrity remarks, within four weeks.

¶ 9(ii)

The Tribunal directed the respondents to permit the applicant to represent within four weeks, with a reasoned decision by the competent authority within four further weeks.

¶ 9(iii)

The Tribunal directed the respondents to convene a review DPC within six weeks of that decision to consider ACP/MACP upgradation as on each due date.

¶ 9(iv)

The Tribunal directed that, if the applicant is found fit, his pay be fixed notionally from the due dates, his pension and retiral dues be revised, and arrears be paid limited as per para. 8.10 within two months of the review DPC's decision.

¶ 9(v)
CAT - ['Ahmedabad']

Original Court PDF

Vakhtaram S SolankivsIncome Tax Appellate Tribunal

CAT - ['Ahmedabad'] · October 30, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment